Mini 1049 - Hide and Seek Mafia - FINAL Kablooie!

[Katsuki]

Drunk posting and trying to clear your scum partner?

THIS IS YOUR DERP STATEMENT.

[tanstalas]

Drunk posting and trying to clear your scum partner?

THIS IS YOUR DERP STATEMENT.

Trying to even it out for you since all of your posts for the last few days have been DERP posts

[mikeburnfire]

Work + More work + College + Marine Corps = No free time.

I will have a proper post on Sunday night.

[camn]

By the way... My instinct?
If Katsu is town, scum would have jumped on the wagon by now.
If Katsu IS scum, her partners are NOT on the wagon right now, and are lurking. Which is almost certainly the case. Scum wouldn't be letting a mislynch lose steam, IMO.

Let's lynch her, check the flip, and catch the rest of the scum with their pants down.

[Katsuki]

Unless, the scum are already on the wagon. Which they most probably are.

This is not a townie driven wagon.

[Katsuki]

Working on mini-analysis, dunno when it will be complete. Gotta leave for airport.

[jenniwren]

Drunk posts are always fun to read.

By the way... My instinct?
If Katsu is town, scum would have jumped on the wagon by now.
If Katsu IS scum, her partners are NOT on the wagon right now, and are lurking. Which is almost certainly the case. Scum wouldn't be letting a mislynch lose steam, IMO.

Let's lynch her, check the flip, and catch the rest of the scum with their pants down.

If she's scum then there's only one scum left. There would only be more than one if she flips town.

Hm. Thinking. More to come.

[camn]

Unless, the scum are already on the wagon. Which they most probably are.

This is not a townie driven wagon.

Then where are they? Why do they let the game smolder?
And what makes it scum-driven?
I, for one, would LOVE it if you would start acting like a townie.. But you persist in acting like scum.
Where is your defense? Where is your indignation? Where is your righteous town fury?

I don't see it.

[Katsuki]

That's where the analysis comes in now doesn't it. It's still being worked on.

p.s. Remaining scum is most likely you and jenn.

Also, my righteous town fury already came and gone. At this point, I wouldn't mind my lynch, as I need to free up a mini spot. However, that has to wait until AFTER I post my stuff and have my say.

[jenniwren]

I thought Tans was scum?

[Ellibereth]

Catching up...

[tanstalas]

I thought Tans was scum?

I was wondering the same thing...

[Ellibereth]

I lied, will have to do this tomorrow night. >.>

[TheButtonmen]

Sorry for the delay and the terrible formatting, I'm having to reread a whole game at the moment so it's cutting into my mafia time for the tonight / tommorrow.

In a chronological and some what PBPA style here's why I think Far cry is the lynch o' the day.

This post seems to be distancing, though Vezo's idea was bad it seemed like he jumped on too quickly.

Then he proceeds to defend Vezo as a VI, which is strange given his previous entry to Vezo wagon based on Vezo making a bad suggestion.

He then unvotes for no real reason.

And then starts the mongoose wagon, note while he recognized and defended Vezo as VI he doesn't see mongoose as a VI.

Budja is replaced.

His response to Mike replacing in is odd because as he later explains.

In his other game with Mike, Mike was the best town. Which makes his "OH SHIT" really weird

MBF is then the target of the NK.

When giving his list of reads he uses reasoning like "Your town because you haven't done anything scummy yet" which to me sound like "I can't find anything to attack you with" and he is again certain that Vezo is scum.

When Elli pressures Vezo, Far Cry coaches him.

When the whole Kats vs Tants fight happens he attacks Kats but never puts down a vote, in fact during all this he isn't voting anyone.

He then latches onto Ellis idea of a lurker lynch despite been quite confident that Kats is qutie scummy. Note he had also just previously been attacking Elli too.

And then there is this little bit; watch him wiffle waffle to what ever is popular.

Compare THIS post and THIS post made latter.

[tanstalas]

@ TBM - So who is FC's partner then?

[camn]

I'm sold.

unvote
Vote Far_Cry

Play better tomorrow, kats.
For everyone.
For yourself.

The "I've given up, please lynch me" attitude sucks, btw. Replace out if you can't keep your heart in the game.

[tanstalas]

Starting to wonder if MPR AND DGB flaked from this game - MPR hasn't posted since monday and I have yet to see DGB respond to me asking for a prod on him

When players flake its one thing when mods flake...

Is there a backup mod this game?

[MehPlusRawr]

Bleh, I've been reading, just don't have much to say. I didn't realize it had been so long, though.

[camn]

Hush your mouth tans. DGB would never.

