Mini 1056 - NFL Mafia (Game Over)

[mongoose]

my policy is to lynch players that are anti town. unfortunately alot of players who have town roles play pro scum. is that my fault? no.

Are you one of them? jk. I dont see what the whole "policy" fuss is about at all.

[rajrhcpfreak]

i really dont know. because its not really policy. its playing the game to the maximum potential.

[jasonT1981]

I kinda see it as nothing more than a conversation starter to be honest, I see people calling for Policy lynches etc early on a few times and its done to stimulate conversation. Besides, how many actual policy lynches happen on day 1?

[Antihero]

That's seriously your reasoning?

No, I completely made that reason up to see how you (and I was hoping other players) would react. Your reaction is satisfactory.

UNVOTE: Mariyta

Are you one of them? jk. I dont see what the whole "policy" fuss is about at all.

Not giving any opinions on other players + criticizing other player's opinions with no reasons = scummy
VOTE: mongoose

I kinda see it as nothing more than a conversation starter to be honest, I see people calling for Policy lynches etc early on a few times and its done to stimulate conversation. Besides, how many actual policy lynches happen on day 1?

Discussion about discussion = fail
Please start posting real content.

He is town based on what exactly?

This post pinged on my scumdar a bit. Kdub isn't calling inhim out on a scumslip, but instead seems annoyed that inhim has such an early townread on freak. IGMEOY

[GhostWriter]

I agree with the vote on Mongoose, but I disagree with your stance on Kdub. I don't much like or understand townreads based on 2 or 3 posts during the RVS.

[Mariyta]

I really hate the "I was just testing you" argument. Yes, the whole point of RVS is to test people and evaluate their reactions, but Antihero's response seems more like a "Crap, no one jumped on the bandwagon. Time to move on." And kdub's post was valid, not scummy. There is no reason for us to believe at this point that Raj is definite town (aside from the fact that he's Raj and Raj is always town, even when he's anti-town. *Antihero, this is a joke, fyi.*)

I agree with the vote on Mongoose, as well. Despite Raj calling it policy, that is really the whole point of the game (for townies, anyway). Mongoose adds nothing to the discuss while trying to seem helpful. Same for Razgriz, so my vote stands and becomes a serious vote.

[charter]

VOTE COUNT

Coach Travis - 2 (jasonT1981, inHimshallibe)
rajrhcpfreak - 3 (Razgriz, mongoose, horrordude0215)
Razgriz - 3 (Mariyta, rajrhcpfreak, jimfinn)
jimfinn - 1 (GhostWriter)
Kdub - 1 (Coach Travis)
horrordude0215 - 1 (Kdub)
mongoose - 1 (Antihero)

NOT VOTING

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch! Deadline is October 3rd, Noon.


Also to clarify, if a backup QB takes over, they can pass to anyone (normally the QB can't pass to the same person consecutive nights).

[inHimshallibe]

That's seriously your reasoning?

No, I completely made that reason up to see how you (and I was hoping other players) would react. Your reaction is satisfactory.

UNVOTE: Mariyta

Are you one of them? jk. I dont see what the whole "policy" fuss is about at all.

Not giving any opinions on other players + criticizing other player's opinions with no reasons = scummy
VOTE: mongoose

I kinda see it as nothing more than a conversation starter to be honest, I see people calling for Policy lynches etc early on a few times and its done to stimulate conversation. Besides, how many actual policy lynches happen on day 1?

Discussion about discussion = fail
Please start posting real content.

He is town based on what exactly?

This post pinged on my scumdar a bit. Kdub isn't calling inhim out on a scumslip, but instead seems annoyed that inhim has such an early townread on freak. IGMEOY

<3

unvote
vote: mongoose

[Coach Travis]

I personally hate policy lynches, mostly because I feel you should vote on who you actually find scummy, not on who you want out because they can't help. Yes, anti-town players are a problem, but wasting a lynch on someone you think could be town, is not a good idea, because if you keep doing that, the scum can just hide in the shadows and win the game easily. So just for suggesting such a thing, I'm not liking rajrhcpfreak, though I'm not sure if he's scummy or it's just a difference in playstyle. No read on Razgriz yet, because what he did is totally null. Antihero looks town to me so far, since he was the one to point out mongoose, and the rest of his post was also pretty good.



And yeah, that one post from mongoose was bad and probably the only really suspicious thing so far,

Vote:mongoose

[Antihero]

I really hate the "I was just testing you" argument.

So, I guess you just prefer an RVS which spirals into a crappy theory debate about policy lynches...
Also, I was hoping others besides you would comment on it (I wasn't expecting bandwagoning votes; that actually would have sent up some red flags for me).

Yes, the whole point of RVS is to test people and evaluate their reactions, but Antihero's response seems more like a "Crap, no one jumped on the bandwagon. Time to move on."

If you look at my meta, you'll see this isn't the case (inhim has seen it before). And also, I think you could figure that this isn't the case from the ridiculously contrived reasoning.

@inhim: "<3"? What's less than 3?

[inHimshallibe]

):

It's a heart.

[rajrhcpfreak]

as much as i love a good bandwagon there isnt enough for me to switch. i would like to hear more from mongoose. looks like most of his posts have joke undertones and random stuff.

[rajrhcpfreak]

inhim you do smiley faces incorrectly.

[Mariyta]

I really hate the "I was just testing you" argument.

