Mini #1022- PokeUPick(Game Over)

[Robocopter87]

It is now Day Five.

[Prox]

Ok, now I'm a little worried. Please don't tell me what I hope didn't happen happened.

[Andrius]

I got a magikarp.

[Prox]

:S This is bad.

[Espeonage]

I got a magikarp.

[SnakePlissken]

What does that mean?

[Espeonage]

It means me and Andrius are town.

[Espeonage]

btw snake. The gandalf flip really isn't good for you. I would start trying to explain what Nicol was doing earlier.

[Prox]

Let's not WIFOM.

[Espeonage]

How is that wifom?

[mikeburnfire]

Super busy today, but glad we killed Gandalf. Shocked he was a Godfather and not a roleblocker, though. Something's not quite right about that. More later.

[SnakePlissken]

It means me and Andrius are town.

How so?

And I haven't read back on Nicol to be able comment properly. The other thing is I haven't had a mail on my night action either?

All I can see in regards to Gandalf that when Nicol used a Focus Blast, which turned out to be an investigation he got the innocent result back. I assumed he was. Never thought he would be a GF.

So where are we looking now? Don't say me either, I mean by the Gandalf flip who else does this point the finger at?

[mikeburnfire]

Player	Status	Role	N1 action	N2 Action	N3 Action	N4 Action
drmy	Lynched D1	Town Lightning Rod	-	-	-	-
vezokpiraka	Stabbed N1	Town Cop	?	-	-	-
jimfinn	Lynched D2	Town Thief	Confirm Esp flavor	-	-	-
Bv	Stabbed N2	Vanilla Townie	-	-	-	-
Xite	Lynched D3	Bulletproof Townie	-	-	-	-
Gandalf	Lynched D4	Mafia Godfather	"Blocked Esp"	"Blocked Jarti"	"Blocked Jarti"	-
Snake/Nicol	Alive	Claimed JoaT	"Gandalf=Innocent"	Forfeit	"Blocked Prox"	?
Prox	Alive	Claimed Nexus	-	-	-	-
Espeonage	Alive	Claimed MagikarpGiver	Gave to Gandalf	Gave to Gandalf	Forfeit	Gave to Andrius
Jarti	Alive	Claimed "Switch"	"Turn on switch"	Forfeit	Forfeit	?
Andrius	Alive	Claimed Vanilla Townie	-	-	-	-
MBF	Alive	Claimed "Redirector"	Vezok Gandalf	Andrius Bv	Gandalf Andrius	Forfeit

I have opinions on who scum could be, but I think voting no lynch to get an odd number is a good move for today. Thoughts?

[SnakePlissken]

Is it ever wise to vote no lynch? Doesn't it give the mafia an advantage and take away our chance of taking them out? I'm open to having my mind changed but vie always understood it to be a bad town play?

[mikeburnfire]

Statistically speaking, yes, there are times when voting no lynch is a good idea.
http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=No_lynch
What was your action last night, Snake? And how do you think Gandalf's flip affects you?

[Espeonage]

No lynch is a good option here as we don't actually lose a lynch, we just lower the amount of people to choose from by one.

[SnakePlissken]

My action was a dream eater last night at Jarti, but it didn't seem to have worked so I assume someone role blocked me?

Gandalfs flip doesn't affect me as he was revealed as a Godfather thus explaining the Innocent verdict. It's one less mafia to find.

[mikeburnfire]

What is "Dream Eater"? Vig? Protection?

[SnakePlissken]

Oh sorry, turns out it's a kill. But like I said it doesn't to appeared to have worked.

[SnakePlissken]

Crap I've just noticed that Gandalf was blocking Jarti which confirms town. Just as well it didn't work. Well by my thoughts then looking at your table Mike I would say its either Andrius or Prox who are the scum. If not both.

[SnakePlissken]

Yawn.

I softclaimed miller for reasons just like this.

If I hadn't already claimed, things would be a lot more precarious for me when the NK was stopped after someone targetted me for a Roleblock.

If a cop had targetted me instead, he would have likely decided that I was scum.

I could have claimed nexus after the event, but that wouldn't have been as effective, and I probably would have been lynched.

***

I do NOT think my claim was terribly bad play at all.

And this post mostly makes me think this where we should be looking, the soft claim Miller being the obvious hole in the plan.

[Andrius]

SNAKEPLISSEN.

THOUGHTS ON JARTI, NOW.

/REREADING

[Andrius]

D1 REREAD IS DONE. WAITING ON SNAKE FOR COOMMENTS THO.

[Prox]

Yawn.

I softclaimed miller for reasons just like this.

If I hadn't already claimed, things would be a lot more precarious for me when the NK was stopped after someone targetted me for a Roleblock.

If a cop had targetted me instead, he would have likely decided that I was scum.

I could have claimed nexus after the event, but that wouldn't have been as effective, and I probably would have been lynched.

***

I do NOT think my claim was terribly bad play at all.

And this post mostly makes me think this where we should be looking, the soft claim Miller being the obvious hole in the plan.

What?

[SnakePlissken]

My thoughts on Jarti is that Jarti is town as the Godfather had Jarti RB twice and you wouldn't do that to one of your own team.