Super Smash Bros. Mafia! GAME OVER!!

[mothrax]

Dana, I don't like that post at all. "everyone stop looking at your own suspects and look only at these two people." when we get closer to deadline, I will agree with this, but now, no.

[singersigner]

wow good job singer. Let me read through the thread and say that my suspects are the two people that have the most lynch votes. I think I'll lynch the one with most. So MY behavior is scummy, but HER'S isnt? Also, the MPR wagon doesnt really impress me. Its more like Gollum trying to get someone lynched after he dies, I honestly think bunny lover is a safer lynch.

Cute. In case you didn't read my post thoroughly (with this reaction, I'm assuming you didn't), I said I'd delve into when I had more time to put my thoughts together. Why don't

you

try replacing into a 33-page THEMED game, and see how much it makes

your

head hurt.

And yes, I'm hopping on a wagon

for now

because at this point, it's fruitless effort to try to look at anyone else with the amount of time I/the rest of us have. I'll see what my gut tells me after this next lynch. Sorry it has to be you, oh emotional one, though that reaction doesn't exactly make you look any less scummy.

Manho...ok, I get the "not in the mood to read the rest of the thread" part...but why fate?

[SharkFinn]

BTW, can we just lynch mongoose already. I know he's scum, you all know he's scum, so can we just end these fruitful efforts to stop this wagon?

[danakillsu]

@ mothrax
I'm not telling anyone they HAVE to do it or dire consequences will ensue. Just saying we could keep a bunch of useless discussion from being a part of this thread if everyone would vote for one of the two. And does it saying anything that the ones who support a mongoose lynch are the ones who have been more active lately?

[tanstalas]

And yes, I'm hopping on a wagon

for now

because at this point, it's fruitless effort to try to look at anyone else with the amount of time I/the rest of us have. I'll see what my gut tells me after this next lynch. Sorry it has to be you, oh emotional one, though that reaction doesn't exactly make you look any less scummy.

I will say though, that just hopping on a wagon without reading the post just seems like a scummy thing to do, replacing into a game and being scum people usually look at the last vote count and then tunnel onto the person with the most amount of votes (unless that person is your scum-buddy).

You also contradicted yourself in the above post from your first post.

Oof, hey y'all. This is my first large theme game, so

bare with me here while I catch up and

understand

everything that's going on

.

I'll start reading the thread now, and will try to hurry it up.

I might post intermittent thoughts with EBWOPS, but most likely

will wait til I'm done and give a brief synopsis from there

(though if it's anything like replacing in newbie games, you might like updates as to how far along I am?). Thanks for your patience!

You ask for us to be patient with you while you catch up, that post was on FRIDAY, on Wednesday you stated that you were still trying to sift through the thread that is 39 pages long. You do realize that when you jumped in the thread was only 32 pages..

Also the fact that you have had FIVE days to read the thread and are still saying you have not caught up seems strange to me. You must be the slowest reader ever. More likely I am thinking you are scum. You know who is scum and you know who is town. I think MPR is your scum-buddy and you don't want to vote your buddy off the island so you went with the mongoose BW because you know he is town (or at the very least not on YOUR mafia team)

it's fruitless effort to try to look at anyone else with the amount of time I/the rest of us have.

The above quote also pisses me off. I disagree with you VERY much on this, in fact when someone replaces into a game I look forward to their analysis as they have just read the entire thread and everything is still fresh in their minds, and also may have picked up on a tell that we all missed/never noticed depending on who has been lynched/NK'd up until this point. And really not sure why you said useless with amount of time we/you have? We have until SEPTEMBER 9th to make a lynch, that is PLENTY of time.

Bottom line: You have been here for over 5 days since your first post and have said nothing except fluff. I don't believe "lurkers" should necessarily be lynched - however I do think active lurkers are another matter

Mega FOS: singersinger

I'd vote for you instead of the FOS - however we do not need a 3rd BW forming ATM - as I am sure MPR will flip scum anyhow.

[Fate]

@ Fate
He decided to vote along with you, so the issue is resolved. Unless you try to do something similar or many others vote for you, me voting for you would be useless.

