Mafia on Holy Orders (Game Over!)

[Socrates]

Hey Plum, I hereby pledge my vote to you for the remainder of the game day. Whoever you want me to vote, I will vote, no questions asked.

So, who do you want me to vote?

[Plum]

Pacman.

[Socrates]

Top three scum:

Sebguer: argues his Furc vote with a healthy swab of uhhh, I forget the word, changing his argument to better fit his desired conclusions, rather than drawing conclusions from his arguments, as previously covered.

Friend: In addition to the dissonance that I went into when I was talking with Iec during day 1, he also antagonized Plum and refused to go along with her request on the grounds that she "Might be scum", with no consideration of whether or not the request was a good one. I don't know if that is actually a scum tell, but I want it to be one.

Furcolow: His actions around the end of the Wraith wagon are just plain weird and at least make coherent sense if he was scum not wanting to take responsibility for hammering a townie but wanting the day to end.

unvote, Vote: pacman

[Friend]

That's not why I didn't fulfill plums request, Soc.

[Socrates]

I don't feel like conforming to your shit especially when I'm not so sure of your townieness.

Lies.

[Friend]

especially =/= because

[zwetschenwasser]

yo socrates, furcolow is playing perfectly to meta. I have a nullread on him at the moment.

[Socrates]

especially =/= because

Your pendantry amuses me.

[Socrates]

especially =/= because

Your pedantry amuses me.

[zwetschenwasser]

HAHAhA

[Friend]

It's not pedantry. It's more like "I don't want to do what you say because I feel it's not going to be very helpful. Another reason I don't want to do it is because I'm not sure you're town and don't like your attitude towards leading the town around."

[Socrates]

Well, first of all, its the fact that you put the reason forward at all that gets my hackles up. If I wasn't deliberately constraining myself, I would call it a

true

example of the word I misspelled on my list. Discrediting someones arguments by saying they might be scum is flat out irrational.

Second of all, you haven't given any other coherent reasons for you stance than that one. "I feel it's not going to be very helpful." barely counts as a reason because you give no elaboration on why you feel that way, and you are only just now saying that.

The word is actually not entirely appropriate anyway, but it would be pedantic for me to point that out. It gets the point across.

[zwetschenwasser]

Well, first of all, its the fact that you put the reason forward at all that gets my hackles up. If I wasn't deliberately constraining myself, I would call it a

true

example of the word I misspelled on my list. Discrediting someones arguments by saying they might be scum is flat out irrational.

actually, that's furcolow's playstyle.

[Furcolow]

i don't distance myself from wagons
i hammer as a townie when i think someone is scum
i will bus my team as scum
youre off on me, socrates
i thought your case would be better than that, considering that it is entirely wrong

[AGar]

i don't distance myself from wagons
i hammer as a townie when i think someone is scum
i will bus my team as scum
youre off on me, socrates
i thought your case would be better than that, considering that it is entirely wrong

lolWIFOM.

Why exactly are we waggoning M=W blindly again?

[Furcolow]

whatever
wifom is null
and im being honest
what more can you ask for, judge?

i would be willing to switch my vote to mothrax

[Me=Weird]

Why exactly are we waggoning M=W blindly again?

That's what I'm trying to figure out.

[AGar]

WIFOM is null. I was just laughing at it.

I honestly think you're town atm. Don't start flailing yet.

Why would you be willing to switch to mothrax?

[zwetschenwasser]

whatever
wifom is null

incorrect. Arguing something based on wifom is scummy.

[Friend]

Yeah, whatever Soc.

M=W is scummy cause he's pressing for VItown lynches. AKA "easy targets."

[AGar]

whatever
wifom is null

incorrect. Arguing something based on wifom is scummy.

This is where I disagree. Several players have hammered the "WIFOM argument = scum" tell around the site, and I couldn't disagree more.

Using WIFOM as an argument is a null-tell. It just means the argument itself is incorrect. It isn't indicative of alignment. Now, if you can see a reason that it would be beneficial to a scum motivation to use WIFOM as an argument, I'm all for lynching that person. But just saying "They're arguing with WIFOM" alone is not enough. Even as a defense, all finding WIFOM does is tell you that that persons defense of the actions is null. It doesn't make them any more or less likely to be scum.

[zwetschenwasser]

agree to disagree, check. Moving on...

[Furcolow]

I agree with judge. WIFOM is highlighted best in the princess bride. You know why? Both glasses are poisoned, really.



I would be willing to lynch mothrax because I am town and he is willing to lynch me, which makes him unhelpful

[Vi]

Vote Count XIV

~ Neither melody nor rhythm

Furcolow (L-4) ~ mothrax, pacman, Me=Weird, animorpherv1,

zwetschenwasser

Me=Weird (L-5) ~ Iecerint,

Furcolow,

Friend, Furcolow
pacman (L-5) ~ vezokpiraka, Plum, Socrates
mothrax (L-7) ~

Friend,

AGar,

zwetschenwasser, Furcolow, Furcolow

vezokpiraka (L-7) ~ SocioPath
Plum (L-7) ~ zwetschenwasser

Vi (L-8) ~

zwetschenwasser

curiouskarmadog (Sebguer) (L-8) ~

Socrates

Not Voting:

Locke Lamora,

Plum,

curiouskarmadog (Sebguer)

AGar 0 | ani 0 | Me= 1 | Friend 0 | Furc 0 | Iece 0 | Locke 0 | mothrax 0 | pacman 1 | Plum 0 PROD1 2 | ckd 0 | Socio 1 | Socrates 0 | vezo 1 | zwet 0

--With 15 alive, it will take 8 to lynch.

---I found out why the prods weren't going out. I assumed that after clicking "Submit", the PM actually went out instead of going to some kind of auto-preview. Have I mentioned in the last five minutes how much I hate phpBB3?

Battery power:

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

||||

|

|||

(88%)

[zwetschenwasser]

WIFOM is highlighted best in the princess bride. You know why? Both glasses are poisoned, really.

this means nothing.