So, I guess you just prefer an RVS which spirals into a crappy theory debate about policy lynches...
Also, I was hoping others besides you would comment on it (I wasn't expecting bandwagoning votes; that actually would have sent up some red flags for me).

Yes, the whole point of RVS is to test people and evaluate their reactions, but Antihero's response seems more like a "Crap, no one jumped on the bandwagon. Time to move on."

If you look at my meta, you'll see this isn't the case (inhim has seen it before). And also, I think you could figure that this isn't the case from the ridiculously contrived reasoning.

I didn't say it wasn't a valid scumhunting method. I just don't like it. Especially when you give in so easily. My apologies for not keeping quiet til scum jumped on. Next time I'll give the fish time to bite.

I don't like meta play. People are constantly learning/evolving and I don't feel that looking at past games is as helpful for me as it may be for others.

[Antihero]

I personally hate policy lynches, mostly because I feel you should vote on who you actually find scummy, not on who you want out because they can't help. Yes, anti-town players are a problem, but wasting a lynch on someone you think could be town, is not a good idea, because if you keep doing that, the scum can just hide in the shadows and win the game easily. So just for suggesting such a thing, I'm not liking rajrhcpfreak, though I'm not sure if he's scummy or it's just a difference in playstyle. No read on Razgriz yet, because what he did is totally null. Antihero looks town to me so far, since he was the one to point out mongoose, and the rest of his post was also pretty good.



And yeah, that one post from mongoose was bad and probably the only really suspicious thing so far,

Vote:mongoose

This wagon jump looks kind of shady to me because you don't say anything about about why mongoose's post was bad. IGMEOY too.

[GhostWriter]

Not to mention the whole "and the rest of his post was also pretty good" bit.

[Kdub]

This post pinged on my scumdar a bit. Kdub isn't calling inhim out on a scumslip, but instead seems annoyed that inhim has such an early townread on freak. IGMEOY

It wasn't my intention to call a scumslip. I really wanted to know why he had a town read so early. And I should point out that he didn't even answer the question.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: inHim

Ignoring questions is scummy IMO.

[horrordude0215]

He is town based on what exactly?

This post pinged on my scumdar a bit. Kdub isn't calling inhim out on a scumslip, but instead seems annoyed that inhim has such an early townread on freak. IGMEOY

I don't really agree with you here... Questioning why people give town reads without reasons is a good reason to question someone...

Inhimshallibe, I really don't like your post 57. You don't do anything except quote a post, make a smiley, and seem to jump on a bandwagon. At least saying why you agree with the post would be decent.

FoS

for you.

Yes, anti-town players are a problem, but wasting a lynch on someone you think could be town, is not a good idea, because if you keep doing that, the scum can just hide in the shadows and win the game easily.

Something I noticed here... Why would you lynch someone you think could be town?

So just for suggesting such a thing, I'm not liking rajrhcpfreak, though I'm not sure if he's scummy or it's just a difference in playstyle.

Wishy-Washy blah blah blah.

No read on Razgriz yet, because what he did is totally null.

Can someone explain what Exactly Raz did? I'm still confused about that lol.

And yeah, that one post from mongoose was bad and probably the only really suspicious thing so far, Vote:mongoose

I'm seeing this as slightly opportunistic and parroty-ish.

Minor FoS

So, I guess you just prefer an RVS which spirals into a crappy theory debate about policy lynches...

Was this an attack on me or something? That's what it's looking like...

UNVOTE:
VOTE: inHim

Ignoring questions is scummy IMO.

inHim's post looks like an RVS comment to me... I don't really know why the question was asked in the first place...

[Antihero]

So, I guess you just prefer an RVS which spirals into a crappy theory debate about policy lynches...

Was this an attack on me or something? That's what it's looking like...

No, it was an attack on jason's last post. The world doesn't revolve around you, you know.

[mongoose]

unvote, vote coach travis

All right, I don't post too much and that post was a bit short and didn't contribute much. The point of the post was to try and figure out what the point of the whole policy lynch thing was. At that point I really didn't have a point to make about anything else, since I wasn't getting any reads.

Coach travis says my post was bad and suspicious, but doesnt really explain, right after he agrees with my post. He also says anti hero is town because his post was good. Again, no explanation. He also hasn't made any serious posts outside of this one.

And hes a Raiders fan.

[jasonT1981]

guys, I am really sorry however I have to replace out, there has been a death in my family and I will not be about too much to play mafia. Again, I am sorry. The mod has been notified.

Jason

[GhostWriter]

My condolences, Jason. I wish you the best.

[GhostWriter]

Coach travis says my post was bad and suspicious, but doesnt really explain

Polly wanna cracker?

right after he agrees with my post.

I don't see it.

He also says anti hero is town because his post was good. Again, no explanation.

I totally referenced that, Polly.

He also hasn't made any serious posts outside of this one.

And hes a Raiders fan.

Pot calling kettle black, plus a little extra pointless joke to attempt to lighten up the post right after having talked about someone not having serious posts. Lovely.

I didn't like his post, and I'm still decided whether I like your post even less or not. I probably will.

[Antihero]

@jason: I'm sorry to hear that, my condolences as well.

GW's post above = goodposting

[Mariyta]

I'm so sorry, Jason. My thoughts are with you.


I'd like to hear what Razgriz has to say about the Mongoose wagon. I'm torn between the two at the moment. They both are posting w/o saying a whole lot.