Mini 1034 - Castlevania Mafia (Game Over)

[tanstalas]

Proven role isn't proven alignment. Also, you can paraphrase. You can say "the mod said yes" or "the mod said no" but you can't copy/paste the pm.

Stop fishing MPR - I already said I wasn't going to reveal what the mod said

[Kdub]

SpyreX replaces drmyshottyizsik.

Vote Count

LynchMePls (0)

-

SpyreX (0)

-

jenniwren (0)

-

UncertainKitten (1)

- McGriddle

MehPlusRawr (3)

- UncertainKitten, Dekes, tanstalas

Katsuki (0)

-

Dekes (0)

-

Coach Travis (1)

- jenniwren

zwetschenwasser (3)

- Coach Travis, VasudeVa, zwetschenwasser

McGriddle (0)

-

VasudeVa (0)

-

tanstalas (3)

- LynchMePls, Katsuki, MehPlusRawr

No Lynch (0)

-

Not Voting (1)

- SpyreX

12 votes available, 7 votes needed to lynch.

Deadline is September 16, ~ 9 am PDT.

[tanstalas]

Welcome SpyreX - looking forward to your posts

[tanstalas]

Proven role isn't proven alignment. Also, you can paraphrase. You can say "the mod said yes" or "the mod said no" but you can't copy/paste the pm.

Stop fishing MPR - I already said I wasn't going to reveal what the mod said

Right, and if I was scum I would be so terrified of my own scum-buddies targeting me at night that I would ask the mod if I would absorb a NK

[MehPlusRawr]

I will not tell you the answer, but this is why you all should get off my BW now if you are town because this should hopefully make me obv-town in your eyes as if I was lying about this it would be in violation of A6 - "You may

not

quote or

pretend to quote private communications with the mod

or other players."

I misread what you said. Thought you said that you couldn't answer it because it would be quoting your pm.

Please tell me you're not inferring that you're town because scum can't fakeclaim as it would be "pretending to quote a pm from a mod?"

Because that would be the stupidest thing I've heard today, next to somebody asking how to refresh his browser.

[MehPlusRawr]

Hi, Spyre.

[LimMePls]

Proven role isn't proven alignment. Also, you can paraphrase. You can say "the mod said yes" or "the mod said no" but you can't copy/paste the pm.

Don't answer this question tans. You are right to not explain if it counts against the NK.

Unvote
Vote: MPR

He could do that, but why would he?

[Coach Travis]

Interesting roleclaim, I'll believe it because it fits into everything I've felt reading through the game so far, that Tans is simply overwhelmed, trying to help the town in his own way, so I could see that being the case if he has this big power role we don't want to lose.

And yeah, I get that zwet may be similar in his other games, but just in general the way he comes off I'm not liking at all, and with that type of player I'd always prefer to have them lynched because even if he's town I'm not finding him terribly helpful, and so far he's done nothing to make me think he's town. I've never got the point of playing mafia if you're going to be that deliberately unhelpful. MPR's fishing is getting ridiculous though, so I'm also suspicious of him.

[LimMePls]

SpyreX replaces drmyshottyizsik.

Talk about an upgrade!

[UncertainKitten]

Careful tans. You're putting me in a position where I'm scum whether I attack you or not, and it doesn't necessarily logically follow.

...wow, SK claim much?

SpyreX replaces drmyshottyizsik.

FUCK.
YES.

@MPR: I think that's exactly what he's saying. I usually have a facepalm pic for these situations, but I'm too lazy to pull it up. At any rate, LMP has a point about the fact that tans is still right to not divulge the NK aspect. That said, I don't see you fishing for it so much as commenting on how silly it was to try to use the rules that way.

@CT: Well, as has already been bandied about, proven role does NOT equal proven alignment.

But, whatever, at this point I figure tans is Town or SK. SK would fit with a few things he's said. Admittedly, I'd want to see at least one night before lynching based on SK Spec.

[VasudeVa]

tanstalas seems to be a paranoid player. Not sure if it's scum paranoia or just null paranoia. I've been...similar. I think I need to do a full reread of this game. I'm in too many games. ._.

Here's a promise of an in-depth reread in 3-4 days. Feel free to call me out on it if I don't deliver. Can't do it now though, one game is in full momentum.

[zwetschenwasser]

I really REALLY really don't like tans's claim, because if it were real, it would essentially be the equivalent of a self-confirmable townie.

[UncertainKitten]

Well, it depends on a lot of factors, zwet. Because again, it doesn't really prove itself well, and is actually kinda a scummy power, but REALLY POWERFUL for scum, hence my conclusion of SK. It's a really innovative SK power, if an SK exists. Problem is, we have no evidence an SK exists.

[VasudeVa]

What the flying fuck why the fuck did you claim that Chronopie!?

[VasudeVa]

Ack. Wrong game. Damn, I need my sleep.

[zwetschenwasser]

Well, it depends on a lot of factors, zwet. Because again, it doesn't really prove itself well, and is actually kinda a scummy power, but REALLY POWERFUL for scum, hence my conclusion of SK. It's a really innovative SK power, if an SK exists. Problem is, we have no evidence an SK exists.

I actually think tans is lying about his claim.

[SpyreX]

What up game.

Few things on the itenerary.

1.) I am a miller. An AWESOME miller. You can have a name if you want but, on the offchance there isn't fakeclaims (which I doubt) its definitely one that could cause a ruckus.

2.) Zwet, damnit, get that vote off yourself. You're town.

3.) UK you're probably town too but you forgot the key part about 'scum intent' - that it has an inverse. WHY in the hell is there a wagon on tans who is twirling town on a level unparalleled - wrong about some stuff, but town nonetheless.

4.) Lets go ahead and lynch real scum:

Unvote, Vote: Coach Travis

Talk about not wanting to step on any toes. Or say anything unique. This is that guy that sticks in the mob and when things go wrong points at the pitchforkers going "not me".

There's another in the morass of lurkers as well. They will be found and dealt with accordingly.

[UncertainKitten]

3.) UK you're probably town too but you forgot the key part about 'scum intent' - that it has an inverse. WHY in the hell is there a wagon on tans who is twirling town on a level unparalleled - wrong about some stuff, but town nonetheless.

You clearly haven't been reading my posts.

[UncertainKitten]

@zwet: Unlikely.

[SpyreX]

No, I know YOUR stance and thats the big reason why I'm town on you yo'.

The dealio is I didn't see you crackin' skulls near hard enough with stopping this silliness.

[UncertainKitten]

I've been telling everyone they are moronic to vote tans. But to be honest? I wanted his wagon to continue because I expect a lot of intent will be revealed once we have some flips to work with. Hence why I've been like "Guys, he's newb town" "Guys, seriously, he's newb town" "Guys, he's fucking newb town" "Oh for the love of God, he's fucking newb town" throughout the game, but not going farther beyond that.

[McGriddle]

@zwet: Unlikely.

Why is that? Isn't it common for scum to lie about their roles? And hid claim seemed a little too spontaneous for my taste.

[UncertainKitten]

Not uncommon, but at the very least the role is verifiable. You don't claim an unverifiable role without something to back it up.

[SpyreX]

I dig your smooth vibes you happenin' chick. I just wish you'd have stomped the yard before he claimed but alas.

[zwetschenwasser]

I'm voting myself?

Unvote