Mini 1046 - Murder in the Desert (Game Over!)

[DemonHybrid]

And I'm the doctor. It was nice knowing you.

So what do you guys think? We sure as hell can't have all townies.

[DemonHybrid]

VT. I'll need two skills.

What do you mean by this?

[Nicodemus]

Vote Count 3.03

Socrates

(1): WeaponsofMassConstruction

Not Voting:

boberz, charter, DemonHybrid, Lowell, Slaxx, Socrates, Xine

5

to lynch.

Deadline for D3 can be found here

[DemonHybrid]

Well, I'm kinda looking at bobz, Lowell and Soc. I'm willing to look past charter's willingness to mass claim, and Slaxx has been nothing but townish all game.

I of course believe Xine's claim. I think if we do take care of the three aforementioned, we'll hit at least one scum and then make the necessary connections.

I suggest lynching bob/Lowell/Soc, Xine tracks one of the remaining two. Roleblocker's dead, so this makes things pretty clear cut and I think we have a good chance of wrapping this game up.

Soc/bob/Lowell, please give 1 post each on why you shouldn't be lynched, who your biggest suspicion is and why with a clear case and evidence to boot.

[DemonHybrid]

EBWOP: I don't care for the order.

[Slaxx]

Lowell should get in here and provide a nice long post about scum reads and why...I will also do my part and reread.

I trust Demon's claim 100%.

I trust Xine's claim about 90%.

The reason for the difference is that Xine could be a mafia tracker, even though I doubt it. But regardless she followed DH and confirmed him.


Slaxx's game plan: Hope we lynch scum today, then Xine tracks whoever she wants cleared with her in endgame.

If not, same plan really.

[Slaxx]

I really thought Charter was a PR.

[DemonHybrid]

I think Lowell's claim is kinda sketchy. "I'm a VT, I need two skills"

First part = everyone calls themselves "Townies", as per the VT role PM. He doesn't.

Second part doesn't make any sense.

So, let me give you an incentive to making that REALLY important and mandatory case and defense, Lowell.

Vote: Lowell

[DemonHybrid]

Cool.

I claim vanilla townie if it matters.

In that light, as well, WMC needs a special mention for his claim.

[Slaxx]

Meh I was going to claim Vanilla Townie but I decided to be cute and copy exactly what charter said except replace it with second. I wouldn't make a case out of it.

Not that Lowell doesn't have his fair share ox explaining to do, because he does.

[DemonHybrid]

Meh I was going to claim Vanilla Townie but I decided to be cute and copy exactly what charter said except replace it with second. I wouldn't make a case out of it.

Not that Lowell doesn't have his fair share ox explaining to do, because he does.

Quoting role PMs are bad bad bad. Mine says just Doctor though, like Townie. No Town prefix.

The biggest downfall of those fakeclaiming VT are those who never read the VT PM in the start. =) Keep that in mind.

If we happen to lynch Lowell, then I'm thinking WMC needs a track. I'm protecting Xine either way; she is getting her track.

[Slaxx]

I never read my role PM or pay attention to the wording :/

And I didn't quote the role PM D:

And about your FoS....Lowell needs to explain the two skills part, because that sounds like a chunk of a different role PM.

[Slaxx]

-Read the flavor of my role PM

[DemonHybrid]

And I didn't quote the role PM D:

I know you didn't. Just saying, you did the right thing.

[DemonHybrid]

And I didn't quote the role PM D:

I know you didn't. Just saying, you did the right thing.

EBWOP: I read "charter" as Nicodemus. So, that quote the role PM thing is just me being a dummy.

Carry on.

[DemonHybrid]

WOMC, I'm adding you to the list of people who need to post a defense and a case on your biggest suspicion.

So, waiting on all four of you.

[charter]

To be honest, I looked at the first post to see what it said, but I don't think saying townie or vanilla means much in a game like this. Alright, the claim of doc is believable, though I seriously question you choice of Xine. That was a bad target to protect.

Sooo, I think that it's two of boberz, lowell, weapons, and Socrates... It's possible Xine is mafia, but a mafia tracker and roleblocker against just a doctor and watcher seems very unlikely. Time to go reread, YET AGAIN.

Xine, why did you track Demon, that doesn't make much sense. Socrates was the good choice of who to target, which we agreed on yesterday.

Also, just as an aside, Weapons's first post today looks mightily like bussing then tying me to Socrates to mislynch me the next day. I also just went and ISO'ed WEapons, and this jumped out at me.

Okay, so Xine lynch isn't happening? This is rather disappointing.

Which roles are commonly included in a setup with a tracker, or are there any?

And in my opinion, Slaxx's soft claim seems very...calculated.

His fishing question there is pretty megascummy. No one bit, and he later claimed vanilla. I dunno, just seems... Fishy..
Anyway, I want to hear who Lowell and Soc and Boberz are suspicious of before I reread and tell them who I'm suspicious of.

[DemonHybrid]

Stop tunneling Xine. She's town. She tracked me because I might have looked somewhat scummy after xvart's lynch.

Can we focus?

[DemonHybrid]

Like I said, I would like the 4 that I mentioned (Lowell, WOMC, Soc, boberz) to post why they shouldn't be lynched, their biggest suspect and a case on that suspect with evidence. I would ask that everyone hold comments until after the aforementioned 4 post their cases and defenses.

[WeaponsofMassConstruction]

Which roles are commonly included in a setup with a tracker, or are there any?

And in my opinion, Slaxx's soft claim seems very...calculated.

[/quote]

Do you see the connection between these two lines?

I see boberz and Lowell as obvtown and have already given cases on Socrates/charter.

[DemonHybrid]

So, Lowell and WOMC lynches then?

Or will you actually give us the defense/case?

[WeaponsofMassConstruction]

You're kidding, right?

[DemonHybrid]

You're kidding, right?

I would like a fresh new case on your biggest suspicion, not many small suspicions. I would like a reason as to why you should not be lynched. If you have posted evidence and don't want to bring it up again, then point me to a post # and we'll go and check it out.

You can't just say "I already posted it. These people are obv town", that isn't what I asked for.

[WeaponsofMassConstruction]

Check #25, 28, and 41 in my iso. Stuff on stuff after that point will come later.

As for my defense, wth. I'm town?

Also, why are you only requesting reads from your targets? Everyone should participate, including you, who should set an example.

[DemonHybrid]

Check #25, 28, and 41 in my iso.

Stuff on stuff after that point will come later.

As for my defense, wth. I'm town?

Also, why are you only requesting reads from your targets? Everyone should participate, including you, who should set an example.

Was looking for the bold. Don't forget that.

Also, I'll do it if it makes you feel more comfortable. Give me some time to make my argument.