Mini 1034 - Castlevania Mafia (Game Over)

[Katsuki]

Skimmed response. My one issue with it is that it seems that the majority of your arguments were drawn from another game/s.

I will comment later when I have time to read post in depth.

[UncertainKitten]

Gonna note that while I'm most active post wise I've still not contributed much in the way of opinions because you all have been tied up in this tans business. There hasn't been anything to GO off of. All I have right now is Dekes town, tans town, and POSSIBLY zwet scum, but no real reason to believe that per se.

[Katsuki]

I would agree with dekes town, but my gut says opposite on zwet and tans.

[tanstalas]

And this time - Dekes - I do want an answer of who you will be going after tomorrow if I get lynched and when I flip town. Want to know this before you get to have your quickchat with your scum buddies and decide who to go after tomorrow. Would also like to hear this from everyone else on my wagon. If you are town, I see no reason why you cannot speculate on who your 2nd most scummy person if. Unless you do not want to offend another townie, and have them look into your posts more carefully?

[LimMePls]

If I have to ability claim - I have no problem with it, if my BW gets bigger I will, in fact I still have an ace up my sleeve that should pretty much guarantee me being obv-town, however there are some "issues" with it - however I am very valuable to the town, and I will not myself be lynched. Trust me, I will not by lynched today.

Then why are you behaving the way you are? It makes absolutely NO SENSE!

[Dekes]

And this time - Dekes - I do want an answer of who you will be going after tomorrow if I get lynched and when I flip town. Want to know this before you get to have your quickchat with your scum buddies and decide who to go after tomorrow.

So, now I'm definite scum, although last time I checked I was #4 on your scum list? Because I made a case against you? Great stuff.

I will answer to your last post tomorrow and to your question here, too. But it's 2 A.M. over here and I had to made another post first.
Just wanted to get another question out quickly:

@everyone
What do you think of tanstalas rushed L-3 not-in-danger-of-about-to-being-lynched nameclaim plus PR-softclaim?

[tanstalas]

@mod

- Am I allowed to post the question I asked you about my ability and your response? (paraphrased of course)

[UncertainKitten]

@Dekes: Newb town thinking he'd get clever by softclaiming his PR. The entire "gambit" reeks of inexperience, not scumminess. How does it benefit him to nameclaim/softclaim a PR as scum so early?

[tanstalas]

And this time - Dekes - I do want an answer of who you will be going after tomorrow if I get lynched and when I flip town. Want to know this before you get to have your quickchat with your scum buddies and decide who to go after tomorrow.

So, now I'm definite scum, although last time I checked I was #4 on your scum list? Because I made a case against you? Great stuff.

I will answer to your last post tomorrow and to your question here, too. But it's 2 A.M. over here and I had to made another post first.
Just wanted to get another question out quickly:

@everyone
What do you think of tanstalas rushed L-3 not-in-danger-of-about-to-being-lynched nameclaim plus PR-softclaim?

Actually "Last time you checked" - which was also your last post - you were #3 on my list

My top 3 picks (in order)
1)LMP
2)Katsuki
3)Dekes

Short memory? You should eat more fish, I hear it is brain food, might help you

[Dekes]

And after that you voted Zwet so he surely must've climbed up your list to the top. Correct me if I'm wrong but that would make me #4.

[tanstalas]

And after that you voted Zwet so he surely must've climbed up your list to the top. Correct me if I'm wrong but that would make me #4.

No, that would make Zwet #4. I truly do think you three are the most scummy. However I also think Zwet is as well. I placed my vote on Zwet because he already had votes on him, so there would be more pressure, rather than me try to start a BW on one of my top 3 suspects who currently have no votes on them. As well, a few people seem to think you, kat and LMP are town. So maybe they see something that I do not see. I never said I was an expert at playing mafia. I think you 4 are scum. Other people in this game disagree with me but we all agree on Zwet, hence that is why my vote is on him.

[zwetschenwasser]

Based on this^ I'm starting to buy UK's insistence on tans' inexperience.

[LimMePls]

Based on this^ I'm starting to buy UK's insistence on tans' inexperience.

