Ladies Night -- Game Over

[DrippingGoofball]

OK cepi is town.

Even though two of her choices were on the Paws wagon?

That doesn't make her less of a shining beacon of wholesome, bloodlusting townieness.

[camn]

.....
DO you have a vote restriction?

[Haylen]

I can't Day Talk. Ok?

[DrippingGoofball]

I just iso'd Apokalyptyka. Not really feeling the scum vibes here.

[DrippingGoofball]

camn is town, cepi is town, so next is chauchau. Not seeing much scum here, either. She's kinda antagonizing a whole slew of players, which isn't something scum would do.

[DrippingGoofball]

I iso'd Haylen and scanned - lots of fluff.

The signal to noise ratio is about as unfavorable as the towntell/noise ratio. Mmmmm.

[cepi]

Just her first serious post of the game is a bunch of scumtells.

Ok, this is interesting.

I'm not sure what Hoopla's trying to do here; on the one hand I doubt that scum would give themselves such a high profile so early, but on the other hand her behavior doesn't scream town.

I fail to see whether it matters if Hoopla cares about me as a player or not, but

for the record: I played a couple of newbie games a while ago that I'm too lazy to go back and look up, and I don't know that I have a playstyle or anything to offer the town other than trying to win using my best reasoning.

I admit that my opinion of Hoopla may be skewed negatively due to the dismissive attitude that she's currently taking with the few players that haven't met her high standards. In addition, I personally dislike when RL emotions and the intentional triggering of same get involved in Mafia games,

and Hoopla seems to be trying to piss as many people off as possible. It may possibly be a tactic to motivate discussion, but it seems more likely to cloud logical reasoning with emotion and thus give scum more room to maneuver.

Also, newest Hoopla post came up as I was about to post. Now I'm definitely feeling padding; either try to bring the game out of random stage or don't. I think I'm currently justified in casting a

vote: Hoopla

.

Apokalyptika scumbag really didn't know how to start this post without sounding too scummy.

Whishy Washy about Hoopla. Also she takes into account the possibility that Hoopla may be town but only looks for the bad reason to vote for her. TLDR: Voting people for nulltells.

My playstyle? How about you don't know how to catch me if I don't play to my town meta?

[cepi]

More than the others?

I mean.. I agree, and want Apok to hang... but a competing vote?

Morea than the others, yeah.

Competing votes are good stuff. Day has just started.

[cepi]

I can't Day Talk. Ok?

Who is scum and why? Now.

[DrippingGoofball]

I'd like to refer everyone to this Ojanen post:

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 6#p2463356

Ojanen didn't get NK'd, so clearly, has some inaccurate scum/town reads, but she's a genius.

[Hoopla]

I'd like to refer everyone to this Ojanen post:

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 6#p2463356

Ojanen didn't get NK'd, so clearly, has some inaccurate scum/town reads, but she's a genius.

Why don't you consider the possibility that she's scum? She's off the D1 Paws wagon.

[DrippingGoofball]

Esurio was pretty gung-ho about an Apolytptyka lynch:

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 0#p2459060

[DrippingGoofball]

Why don't you consider the possibility that she's scum? She's off the D1 Paws wagon.

There is a lot of intelligence in her reads. Plus I'm not finished iso'ing players.

[Haylen]

I can't Day Talk. Ok?

Who is scum and why? Now.

I said this just now. camn for her post before and camn for yesterday.

[DrippingGoofball]

THIS

is wrong on many levels.

Ah, it was not nice to not wait me before lynching. I still want camn love, but I'm also interested in how the Paws wagon build so fast. Specially fenchurch's hammer vote.

I am leery of FOS's. Especially the one below:

Wow, I iso'd Paws and I must say that there's nothing there. Nine posts of pure nothingness. Seems like someone is active lurking, and let's add the benching, and we have something worthy here.

FoS: Paws

[Haylen]

While im at it.

FoS Cepi

Obv not reading the thread properly. Since I voted camn the page before this one.

[Hoopla]

Why don't you consider the possibility that she's scum? She's off the D1 Paws wagon.

There is a lot of intelligence in her reads. Plus I'm not finished iso'ing players.

Yeah, but intelligence doesn't equate with alignment - I'd be very worried if you let Ojanen off the hook purely for intelligent reads, especially when she's in the pool of 6 players you're keen to lynch from. You've given your alignment assessments on other players without finishing your iso - make a decision on Ojanen.

[DrippingGoofball]

Sucrose: meh. Need moar.
UKitten is town.

SCUMLIST:

Apok (for reasons that needed 'splainin but I see it now)
Sotty (for tentative, scaredy-cat language), ODD scumreads, and OFF the Paws wagon safely on a peripheral wagon that wasn't going anywhere.
Snow_Bunny - as the lesser evil here.

[Hoopla]

Sotty (for tentative, scaredy-cat language), ODD scumreads,

and OFF the Paws wagon safely on a peripheral wagon that wasn't going anywhere.

Not really, though...

Come on DGB, I know you're better than this.

[cepi]

I can't Day Talk. Ok?

Who is scum and why? Now.

I said this just now. camn for her post before and camn for yesterday.

No additional suspects?

[UncertainKitten]

Off wagon is Sucrose and possibly Snow_Bunny. I don't have a good bead on Snow_Bunny, to be honest, since as I remember she tends to play...um...like this.

I should probably cross reference Umineko mafia and this game.

To be fair, I also have to review Sucrose a bit, but I'm not entirely sure she's acting as dumb as she was trying to lead me to believe, and the names out of a hat trick she pulled earlier was scummy no matter how much potential stupidity could explain it.

[Hoopla]

UK; thoughts on DGB and camn?

[UncertainKitten]

Ah, sorry,

Vote Sucrose

I should have done that in the last post.

Cut by Hoopla: DGB is interesting. Not entirely sure what to make of her. I rarely am. I'm not entirely sure I've often seen this barrage of "X is town" from DGB before whatsoever.

camn said some interesting things that lead me to believe she's just irritating, not necessarily scum.

[DrippingGoofball]

Sotty (for tentative, scaredy-cat language), ODD scumreads,

and OFF the Paws wagon safely on a peripheral wagon that wasn't going anywhere.

Not really, though...

Come on DGB, I know you're better than this.

I meant, OFF scumreads, not ODD scumreads.

I don't like your 'tude, Miss Hoopla.

[UncertainKitten]

Oh, hey, also of note, she never did answer my riposte about how absolutely TERRIBLE her single game sample size was of the prevalence of angriness.