Nativity Mafia - Game Over, Praise The Lord!

[This is not me]

yeah,but on the other hand if i would die all my info would be gone.and oky it seems so that saying who are townies are pointless,so from now on i only say if i catch some scummy?

[Mr. Flay]

Page Fourteen Vote Count

, powered by The Count-Counter 2000:

Squonk - 3 (TonyMontana, NanookTheWolf, dybeck)
dybeck - 3 (SSB!, darquiel, Fritzler)
darquiel - 2 (Puzzle, rajrhcpfreak)
SSB! - 1 (Squonk)

Not voting - 6 (Iammars, Werebear, This is not me, Astronaut, Tyfo, Thoth)

15 alive; 8 to lynch.

Prods have gone out.

[Puzzle]

yeah,but on the other hand if i would die all my info would be gone.and oky it seems so that saying who are townies are pointless,so from now on i only say if i catch some scummy?

No, what I was saying is that you shouldn't say who you'll investigate beforehand.

Additionally, you should always wait until someone is about to be lynched before giving us the name of an innocent : it could help to see the said innocent be wagonned, in order to analyze who went after him, when and how.
And the town should always leave you the time to say who is innocent before concluding a lynch.

[Tyfo]

It seems that we are running round in circles, eh?

[darquiel]

It seems that we are running round in circles, eh?

Very much so.

[This is not me]

yeah and it sucks,i am not very far of making random lynch vote,but that would suck of course

[Thoth]

yeah,but on the other hand if i would die all my info would be gone.and oky it seems so that saying who are townies are pointless,so from now on i only say if i catch some scummy?

As we probably still have a doc (seeing that we only have a dead backup) that's usually the best course of action. Unless you have something like 3 innocents where it gets hard for scum to catch up on killing the doc, you and all 3 innocents.

[Puzzle]

yeah and it sucks,i am not very far of making random lynch vote,but that would suck of course

Darquiel is a random player and a lurker to boot...

[Fritzler]

unvote vote: Werebear

Speak up sunny.

[Werebear]

Poke from Mr. Flay received. Here's my list of some of the more obvious roles, also known as "What I'd Include If I Ran This Game":

Mary
Joseph
Jesus

Gabriel (cop)
Seraphim (doc)
Cherubim (backup doc)
Balthasar the Magi (mason)
Melchior (mason)
Caspar (mason)
Innkeeper (role blocker)

Madalyn Murray O-Hair (Cult leader)
Herod (GF)
Soldier (mafia)
Soldier (mafia)

Were there any role-claims I missed besides "shepherd - townie"? Also, one notes that Madalyn is a contemporary figure that was against religion, so the scope of characters is not limited to the ones found in a stable. Quite honestly, and I know I'm putting myself out by doing this, I hesitate to believe if vanilla townie roles exist.

[Fritzler]

Do you think all scum roles could be from the present day? And god, I wish I had any role but vanilla townie.

[This is not me]

well werebear your list is good,but i know some minor things what are different...

[Astronaut]

Day three, and I really don't feel I've got much to go by. Werebear's list seems reasonable, but seeing that there's still 15 of us alive, mod has included some other roles as well.

Lynching a random person/ a lurker isn't a plan I'd normally support this late in the game, but I really don't have any better suggestion...

[Iammars]

I still think that Herod will have some interaction with the Magi.

[TonyMontana]

I think the sheep are the scum. -.-

[Puzzle]

#81.

[TonyMontana]

No, but i mean sheep as in the characters in the story
Wolf in sheep clothing they are!

[Werebear]

Oh, I know there are more twists in this. And I had considered the idea of animals as scum, but the kill types don't match up, now that the cult leader has been killed. (I'm assuming the trampled death is by the SK)

[darquiel]

Hmm I Cant help but feel we are missing something extremely important in the set up. Either way at this point i think it would be better if we focused on each other right now.

At the moment my vote is going to stay where it is, but i would like to hear thoughts from those who havent voted yet.

[This is not me]

i dont play mafia very good,so i often cant make the decitions the sheep can be baddies(I dont know the story that well)and they maybe are just using the chance that i invegested their godfather.but then again it is very possible that they are townies.

[rajrhcpfreak]

But not everyone is happy to see this joyous day... will he go on to be the Savior, or wind up in a shallow grave? It's up to you to help decide.

y does the sheep care?

unvote Darq

[dybeck]

Wasn't King Herod the guy who ordered the deaths of the first-borns in Exodus?

Why would he be in the Nativity story? Isn't there hundreds of years between these two stories?

[Thoth]

King Herod ordered the death of all young children to be sure to get Jesus as well and is a prime target for a scum role in this game ==>Killing Jewish children = bad
All the firstborns were only Egyptian firstborns, but that was on God's orders, so ==> killing Egyptian children = good. Unless I misinterpret of course.

[dybeck]

Wow slaughtering of children sure was a popular theme in old fairy tales huh? Twice in the same book?

They didn't do it with as much style as Revenge of the Sith though.

[Puzzle]

They didn't have laser-sabers...