NY 118 - BBM's Large Normal Mafia (Game!)

[Xite91]

I willing to lynch dana today, but I'm also willing to take a new look at Xite. The fact that every lynch he's headed has been a mislynch is really starting to look suspicious.

But you've been one of my main followers IIRC... that looks a bit suspicious if that's how you feel. (dunno if I can explain this better)

[DemonHybrid]

Haha, Dana's still going at it.

Vote: danakillsu

[Gorrad]

Shanba: Have you made a case and I missed it?

[danakillsu]

wow 5 votes already. Well I guess this pretty much spells the end. Thank God it's not lylo, because town still has a chance after I get lynched. Thanks for at least giving me another night to investigate. C ya on the other side.
Danakillsu

[Wraith]

I willing to lynch dana today, but I'm also willing to take a new look at Xite. The fact that every lynch he's headed has been a mislynch is really starting to look suspicious.

But you've been one of my main followers IIRC... that looks a bit suspicious if that's how you feel. (dunno if I can explain this better)

There's the fact that Robb indeed flipped town, which I really did not expect. I might have misjudged you, and at the moment it is certainly plausible that you could be a very good DSP.

[Wraith]

Top suspects at the moment (in order):

Dana
DemonHybrid
Xite
Prozac

[evilpacman18]

vote: danakillsu

Lol.

[evilpacman18]

So dana is pretty much confirmed scum now. Anybody gonna check for possible affiliations with other players? I don't have the time.

[Flameaxe]

Votecount 4.1

Dana [6] (Gorrad, Shanba, Wraith, Xite, DemonHybrid, evilpacman)

Hiphop [1] (Dana)

Not Voting [8] (My Milked Eek, Hiphop, Singersigner, Antihero, Flinter, Lowell, Bunnylover)

15 alive, 8 to lynch, 8 to no lynch.

[Bunnylover]

24 people, and we think their is going to be only 1 cop?
I would rather kill Hip-hop (or whoever his replacement is)
Most likely watch it flip scum, allow Dana to live, eventually he going to have to out another of his scum buddy to keep alive, and we just keep doing this until Dana is the only one left and then you all can go crazy and lynch him.

[Lowell]

I guess maybe I'm a sucker, but I tend to agree with bunny. I still think dana still isnt' the lynch tonight.

vote hiphop

[Shanba]

I dunno if you guys come from different metas or whatnot, but the dead we have now - plus the implied masonbuddy - is pretty much the limit for town power roles in a normal game this size. I'd be surprised if we had anything else at all, frankly - especially with the super backup. Two cops, a doc and a backup? That's pushing the limits of credulity. Non-sane cops and a backup in a normal game? Again, that would be incredibly unusual. Even if you don't trust my scumhunting skills, trust that I've played enough games here to have a feel for these things.

Gorrad, no case yet. I'm debating whether to bring one today or tomorrow. I'm worried that if I do it today, it'll get swallowed up in the quicklynch and the impact will be dulled. But I'd like to get it out before I get nightkilled. I dunno.

[Wraith]

I say we lynch dana now, lynch hiphop tomorrow. If dana is trying to save his own skin by bussing a scumbuddy it's an awful strategy.

[Bunnylover]

well the reason I'm not pushing for his lynch, is because Kise did not vote him.
Kise would obviously search the person who is claiming to be his role, and since he never put a vote on Dana, that must mean he got an innocent on him.
Kise wouldn't want to reveal himself unless necessary to save Dana, which would cause them both to most likely die in the end.
Kise also had his vote on Porochaz, saying he was godfather. Kise probably searched Porochaz and got innocent on him, but didn't believe it. Its possible for someone to have GF role, but I don't think we should look into it atm.

Vote: Hip-Hp

@Shanba: Although it is a bit of a stretch to have this many roles, I think it still has a chance to make it plausible that we need to take into consideration. I am not saying you are wrong, but even if Dana is scum, he will have to continue to give up his scum buddies to save himself.

Also, who did you investigate Dana? I don't know if you posted it and I just missed it or you haven't posted it yet.

[Wraith]

Dana got a guilty on hiphop. If you didn't know that, why are you voting for him?

FoS: Bunnylover

Also, I highly doubt Kise and dana knew each other were cops.

[Bunnylover]

I'm voting Hiphop, because Dana got a guilty on him.
Doesn't guilty mean scum?
No, I believe Kise knew Dana was the cop.
I don't know if Dana knew Kise was the cop.

[Bunnylover]

I should say was a cop, not the cop.

[Wraith]

I'm voting Hiphop, because Dana got a guilty on him.
Doesn't guilty mean scum?
No, I believe Kise knew Dana was the cop.
I don't know if Dana knew Kise was the cop.

Yet, in the same post you voted hiphop, you also asked dana what his results were, directly contradicting this post. Why are you lying?

[Bunnylover]

lmao I feel like an idiot.
I honestly don't have anything to say to that.
I wasn't lieing on purpose, it was an honest mistake, but I can understand your suspicion due to that.
The only thing I can think of why I directly said that Dana found Hip-Hop scum, then asked for his investigation is due to the head ache I had, but that really isn't a good excuse.

[Antihero]

While I do have a bad taste in my mouth from the WIFOM fest from yesterday, I think the Kise flip pretty much kills dana's credibility.

It also should be fairly obvious at this point that bunny is scum. preview edit - but I do hope your headache gets better, bunny

VOTE: danakillsu

[Flameaxe]

Baby Spice in for Hiphop.

[Bunnylover]

@Mod, do we have to vote for Baby Spice or will our vote still count?

[Flameaxe]

Any votes before 1845 will count.

[Antihero]

No, I believe Kise knew Dana was the cop.

What's with this then?

I don't think it's wrong to lynch dana at this point. Roleblocking a claimed cop for 2 nights would make sense if Benmage & nhammen are not aligned with dana. Xite's iffy stance on the matter is noteworthy, and could implicate him later if dana flips scum.

D2, I mentioned that out of Mysterio and Wraith, Wraith was the likelier one to be scum, and also a viable bus for his scumbuddies. The combination of Benmage (known scum) and Xite (probable scum if dana is scum) on Wraith's wagon makes my little "equation" add up, so to speak. If I can run my mouth (err, fingers) for a bit, I think a reasonable lynch sequence would be dana > xite > wraith, if and ONLY IF the former player(s) in the sequence flip scum. It comes down to being one of those scenarios where there's no questions asked. Just do it.


I haven't forgotten about you, Poro. For the time being, there are other.. more interesting developments. I was wrong about Wicked, so, who knows whether I'm wrong with you. That would mean my Godfather-hunting skills are not perfected like I thought they were. BTW, I still need students to take under my wing

[Baby Spice]

Baby Spice in for Hiphop.

One of these days I'm going to write myself a killer Dr. Who style regeneration sequence for when I replace into a game.

Unvote

just in case hiphop left a vote hanging.