He cant be scum in all 3 games, can he???manho wrote:[off-topic] you are in all my 3 games? i'm tempted to vote you here to make all my 3 votes on you.[/off-topic]Chronopie wrote:Going to be semi-V/LA over the next week, I have a group presentation to work on. posting this across all games.
Obviously he would die. Why the hell would the mafia want another doctor in the game? Are you trying to make us think you're town by stating the obvious? Breaking strategy? WTF?Chronopie wrote:Damn shame about Esurio Dying, I had a Breaking Strategy in mind.
i was once being scum in 3 out of 4 games at the same time.SharkFinn wrote:He cant be scum in all 3 games, can he???manho wrote:[off-topic] you are in all my 3 games? i'm tempted to vote you here to make all my 3 votes on you.[/off-topic]Chronopie wrote:Going to be semi-V/LA over the next week, I have a group presentation to work on. posting this across all games.
Hmm....
Yes a breaking Strategy, involving Esurio's ability, the fact that we had two docs at that time, and the mod confirmed info on what would happen had Esurio answered my question and gone along with my strategy earlier.Stels wrote:Obviously he would die. Why the hell would the mafia want another doctor in the game? Are you trying to make us think you're town by stating the obvious? Breaking strategy? WTF?Chronopie wrote:Damn shame about Esurio Dying, I had a Breaking Strategy in mind.
Give me one reason why scum would abstain from using a smash ball kill, and then I'll answer your questions.Stels wrote:@Nachomamma8: It took you 2 weeks just to tells us that you didn't submit your night action in time? Did you talk it over with your scum partners over N3 just to come up with that reason? Why did simply telling that one phrase took you sooooo much time?
HEY NACHOS CONFIRMED FUCKIN TOWN VIA N1, HIS ROLE, N ME.Stels wrote:@Nachomamma: ok, the fact that they get another free kill is a plus for the mafia, but what if scum abstained from using the smashball, to attract attention from themselves onto a "sacrifice" in order to help their scum team win. For example, what bunnylover said about Fate being a 'mafia godfather', wouldn't scum try to attract attention away from the GF? If Fate is a GF, then as his friend and scumbuddy, wouldn't you want to make him live longer? That is assuming you're scum, which is what I'm trying to find out.
Were you just embarassed to tell us that you didn't submit you SB kill? <---that I highly doubt.
Mind responding to this?Nachomamma8 wrote:The fact that you never explained your little theory is what makes it scummy. Since you never explained your theory, it seems more likely to me that you were just reaching for reasons not the townvote fate as opposed to you even having a theory in the first place.Holding off is better incase a claim happens, like what happened with pikachu yesterday.
No. He didn't. I'll bring up the quote if need be, but you're 100% wrong here.Paltry brought up that double lynch was bad, not good. MPR was the lucky winner due to being scummy apart from that suggestion.
Show me one point he could defend against when he originally attacked mongoose.Nothing is wrong with an early stage wagon, MPR reacted horribly to it. Far more interested in attacking his attackers then defending against any points.
No. It was question whose answer would've been useful to know.It was a slight attack, not strong but it can be interpreted as an early step to using the sudden SSK-hammer as future casefodder
Odd. The only reads they've given are mongoose is scum, and you're town. And you've never said ANYTHING about mongoose being scum, so I'm assuming you didn't try to give them the smash ball because you knew they wouldn't shoot you... right?I think you arent the most useful player in the world, and I do not trust your reads at all, but there are some small reasons to think you are town. I will never townvote you though before a massclaim given a few recent things. Also yes, I still think kocc and stelz are town. I like thier reads a whole lot more then yours.
MPR explained himself in ISO #30, which I find to be good enough reasoning. He thought diddin was fakeclaiming because he got a picture of a photobucket that wasn't Ani's...He voted him for the picture he put up. Shameless/stupid wagon if I ever saw one.
I already said I was talking with the mod. I couldn't say more because:mongoose wrote:on a slightly more on topic note, I dont see why you couldnt just tell us the smash kill was submitted late, and that you were trying to make it go through.
Do not quote or pretend to quote any private communication, either from me or from anyone else you are allowed to talk with at night. This includes your role PM. Violators will be modkilled. You are allowed to paraphrase, but you are not allowed to plagiarize. If in doubt as to your paraphrase's legality, PM me with the wording you want to use.
Ok, so then this is one of those "impossible to defend against" points? I already said my reasoning, if you are going to refuse to accept it say it instead of beating around the bush.Nachomamma8 wrote:The fact that you never explained your little theory is what makes it scummy. Since you never explained your theory, it seems more likely to me that you were just reaching for reasons not the townvote fate as opposed to you even having a theory in the first place.Holding off is better incase a claim happens, like what happened with pikachu yesterday.
Looking back you are right here, and I read his inital post wrong. My point on MPR being previously scummy still stands though, any response to that part?No. He didn't. I'll bring up the quote if need be, but you're 100% wrong here.Paltry brought up that double lynch was bad, not good. MPR was the lucky winner due to being scummy apart from that suggestion.
Again, nothing is wrong with early wagons. It is one of those things that most newer players have seething hate for due to some reason I cant understand. Mongoose was not the only one he did this too as well, he reacted the exact same way to bunnys vote. Also you can technically say mongoose voted for the sake of wagoning, due to his "I agree with diddin" post in which diddin says he is bandwagoning.Show me one point he could defend against when he originally attacked mongoose.Nothing is wrong with an early stage wagon, MPR reacted horribly to it. Far more interested in attacking his attackers then defending against any points.
Stelz is in no way scum with diddin (see his early speculation post regarding Luigi), and his opening post the next day. I would nearly be willing to bet the game that if Stelz is scum, it is with gollum. I do not get a scum read off him though, so that is a great reason to give him SB (Not scum A, townish read).Odd. The only reads they've given are mongoose is scum, and you're town. And you've never said ANYTHING about mongoose being scum, so I'm assuming you didn't try to give them the smash ball because you knew they wouldn't shoot you... right?I think you arent the most useful player in the world, and I do not trust your reads at all, but there are some small reasons to think you are town. I will never townvote you though before a massclaim given a few recent things. Also yes, I still think kocc and stelz are town. I like thier reads a whole lot more then yours.
Yeah this was the dumbest reason ever to vote him. That wasnt even a picture of Luigi (its an internet meme). That was more of finding an excuse to vote him.MPR explained himself in ISO #30, which I find to be good enough reasoning. He thought diddin was fakeclaiming because he got a picture of a photobucket that wasn't Ani's...He voted him for the picture he put up. Shameless/stupid wagon if I ever saw one.