I've gotta say, I'm starting to agree. But inexperience != town.

[UncertainKitten]

The fact it took you 10 pages to see that kinda says a lot.

Now, I do realized newbs still can be scum, and the RNG doesn't discriminate, but he's pretty consistently, to me at least, looked like town failing to help the town a lot, and trying desperately to do so. Word choice and the like implies it.

@LMP: But, knowing he's inexperienced, what makes him scum? Can you list it off?

[zwetschenwasser]

anyway, to tans, usually when someone screams out their scumminess to you, you make your case as to why that person is so much scummier than the others on your list, and if noone buys it, THEN consider joining the bandwagons. well, at least that's the protown thing to do. from another player I would find your post VERY scummy.

[tanstalas]

anyway, to tans,

usually when someone screams out their scumminess to you, you make your case as to why that person is so much scummier than the others on your list

,

and if noone buys it

,

THEN consider joining the bandwagons

. well, at least that's the protown thing to do. from another player I would find your post VERY scummy.

I'm not following?

I had attempted to make cases on people I have suspected, and voted

Case in point: http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 2#p2474762 and I also made cases on Katsuki and Dekes

Noone bought it

- and in fact, other people said they had pro-town vibes on my top 3 suspects

I then joined your bandwagon (with reasoning as well)

So I fail to see how from another player you find my post very scummy? Maybe I am missing something, feel free to explain

[zwetschenwasser]

then push push push!

[Kdub]

Vote Count

LynchMePls (0)

-

drmyshottyizsik (0)

-

jenniwren (0)

-

UncertainKitten (1)

- McGriddle

MehPlusRawr (0)

-

Katsuki (0)

-

Dekes (0)

-

Coach Travis (1)

- jenniwren

zwetschenwasser (4)

- UncertainKitten, Coach Travis, VasudeVa, tanstalas

McGriddle (0)

-

VasudeVa (0)

-

tanstalas (4)

- zwetschenwasser, LynchMePls, Dekes, Katsuki

No Lynch (0)

-

Not Voting (2)

- drmyshottyizsik, MehPlusRawr

12 votes available, 7 votes needed to lynch.

Deadline is September 16, ~ 9 am PDT.

[zwetschenwasser]

CMON GUYS LYNCH ME QUICK

[UncertainKitten]

Now zwet, you should know I'm...relaxed, as it were. And I like to take it easy. No need to rush your lynch when we have 10 pages of chaff to ignore ^-^.

[Katsuki]

Didn't get time today to make proper post. Will get to UK's post on tans claim.

Meanwhile, jenniwen, MPR and McGriddle are lurking quite happily.

[VasudeVa]

Hey zwet, why are you acting like you are?

[jenniwren]

I didn't mean to lurk...my computer went into the shop Friday night and I've had to fight my dad for computer time on his (he's been raiding on WoW this weekend). I had gotten behind on this thread, and I need to do a reread to catch up and write something up. I will try to get more posted tonight, but I am traveling Tuesday, so today will be a busy day all in all.

My initial thoughts, though, are that Zwet had too much fun tormenting Tans with his "irrelevants," as every time he says that (or something equally dismissive), it makes Tans dance a little faster. (Naughty Zwet!)

Tans really wants to prove he's town...and though I disagree with some of his reasons to accuse people (For instance, the whole thing about Kat's posting after a trip thing? That was bad.), I am not certain he is scum. I also think it would be easy for more experienced scum to exploit his desperation. I'm still trying to feel people out and wade through this entire discussion; one thing I've seen in mafia is that hasty conclusions usually end up causing problems. Anyway, I'll post more later.

[zwetschenwasser]

Hey zwet, why are you acting like you are?

read my completed games. I'm CRRAAAAAIZYY!

[McGriddle]

Didn't get time today to make proper post. Will get to UK's post on tans claim.

Meanwhile, jenniwen, MPR and McGriddle are lurking quite happily.

As you know I am not posting much in the other game I am not mentioning. I am not lurking. I am busy. Plus there isn't much going on for me to chime in. I don't necessarily understand the cases and I am unintrigued by anyones statements thus far.