Mini 1056 - NFL Mafia (Game Over)

[horrordude0215]

Back, sorry. Internet's still off and on. Gonna try to stay on long enough to read

[mongoose]

Mongoose: tell me why you got lynched in Boondox. Was your gameplay very similar to here?

I would have gotten lynched if it wasn't for the mass claim. Yes it was.

Well, ghost said I shouldn't "parrot" other people, so I didn't. And because of that i get lynched. Remind me why saying I have a bad feel about someone is scummy, but when raj, antihero, and others who get "town vibes" aren't scummy?

[charter]

VOTE COUNT

mongoose - 5 (Coach Travis, GhostWriter, inHimshallibe, Antihero, Mariyta)
inHimshallibe - 1 (Kdub)
drmyshottyizsik - 2 (rajrhcpfreak, jimfinn)
GhostWriter - 1 (horrordude0215)
Kdub - 2 (Locke Lamora, drmyshottyizsik)
horrordude0215 - 1 (mongoose)

NOT VOTING

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch! Deadline is October 3rd, Noon.

[drmyshottyizsik]

Oh wait, I forgot to read page 7. never mind. I'm pretty sure hes town, as stated above.

lawlz

[drmyshottyizsik]

i agree with coach travis in the fact that the case on Kdub is very weak and I really don't think he is that scummy. He pretty much took the words out of my mouth. Also, I do agree with antihero about horrordude. His tends to respond to inquisition by questions of his own. Also, his pots just seem off.

unvote;vote horrordude

God stop being scum and talk for your self

[drmyshottyizsik]

Can I hammer?
Please? I know he's L-2 but I want the hammer

[rajrhcpfreak]

i find mongoose scumy. but the three previous votes are exactly why im not putting my vote on there.
how about a claim mongoose.

[rajrhcpfreak]

three previous posts, not votes

[Coach Travis]

Yeah, I don't blame you for keeping your vote on Shotty, he's gone back to his old ways after starting off with an uncharacteristically decent post. The thing is, while he's certainly acting anti-town at this point which is not a good thing, it's really hard to determine if he's scummy or not, because he plays like this all the time. So lynching him would almost be a policy lynch, which is the only reason I'm happy to keep my vote on mongoose, see what he turns up as and then go from there, because with him I am getting a scum read, where with Shotty it's more "WTF Shotty' than anything else.

[Antihero]

no I didn't. Horror is just my third choice. I am still figuring him out, but i am pretty sure kdub is scum

Wait...what?

The amount of crappy piggybacking on the horrordude suspicion is really making me doubt my scumread on him.

shotty's chainsaw defense + the above post = shotty/CT scumpair

[Coach Travis]

How did you come to that conclusion? You can't say I'm distancing because I haven't gone after him more than anyone else who isn't liking him, and my last wasn't exactly defending him, I admitted he's been awful and his playstyle has been anti-town. I just don't think his behavior automatically makes him scummy, because he pulls this same crap in every game he's in, regardless of his role. so it's really hard to get a clear read on him He's still one of my three suspects, so nothing's changed there, I just think right now that out of the three he's the one I'm less sure of. So I don't see how you could think we're partners.

[Kdub]

This post is so f'ing full of opinions, fluff and mis rep, and on top of that you come of as scummy. I have bolded why.

News flash: opinions are an important part of playing mafia. And your comment about pressure votes is valid in general, but CT's vote clearly wasn't simply a pressure vote, otherwise he would have said so in his explanation, right?

I think it's mongoose, kdub, and horror. And I gave reasons

Did you for horror? If I missed them, please point me to them.

no I didn't. Horror is just my third choice. I am still figuring him out, but i am pretty sure kdub is scum

...
This is such a blatant contradiction that I'm not even sure whether to call it scummy or VI play. Also, you didn't even give reasons for suspecting mongoose, who you are suddenly eager to hammer. How about you give those reasons that you said you gave but actually didn't?

Still not seeing mongoose as scummy. Unhelpful perhaps, but I don't like the wagon on him because a lot of the votes on him have looked opportunistic. CT's initial vote on him has been brought up already, and inHim has contributed almost nothing all game until his last post against mongoose. I'm sticking with those two as my top suspects, though to be fair, CT's recent posts have been better with the explanations, but that could be a response to the negative attention he got for his initial vote. Last suspect would probably be drmyshotty for the above quotes. I don't particularly like Mari's reaction to my post about her and jim, but I doubt there are four scum, so she's on the bubble.

[Locke Lamora]

Having read SSB Mafia, I think scum-mongoose works harder than this.

Shotty: your Kdub 'case' is ridiculous. That's got to be the weakest collection of scumtells I've ever seen. You're just plain wrong with the majority of it. Your failure to comment on anything other than a few Kdub remarks and your eagerness to hammer mongoose don't do you any favours either.

Unvote; Vote: drmyshottyizsik

[mongoose]

unvote. vote: shotty

those posts were scummy beyond belief.

Raj, how will a claim help?

[Mariyta]

unvote. vote: shotty

those posts were scummy beyond belief.

Raj, how will a claim help?

Could it be that we've found two scum this early in the game? Shotty is being the nice scum and votes for someone else, while mongoose is clearly fine with bussing his partner. Now who do we want to lynch first? Tough decision. I'll be gone all day, but when I get home, I'll decide.

[Mariyta]

Eff it. UNVOTE: mongoose, VOTE: Shotty

[jimfinn]

I'm leaving my vote on DMSIS in light of his recent posts. Only for scum does it really make a difference who is the hammer, in my experience. Scum want towncred for hammering their buddy, but the town doesn't care who hammers as long as the scum dies.

[inHimshallibe]

I'm not opposed to this.

unvote
vote: shotty

Claimzorz?

[rajrhcpfreak]

inhim, you dont think that shotty/mongoose/coach pick three is possible?
seams like its too easy.

[Coach Travis]

I believe Shotty's at L-1 now. I'm willing to hammer, since he is on my list of suspects, but I'll at least him give a chance to make one more post first, if only to see how hilarious it will be.

[inHimshallibe]

inhim, you dont think that shotty/mongoose/coach pick three is possible?
seams like its too easy.

Well, I'm certainly of the opinion that any of them would be a good lynch Today.

I'd most prefer mongoose, because even his shotty vote was a parrot. shotty next because his behavior is way too erratic. To me it seems that when people noticed that shotty's first post was vastly different from his normal play, shotty went "ohshit" and reverted into classic, nigh unreadable shotty. Coach Travis: I just don't have an obvtown read on him, so his lynch is better than others.

[Antihero]

@shotty: Next post, claim.

@freak: Who else is on your scumdar, then?

[drmyshottyizsik]

Claim, Tight End,
I act as a town role blocker

[Antihero]

Um, shotty, there's not a roleblocker aspect to that role. The role PMs are posted the second post.

Nice try, scum.

UNVOTE: mongoose
VOTE: drmyshottyizsik

[inHimshallibe]

LOL