Skill- what the others said, you misinterpreted what I called WIFOM.
el simo wrote:How do we know he is really a vig and not a serial killer? It would be easy to for a SK to claim vig.
We don't but it's not something to address today. Plus even if he is SK, we can use that to our advantage for the time being.
mongoose wrote:Well, unless someone is going to counter claim don, i guess we kinda have to believe him. I'm not so sure about the case, but we kinda have to trust him. The question is, what if mysterio isnt Scum. Does that mean don is telling the truth, or does it mean he is a liar and should be killed the next day. I still wanna think this through, since this is probably the ideal way for a serial killer to mole a village. However, in another game I played in on another forum, I was vig and was forced to claim, and basically was used as a second lynch. Until the doc died and I dies the next night. I'm holding my vote for now.
To me it's null. If mysterio flips town, that tells us nothing about DJ. If mysterio flips scum, then there is a much better chance that DJ is town although we cannot rule out the SK possibility.
wishy washy voting isn't a scumtell. unless mysterio flips scum. anyone who wants to post suggestions, i'm all for it. if we're lynching mysterio(which we should since he's all but dissappeared) then please format your suggestions in the form of:
no. i won't be announcing plans, and if i do, it will only be to wifom the scum. i think having everyone produce a suggestion in the format i laid out might actually be used as a scum hunting tool in case i wind up dead.
i would like doc protection if we have one, btw. but i understand if i don't get it. i have a feeling that mysterio is scum, and that i will be targeted for nk. as far as scum is concerned, if i'm not vig, i'm sk, and so they would be glad to be rid of me either way. especially if mysterio flips scum. they don't need another killer running around. in any case, i'm pretty good on this lynch, so i'd like players thoughts, lists, suggestions, etc. and then some type of hammer would be nice.
I agree with don that if Mysterio flips scum, don would be shot during the night, regardless of him being a vig or sk.
I'm also going to refrain from suggesting a kill for don because a) my guess would be good as his, and b) I don't want mafia to clue in on who don might shoot tonight.
But you should shoot, especially if Mysterio flips scum.
don_johnson wrote:wishy washy voting isn't a scumtell.
Since when?
since, like, forever man. wishy washy voting is more of a playstyle than a bona fide alignment indicator...
at least that's my opinion. the only time it becomes an issue is when alignments get revealed. i.e. mysterio flipping scum would make it more of a scumtell. a town flip could indicate a cautious townie. its still day 1, too. many games aren't really able to be figured out until later days. but we'll see.
It's basically because don said so. At this point it seems that people are voting for me in the hopes that don's gambit works out, rather than voting for the player who has acted the scummiest in the game. Raivann again switches his vote to me without any new posts on the subject, nor any new posts by Skill. he doesn't even give any explanations. It seems he's just looking for a wagon to coast on at this point.
The fact that you wanted to lynch a claimed vig without a counter-claim paired with the OMGUS of don, then your convenient vanishing when the pressure on your was amped up.
Heya, I'm back. Just working on a freakin' huge hw assignment the other day and this game totally slipped my mind whilst I was working, but I'm back now.
@scott, sorry about misinterpreting your answer, I get it now. I'm so dense sometimes >.>;
I agree that don's kill shouldn't be discussed, it just gives more info to the scummies, and they can work their kill around what's brought up. Although...
Jase wrote:Kill who you want I guess. You may want to kill of a lurker if nothing else. I know I like a town free of dead weight.
I agree heartily with this.
I'm alright with the Mysterio lynch. Well, I hope no one else has anything to add, 'cause I'm going to drop the hammer.
vote: Mysterio
Mini 1042 is on Day 4 now and doesn't need any replacements.