[DrippingGoofball]

YOUR TENTH VOTECOUNT was cowering under the bed! 'Nuff trash talk, tanstalas!

Katsuki (3): tanstalas, Pomegranate, jenniwren
tanstalas (2): Katsuki, mikeburnfire
Far_Cry (2): The Buttonmen, camn
MehPlusRawr (1): Ellibereth

With 10 players, it's 6 to lynch...

[Far_Cry]

Sorry for the delay and the terrible formatting, I'm having to reread a whole game at the moment so it's cutting into my mafia time for the tonight / tommorrow.

In a chronological and some what PBPA style here's why I think Far cry is the lynch o' the day.

This post seems to be distancing, though Vezo's idea was bad it seemed like he jumped on too quickly.

Then he proceeds to defend Vezo as a VI, which is strange given his previous entry to Vezo wagon based on Vezo making a bad suggestion.

He then unvotes for no real reason.

And then starts the mongoose wagon, note while he recognized and defended Vezo as VI he doesn't see mongoose as a VI.

Budja is replaced.

His response to Mike replacing in is odd because as he later explains.

In his other game with Mike, Mike was the best town. Which makes his "OH SHIT" really weird

MBF is then the target of the NK.

When giving his list of reads he uses reasoning like "Your town because you haven't done anything scummy yet" which to me sound like "I can't find anything to attack you with" and he is again certain that Vezo is scum.

When Elli pressures Vezo, Far Cry coaches him.

When the whole Kats vs Tants fight happens he attacks Kats but never puts down a vote, in fact during all this he isn't voting anyone.

He then latches onto Ellis idea of a lurker lynch despite been quite confident that Kats is qutie scummy. Note he had also just previously been attacking Elli too.

And then there is this little bit; watch him wiffle waffle to what ever is popular.

Compare THIS post and THIS post made latter.

OK, here we go:

1. I enter the game, just give an oh shit comment against MBF, and than now I get attacked for it. I'm simply pointing out my experience with him.

2. MBF's room get's bombed. Just a second. If I was scum and really wanted to get rid of MBF, why would I bomb his room? Chances are he's not going to be in there.

Anyways, I'm not sure what exactly your trying to say with this. Are you trying to say that I think MBF is good town, and he's going to hunt me down, and as a result, I wanted to kill him?

3. My reads on people were vague, that's for sure. But that's because I didn't have anything real sufficient against them (with the exception of vezo.) What makes you think I'm scum not going either way or unsure town?

And you're saying that me knowing that vezo is scum means I was his partner bussing him? I ask how you reach such a certain conclusion.

4. Elli's idea was simply wrong in asking vezo to claim. It would not make any difference to town what his role was at that moment.

5. Once again, I never put down a vote because I'm not sure what to think quite yet. Kats, Elli, and Tans are possible suspects, and I'm not sure who to vote for now. Not understanding what is wrong with that.

6. What makes those two posts different. Are they contradictory or what?

You previously stated that jenni and I are scum. What makes jenni scum? And why do you link us together?

I think you need to put more of your own personal input to prove that I'm scum. Because at the moment, I'm not getting any vibe.

[TheButtonmen]

2. MBF's room get's bombed. Just a second. If I was scum and really wanted to get rid of MBF, why would I bomb his room? Chances are he's not going to be in there.

Anyways, I'm not sure what exactly your trying to say with this. Are you trying to say that I think MBF is good town, and he's going to hunt me down, and as a result, I wanted to kill him?

Yes.

I think you need to put more of your own personal input to prove that I'm scum. Because at the moment, I'm not getting any vibe.

Your not getting a scummy vibe from yourself.....

No shit really?

[Far_Cry]

Don't try to be funny. When I said that about vibe, I'm talking from a general point of view. As another, neutral person looking at the game, you didn't make a strong case against me.

And you ignored what I asked you to do: to give me a personal summary of my actions and why they are scummy. Not just give vague comments about posts.

[TheButtonmen]

So your defense is that I haven't convinced you that you're scum.

Wonderful, I'll keep that in mind.

Flail more scum, flail more.

@Elli:

Why the lurking trend this game?

@MPR:

Your last real post was on the 23rd, mind actually playing the game?

@Pom:

I'm used to your slightly lurky nature but this game is much worse then normal.

[Pomegranate]

I've skimmed the thread. I'll post something tomorrow, but right now,

@Pom:

I'm used to your slightly lurky nature but this game is much worse then normal.

There are quite a few Jewish holidays at this time of year (and I think I announced when I'd be V/LA). But my activity should go back to normal now that they've ended.

--

If/When we claim our night actions, I think that we ought to keep in mind that the Mafia member who plants the bomb cannot hide on that night, IIRC.