Last Will Mafia II (Over)

[holycon]

back from V/LA going to do some catch up reading and hopefully have a post ready sometime tomorrow

[esuriospiritus]

Plum PBPA tomorrow probably -- I have the day off. (And I have to stop putting off doing actual

work

for this game, augh.)

However you don't really have to worry about getting any flak from me because you're a semi-sheeped suspect and I know that sheeping all the time isn't a good thing.

This sentence rubs me the wrong way. I can't really put my finger on why, exactly, other than it seems like he's too preoccupied with what other people think of him. I may be reading a Charlie iso soon.

The only reason I suspected that you were just a VI there instead of

my opposing scum faction

was because I thought I had the other ones pegged.

Do I see a scumslip? I think I do.

unvote; vote: Amished

What say ye?

[Plum]

There's another scum faction in this game? Doesn't look too much like it, all things considered. I've learned to heavily distrust slips of even the most damning nature and can easily think of ways the phrasing could have happened by accident. Again, it really doesn't indicate anything unless there are two scum factions, and that is extremely unlikely, so.

[Ythan]

That is an incredibly damning slip though.

[Plum]

I've seen worse (or as bad at least if my memory doesn't fail) flip Town.

[Ythan]

We've all seen obvscum flip town. But you're trying to use that to say that only weak evidence should be used, or something crazy. I'm more certain about you now.

[Xite91]

And your point? The only reason I suspected that you were just a VI there instead of

my opposing scum faction

was because I thought I had the other ones pegged. One game does not a meta make and content is how I get reads on people. If you'd pay attention you'd know I could probably rattle off 5-6 people that would not mind lynching you for your *non* participation. "I don't want to get lynched" definitely does not help your case and I'm considering switching over to you even with obv-scum SSBF over here.

Damnitdamnitdamnit!!!

The only reason I suspected that you were just a VI there instead of

my opposing scum faction

was because I thought I had the other ones pegged.

Do I see a scumslip? I think I do.

unvote; vote: Amished

What say ye?

I was gonna point that out...
Anyways, glad someone else caught it.
But I'm not ready to lynch Amished, because he's not the first.

There's another scum faction in this game? Doesn't look too much like it, all things considered. I've learned to heavily distrust slips of even the most damning nature and can easily think of ways the phrasing could have happened by accident. Again, it really doesn't indicate anything unless there are two scum factions, and that is extremely unlikely, so.

We have not seen any scumflips yet, so we can't make that assumption right away, I mean what if they get alternate NK's?
Also, of course you distrust them, because I caught yours earlier.
How is it so unlikely?

However you don't really have to worry about getting any flak from me because you're a semi-sheeped suspect and I know that sheeping all the time isn't a good thing.

This sentence rubs me the wrong way. I can't really put my finger on why, exactly, other than it seems like he's too preoccupied with what other people think of him. I may be reading a Charlie iso soon.

Probably because he admits to sheeping me AND suspecting me. He also admits that sheeping is bad.

[esuriospiritus]

Again, it really doesn't indicate anything unless there are two scum factions

my

opposing scum faction

?

[Xite91]

Again, it really doesn't indicate anything unless there are two scum factions

my

opposing scum faction

?

esurio, it really would only make sense if there were 2 scum factions, because why would he say opposing?

[Ythan]

He probably doesn't know what he's up against exactly. He does not say that there IS an opposing faction.

[esuriospiritus]

Just because he is on one scum team doesn't necessarily mean he would know about another one existing or not existing for certain. He could be scum not

knowing

whether or not there's another scumteam, but searching for scummy people, anyway. That's how I read it, anyway.

but mostly i just don't want to admit plum is probably right, because I want to think I've got caught scum, here.

And there are certainly enough not-particularly-protown people in this game. e_e

PEDIT: What ythan said.

[holycon]

why would he word what he wanted to say that way as scum that would be a stupid scum move to do so

[Xite91]

Just because he is on one scum team doesn't necessarily mean he would know about another one existing or not existing for certain. He could be scum not

knowing

whether or not there's another scumteam, but searching for scummy people, anyway. That's how I read it, anyway.

but mostly i just don't want to admit plum is probably right, because I want to think I've got caught scum, here.

And there are certainly enough not-particularly-protown people in this game. e_e

PEDIT: What ythan said.

Just sayin it's more likely for him to be scum if there's more than one scumteams, and considering the context of his message, I feel that could be the case, but I feel that we should leave him until tomorrow, because we've got a good wagon on SSBF and he is probscum as well. But Eh, choice is up to you

[Xite91]

why would he word what he wanted to say that way as scum that would be a stupid scum move to do so

Why would he word it that way as town? Can you think of a good reason?

[esuriospiritus]

It's called a scum SLIP for a reason, yo.


dammit, ninja'd by Xite. post is @ holycon.

[Ythan]

Plum's defense, I think, just incriminates them both even more.

[holycon]

I can't think of why he would word it that way at all its a stupid move ether way

[Ythan]

Mistakes are the entire basis of scumhunting. This is just a big mistake.

[holycon]

its a big enough mistake that i am probably going to vote him

[holycon]

VOTE: amished

yeah a mistake like that just can't be overlooked

[esuriospiritus]

But Eh, choice is up to you

Why me? (You...

were

talking to me, right?)

And meh, I'm still more convinced Plum is scum than Ani, SSBF, Ythan are scum. And if one of those three has to be lynched, I rather it be ani. less of a pro-town game (plus my predecessor had a vote on him at some point or other, which is almost like getting a free second opinion from someone I know is town. )

@Holy: is there a... reason you've gone from defending Amished to voting for him in the span of... eight minutes?

[Ythan]

I'm waiting for him to get here but I probably will too. And I really thought he was town too.

[Kmd4390]

You guys are hillarious. I wouldn't mind an amished wagon, but LOL. I can't believe that many people posted without looking at the context. This is so amusing.

[holycon]

But Eh, choice is up to you

Why me? (You...

were

talking to me, right?)

And meh, I'm still more convinced Plum is scum than Ani, SSBF, Ythan are scum. And if one of those three has to be lynched, I rather it be ani. less of a pro-town game (plus my predecessor had a vote on him at some point or other, which is almost like getting a free second opinion from someone I know is town. )

@Holy: is there a... reason you've gone from defending Amished to voting for him in the span of... eight minutes?

I wan't defending him i was asking a question?

[Ythan]

Kmd either get involved or shut the fuck up because that's less than useless.