How is the issue resolved? I coerced him into voting someone I wanted to, and that was what you said was scummy about me.

But you're not wiling to push my lynch just because there isn't enough support out there?

Some obvtown you are.

[Fate]

Good posting tanstalas, scum hate catching up and posting content.

The fact she voted Mongoose just makes me more sure of that slot being town.

[SharkFinn]

Good post tanstalas. Read into I doubt it/singsigner and based on the total of 6 posts they made combined, I think singsigner is scum. I doubt it was definitely bandwagoning and did so without much content, although it appears so.

Mongoose and singsigner are unaligned scum imo, but both scum.

Prediction: Mongoose Villain, singsigner Traitor. (Gollum probably bussed Mongoose before he died)

[danakillsu]

@ Fate
He decided to vote along with you, so the issue is resolved. Unless you try to do something similar or many others vote for you, me voting for you would be useless.

How is the issue resolved? I coerced him into voting someone I wanted to, and that was what you said was scummy about me.

But you're not wiling to push my lynch just because there isn't enough support out there?

Some obvtown you are.

Wow. Nice (apparently intentional) misrep you've got there. One scumtell isn't enough to make me vote for you instead of mongoose. The issue is resolved in that I don't have to vote for you to try to get you to not do it any MORE. And as I said, even if I thought you were a little scummier than mongoose, I wouldn't bother voting for you, because nobody else is, and mongoose looks like he might be lynched today, which is something I want to happen.

[singersigner]

You ask for us to be patient with you while you catch up, that post was on FRIDAY, on Wednesday you stated that you were still trying to sift through the thread that is 39 pages long. You do realize that when you jumped in the thread was only 32 pages..

First of all, "only" 32 pages is a lot.
Second of all, you're right, I did ask you to be patient. I had agreed to replace into the game only just before I lost a very dear member of my family. So yes, I did ask you to be patient with me so as to not need to ask for a replacement myself. No this is not AtE, and I do not expect you to "forgive me" if you've already decided it sounds scummy. Just hoping you'll understand that other people actually have lives.
Third of all, you shouldn't depend so much on replacements to catch slips that you missed. Are you that ignorant? Or are you just hoping that your mistakes will go unnoticed?

And your FoS is intersting. You say we shouldn't have another bandwagon start, and yet you're asking me to start one since we've apparently got SO MUCH TIME. I gave you my vote, and I also gave you a time frame of when I will be able to justify that vote. Chill.

[danakillsu]

^^ This
Really haven't been liking tanstalas' playstyle, although deciding whether it is actually scummy is a different matter altogether.

[Fate]

This what. Why do you feel the need to defend singer when she isn't in danger of being lynched?

If she doesn't deliver she'll get noose. There's no reason for you to point that out.

[Fate]

@ Fate
He decided to vote along with you, so the issue is resolved. Unless you try to do something similar or many others vote for you, me voting for you would be useless.

How is the issue resolved? I coerced him into voting someone I wanted to, and that was what you said was scummy about me.

But you're not wiling to push my lynch just because there isn't enough support out there?

Some obvtown you are.

Wow. Nice (apparently intentional) misrep you've got there. One scumtell isn't enough to make me vote for you instead of mongoose. The issue is resolved in that I don't have to vote for you to try to get you to not do it any MORE. And as I said, even if I thought you were a little scummier than mongoose, I wouldn't bother voting for you, because nobody else is, and mongoose looks like he might be lynched today, which is something I want to happen.

So since I've committed "one scumtell" and you seem capable of recognizing what scumtells are, are you going to elaborate on your mongoose case and your reasoning for voting him that has been questioned by someone?

It would really help push the mongoose wagon if you were town and thought he was scum.

But that's not what it is, is it?

[Kirbyoshi]

The singer-FoS wagon is terrible. We have plenty of time. I'm not sure we'll need it, but we should still take most of it. I actually like Dana's idea of everyone who is active voting for either MPR or mongoose, until your chosen is at L-1, then you can spread them out. Tans looks scum, but I think he's a sheep in wolf's clothing. Fate/Dana need to stop going TvT on us and start actually scumhunting.

