Newbie 970 - Quietville - Game over

[Incognito]

Nachomamma8 (2) <-~ Rain, [O]rphen
Mirhawk (1) <-~ Nachomamma8

Not voting (2) <-~ Mirhawk, Sleepless Assassin

With 5 living, 3 votes will do it.

[[O]rphen]

Here's the way I see it.

You all think I have the best chance of being scum, and you can't really find any strong tells on anyone else except for me.
I suddenly strongly believe that one player is scum.

So, lynch me.
This confirms me as town, and confirm my suspicions to be true.

Then, lynch Mirhawk based on my word. These words will be coming out of a confirmed town's mouth tomorrow; a confirmed town who obviously want to win the game. So, why not trust me?

id like a case thanks

[Nachomamma8]

No.

In a normal game, probably, but here, no. If you're not going to take me for my word, I'm not doing the legwork for you. I've already pointed out he was scum. So ISO him, look through his posts. Look through why Rain and Sleepless are town. I've given you a place to start, so it's up to you to do the rest, not me.

[Sleepless Assassin]

Ok, deadline on Monday and I don't see anyone other than nacho being lynched. Hammah time.

vote nacho

[Nachomamma8]

Bah.

[Incognito]

Nachomamma8 (3) <-~ Rain, [O]rphen, Sleepless Assassin

Mirhawk (1) <-~ Nachomamma8

Not voting (1) <-~ Mirhawk

With 5 living, 3 votes will do it.

---

Flavor later.

---

Nachomamma8,

Townie

, lynched Day 3

It is now Night 3. Please have any and all Night actions in to me within 72 hours of this post. Day 4 will restart on Tuesday, August 31st at about 12 P.M. EDT.

[Incognito]

Sorry, no real time for flavor but I'm opening this now.

---

Mirhawk,

Vanilla Townie

, killed Night 3

It is now Day 4. Your D4 deadline is set for Tuesday, September 21st at 11 A.M. EDT.

[Mirhawk]

dang

good luck guys.

[Rain]

I'm here but I need to reread...

[Incognito]

Bump.

[Rain]

Alright well I was hoping you guys would spark some discussion, but apparently that isnt going to happen.

So, I've been looking at your interactions with Xite to judge which one is more likely to be scum, and while both of you have been targeted by her and have targeted her, some things have stood out:

The cases between Xite and Orphen were quite weak, and perhaps weaker than what was put out against other players. Indeed, orphen even said that his case wasnt based on any good arguments (which he discarded early), but continued to press it at times. Also, while sleepless attacked Xite and then kept it up during all of day2, Orphen and Xite's votes between each other were often being unvoted and revoted without a very strong conviction behind it.

During day2, both Xite and Orphen speculated about why I wasn't NK'ed despite being the most townie looking player during day1, since there was a risk of doctor, (no one mentioned this), this appears like something that would have been discussed between scum during the night when picking the kill. For reference, the main posts were 265 and 286.

Also, voting against themselves between Xite and Orphen was entirely done when the threat of lynching was minimal. Indeed, Orphen took the first opportunity he had to unvote Xite when Xite was put at L-1 during day2. Also, Orphen appeared to be defending Xite somewhat when the possibility of a lynch was getting closer...

Day3 is essentially a null-tell, it only confirmed nacho and mirhawk as townie...

So I'm essentially leaning towards Orphen being scum right now, as his interactions with Xite seem to suggest that his votes against her werent fully genuine. As for sleepless, unfortunately he hasnt posted much earlier in the game and lateralus didnt really do much, but his attack on xite which lasted from day1 until her lynch seemed more genuine.

Not putting a vote right away, but as I said, so far its looking like Orphen is scum...

[Rain]

EBWOP: (no one mentioned this) should be (no one else mentioned this)

[[O]rphen]

mmk will have a reread now

[Sleepless Assassin]

Hey, sorry I haven't posted in a while. Life happened. The good news is that we have this game won from the claim that is about to happen.

I am the cop

So who'd I catch? Actually, it's who I didn't catch. I investigated rain and he turned up town. That means orphen is the last scum

vote orphen

If you guys were wondering, I got a scum result on xite night 1. I picked xite because she was most suspicious. I didn't come out with that because I knew there was a chance to lynch her without making myself a night target for scum. Night 2, I was roleblocked. Last night, I picked rain because I thought if he was town, he had the lowest chance of being nightkilled because he was lynchbait.

[Sleepless Assassin]

Wait, correction. Night 2 I thought I was roleblocked and when I asked the mod, he said my action wasn't in in time. Still had it in my head that I was blocked.

[Rain]

I was about to mention that you can't possibly have been roleblocked since I'm not the doctor (meaning it isn't the build with cop + blocker)...

Well, orphen, any last comments?

[Sleepless Assassin]

And rain is now confirmed not only by my result, but by the fact that he didn't just hammer orphen at first opportubity.

This one is in the bag.

[Rain]

Alright well I'm getting pretty impatient and I'm just going to go with my gut feeling and VOTE: Orphen...

[Incognito]

I was on my way to bed but I just noticed two votes soooooooooooooooooo.... I won't keep you hanging.

Final Vote Count of the Game

[O]rphen (2) <-~ Sleepless Assassin, Rain

Not voting (1) <-~ [O]rphen

3 living; 2 will do it

-~-~-~-~

[O]rphen,

Vanilla Townie

, lynched Day 4
Rain,

Vanilla Townie

, endgamed Day 4

Sleepless Assassin,

Mafia Roleblocker

, survives

The

Mafia

wins the game!

[Incognito]

The game was all vanilla for the town. The Mafia roles have already been mentioned. Night actions should be obvious except for Sleepless Assassin's roleblocks. Since they weren't affecting anyone though, I didn't really keep track of them.

Feel free to use this time to discuss and offer each other some constructive criticism if you'd like. Good game, all! I hope my transitioning into the mod role was smooth enough for all of you.

[Xite91]

Hell yes! I love you sleepless
Good game guys ^____^

[Rain]

Bah... shouldve read more into the fact that sleepless's claim came so late and after my case, but he always started the days late so I just brushed it off...

In the end, orphen and sleep played similar games, they both attacked and got attacked by xite and both of them were happy to follow with the nacho lynch, but sleep played a key part in lynching xite while orphen didnt, thats what it came down to for me...

I dont think orphen couldve said anything to change my mind at the end...

[Xite91]

But like I said, rain, you were my favorite townie, and when it came to the NK night one, you were my top choice <3

[Nachomamma8]

Yup, this was one failure of a game for me.

And I don't think that calling the game "Quietville" was a good idea at all...

[Xite91]

And I don't think that calling the game "Quietville" was a good idea at all...

I lol'd. And Nach, you were pretty convincing in your cases (hey, you came close to swaying a lynch off of obvscum, that's pretty damn good IMHO), you were just convinced the wrong things