Mini 1029: Boondox Mafia (GAME OVER!!!! )

[Scott Brosius]

Skill. Fakegod. El Simo.
U heard it here first.

unvote, vote fakegod

And your 100% on KageLord went.....?

[don_johnson]

Skill. Fakegod. El Simo.
U heard it here first.

unvote, vote fakegod

And your 100% on KageLord went.....?

out the window... apparently. it was something he posted that caught my eye, but on reread seemed reasonable. i've got a real vibe on these three. if fg flips scum i'll shoot one of the other two. still working on more analysis, though. talk later.

[el simo]

Siigh, if you think I am scum I'd really hope you'd let the town hear your case, because I'm pretty sure you are the only one who shares this view. I'd hate to be killed by the vig because we had two wagons on townies on day 1.

[don_johnson]

Siigh, if you think I am scum I'd really hope you'd let the town hear your case, because I'm pretty sure you are the only one who shares this view. I'd hate to be killed by the vig because we had two wagons on townies on day 1.

if fakegod flips scum then your death would not be in vain as it would confirm you for town and give us a good position for the day.

your vote reads like a bus. and your worry about your own skin doesn't help. i said you

or

skill. what do you think of skill as a partner to fakegod? and who else might you pair with fakegod?

[el simo]

Siigh, if you think I am scum I'd really hope you'd let the town hear your case, because I'm pretty sure you are the only one who shares this view. I'd hate to be killed by the vig because we had two wagons on townies on day 1.

if fakegod flips scum then your death would not be in vain as it would confirm you for town and give us a good position for the day.

your vote reads like a bus. and your worry about your own skin doesn't help. i said you

or

skill. what do you think of skill as a partner to fakegod? and who else might you pair with fakegod?

My vote reads like a bus despite my explanation, which is unique to everyone else's, but yours doesn't after the previous post you claimed that someone was scum 100% and then go right off that claim with out any explanations what so ever, and despite claiming to talk more later you still haven't posted you reason, for either me, FakeGod or Skill.

Right, if you hadn't claimed vig I'd honestly think you were the best lynch for the day. If you don't produce a kill tonight I am going to be in serious doubt of your claim tomorrow.

And think about it a bit more don and I think you'll understand why I am so worried, never mind your so far bogus accusations.

If FakeGod does flip scum, my next target would probably mongoose. I don't see anything that would buddy FakeGod with someone so instead of looking for a possible pairing I'd really just focus on who is most suspicious. Mongoose, despite the wagon on Bunny, hasn't improved his posting habits much, perhaps he needs some more incentive.

If you do decide to shoot me tonight, don, I'd hope you'd tell me before the lynch as I'd like to give the town my last ditch effort to help them out, it won't harm the town because if I flip scum then you can just ignore my post, so you're really not losing anything. The only way scum can prevent you from shooting is by roleblocking you which won't make a difference if they know who you are going to shoot or not and by shooting your target before you do which really just helps town.

[don_johnson]

you seem awfullly worried about this...

does that mean that you are extremely confident that fakegod is scum?

please esplain this isea that mongoose is "buddying" to fakegod(or whatever it is that you are implying as the connection between the two)? if you convince me otherwise, then there is less probability i will shoot you. of course, this all depends on fakegod flipping scum. so...

let's get the bastard to L-1, get a claim and then decide between him and bunny, no? or does someon want to make a case for a better lynch candidate?

[el simo]

I don't see anything that would buddy FakeGod with someone so instead of looking for a possible pairing I'd really just focus on who is most suspicious.

And I wouldn't want his lynch if I didn't think he was scum.

[FakeGod]

Claim: Vanilla Townie.

No need to get me to L-1 for a claim.

[don_johnson]

FG lynch is a go!

if he flips town i shoot bunny? thoughts?

[el simo]

What do you think his vote on bunny indicates if he does flip scum?

[el simo]

What I'm implying is, if he was trying to 'bus' bunny he would've been a bit more obvious about it, wouldn't he?

[Skill006]

Alrighty, after a year and a half I'm back. So, here are my thoughts on everything:

My reason for voting mongoose over bunny was to spread the love around. Neither was more suspicious over the other at the time, and there weren't any votes on mongoose so I put my vote there. I've never been a fan of quick bandwagons.

@Kage, you can pass it off as "bad play", however if you do that too often you'll let sneaky scum by. Just happened in a slightly recent game of mine. One of scum's greatest tools are to lurk, especially if the town doesn't notice their absence, like with cloudocean.

Speaking of which, mod, I think cloudocean is due for a prod.

if he flips town i shoot bunny? thoughts?

Risky. If fakegod flips town and scum shoots someone tonight, and you shoot bunny and he flips town, we're toast. Especially if that other person shoots someone.

I wasn't a huge fan of fakegod's playstyle to begin with, but that alone doesn't make him scum. Though, I actually agree with el simo that his defense sounded like a poor excuse. And, when I think about it more, his active lurking and baseless bandwagon votes put me off.

unvote: mongoose
vote: Fakegod

I'm ok with a mongoose, bunny, Fakegod or

maybe

cloudocean lynch, though of course not before he comes back and posts.

[don_johnson]

mod: votecount please?

[FakeGod]

eh, I think that's L-1 on me, right?

[don_johnson]

please do not self hammer if you are town.

[FakeGod]

please do not self hammer if you are town.

Do not worry. I never self-hammer.

[danakillsu]

Votecount 2.3
FakeGod (4)- Scott Brosius, don_johnson, el simo, Skill006
Bunnylover (1)- cloudocean
Not Voting (4)- KageLord, mongoose, Bunnylover, FakeGod

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch, 5 to no lynch.

[danakillsu]

cloudocean will now be prodded. If he does not post in 24 hours, he will be replaced.

[mongoose]

Do we kill FG or not now? Vanilla is always a suspicious role, and even more so in a normal ( I would think) considering there are a wide variety of roles to choose from. I think I should finish him off now.

[Scott Brosius]

Why didn't you hammer bunny then if vanilla is always a suspicious role?

[FakeGod]

Can't you see that he's just testing the waters?

He wants to hammer, but he wants to seem justified in doing so.

[FakeGod]

oops clicked submit instead of preview

EBWOP: because he probably already knows that I'll flip VT.

[el simo]

oops clicked submit instead of preview

EBWOP: because he probably already knows that I'll flip VT.

This is a fair point to consider tomorrow if you do flip town.

[danakillsu]

searching for a cloudocean replacement

[KageLord]

Do we kill FG or not now? Vanilla is always a suspicious role, and even more so in a normal ( I would think) considering there are a wide variety of roles to choose from. I think I should finish him off now.

Scummy (FG gives a fair reason why).

VT isn't a role I find suspicious in a Normal. In fact, I just finished a normal that had 4. However, now that you mention it, it does seem a bit more unlikely to have this many VTs (in my mind, this hurts all 3 of Bunny, mongoose, and FG) given that 3 VTs already flipped. Setup speculation isn't always very useful though since the mod has many many options (my last game had overpowered town anyway because of the PRs). Oh how I hate self-contradictions. I'm going to go ahead and say now that I think at least one of those three has to be scum, disregarding my previous poor play argument.