[singersigner]

What's TvT?

[Bunnylover]

Town v.s. Town I believe.

[Kirbyoshi]

Yesh, it's Town vs. Town. It's used when there's a possibility (or belief) that a town member is arguing with another town member uselessly. Variations are TvS, SvS, and rarely TvI and SvI, where S=Scum, and I=Indy.

[singersigner]

Ok, so in regards to mongoose...of 24 total posts, 4 are questioning why people think he's scummy, 3 are telling people to stopping lynching him, 2 are "surprise" he didn't get killed the previous night (why did you think you were going to get NKed in the first place?), and there were a couple intermittent AtEs/one-line "scum-hunting" arguments. He also vote-hopped several times, with not much explanation, nor any notion to give any sort of explanation later.

[mongoose]

well, If you were in my situation, you would be surprised at surviving the night too. Actually, I believe both Fate and NAcho were being questioned on why they didn't kill me. Also, most people dont exactly give reasons for their votes on me, which is extremely annoying and tends to be a scum tell. I'm not saying that everyone voting for me is scum, but it seems like quite a few of them are. And also, how can you defend yourself if you dont know what to argue against? Its like when your mom says, "Because I said so." My response tends to be (in my head), "Great, so what if you say so?" I think telling people to not lynch me is also perfectly reasonable, when you are 3 votes from getting lynched.

[Framm 18]

well, If you were in my situation, you would be surprised at surviving the night too. Actually, I believe both Fate and NAcho were being questioned on why they didn't kill me. Also, most people dont exactly give reasons for their votes on me, which is extremely annoying and tends to be a scum tell. I'm not saying that everyone voting for me is scum, but it seems like quite a few of them are. And also, how can you defend yourself if you dont know what to argue against? Its like when your mom says, "Because I said so." My response tends to be (in my head), "Great, so what if you say so?" I think telling people to not lynch me is also perfectly reasonable, when you are 3 votes from getting lynched.

If you want to defend yoursef and no one is giving reasons, then go on the offensive and try and start scumhunting or something other than just saying I can't defend because no one is giving me anything to defend against. That doesn't help your cause and actually weakens your case.

As for my reasonings for initially voting for you, was
1) I was wanting to try and get something out of someone, since VEZOK was not talking, and you at the moment seemed to be the most suspicious.
2) Either you really are a beginner and really not sure what to do, or you are scum trying to play the newbie card in hopes that it would pay off for you. Your posts really haven't done much other than trying to guilt us into not voting for you, in my opinion anyways.

I would love to hear more from some players other (Me included) than the 5-6 that are consistently posting. Odd thing is that I do think that at least one of those 5-6 people talking are scum. Just can't quite put my finger on which one at the moment. It is hard to find scum when no one talks.

[mongoose]

tbh this is my first game on the site, and on the other site we play it differently, and we can talk outside of the thread.
And as I have said a bit earlier, I think signersigner and bunny lover are scum right now. I'm not very good at scum hunting either, but tanstalas mostly covered the case. Bunnylover not so much since he doesn't seem as malicious, but still is suspicious from his earlier posts.

[Fate]

Ok, so in regards to mongoose...of 24 total posts, 4 are questioning why people think he's scummy, 3 are telling people to stopping lynching him, 2 are "surprise" he didn't get killed the previous night (why did you think you were going to get NKed in the first place?), and there were a couple intermittent AtEs/one-line "scum-hunting" arguments. He also vote-hopped several times, with not much explanation, nor any notion to give any sort of explanation later.

^LOL IS THIS SUPPOSED TO BE CONTENT?

Catchup post. You have until 1 day before the deadline.

I promise you you

WILL

be lynched if you fail to deliver.

[manho]

iso'ed mongoose, bunnylover, singersigner. mongoose is town, bunnylover is scum, and singersigner is neutral to scum.

EDIT: forgot to iso MPR, will read soon.

[manho]

i'll leave my vote on MPR for now. i really can't read him.

[SharkFinn]

How is mongoose town???????