Open 253: Sea Container C9++ [GAME OVER]

[mongoose]

sorry mothrax, that wasn't at you

[mothrax]

mmmk, sorry for my reply little on edge lately.

[mothrax]

@Mothrax:

Massclaim horse is dead, going to stop beating it.

mothrax wrote:
Why would he have drawn so much attention to himself if he was scum?
mothrax wrote:
:Scum wouldn't do this so I can't be scum" is not a valid defense.

Explain why you contradicted yourself mothrax.

Kat was applying that defense to herself. Self-metaing, wether it is personal or sitewide is not a valid defense. SA on the other hand, I brought it up. Yes, that did not mean he could not be scum, but it made it much less likely.

s

mongoose wrote:
mothrax wrote:
If that is not an option, I think I am down with a mongoose lynch. his reaction to the massclaim argument was scummy, on top of the fact that he is pushing a lurker lynch;
Why was my reaction scummy?

Moth, answer this

In one post, he votes for me because I was stupid, not because I was scummy. He is nice enough to point out that my logic was flawed but not how it was flawed which is what I was asking. The very next post he says I am likely town but leaves his vote on me.

[mothrax]

Also, since apparently my reasoning failed at explaining why looker is not todays lynch, my personal policy is not to lynch a replacee the day they replace in

unless extrenuating circumstances (lylo, multiple replacements, long day etc) apply

I am 21.1% certain I am right about this.

[mongoose]

unvote, vote looker

, for not responding when people ask him questions.

[mongoose]

Also, since apparently my reasoning failed at explaining why looker is not todays lynch, my personal policy is not to lynch a replacee the day they replace in

unless extenuating circumstances (lylo, multiple replacements,

long day

etc) apply

I am 21.1% certain I am right about this.

there is your reason to vote him mothrax. Long, boring, day. Also, where did the number 21.1 come from. I am 78.6% sure you made it up.

[mothrax]

And I am absolutely positive that I did not. That is the probability that looker is scum. (well actually there is another variable that I didn't take into account, but that gets into really complex statistics.

[mongoose]

might I ask where you got the number from.

[mothrax]

Not today no.

[mothrax]

Though it really isn't that difficult to figure out.

[andrew94]

oi blak defend urself.
morthax defend urself

[mothrax]

From what? You quoted one of my posts and said it made me look scummy...

[Alduskkel]

a2rudeboy hasn't responded to my new case on him. Also, this game is outrageously slow. I think I will reread the game on Thursday or Friday and I'd recommend everyone do the same. Even skimming the game over again. We need to do

something

to try and get this game back up and rolling.

[mongoose]

Is any one not named Mothrax, andew, alduskkel, or mongoose playing the game?

[Nexus]

*waves*

I'll get to a reread.

[mothrax]

Just realized that my stat statement is reversed. It should read "there is a 21.1% chance that I am wrong.

[BlakAdder]

@andrew I'll defend myself when you give me something besides "derp this post looks scummy" and "lol you used filler" to defend myself from.
And I am sorry that I haven't been active, but I'll do my best to do a reread.

[mongoose]

I just want to remind you guys we have 4 DAYS TO GET A LYNCH DONE!

[mothrax]

Mod: votecount plox

[BlakAdder]

Okay, I've finished my reread, and I have to say I either want a Looker or Andrew lynch.
I don't really want to go after Looker because he's posted so little (although I don't believe he's given any V/LA notice, correct me if I'm wrong) but Katsuki was very jumpy day one, got defensive easily, jumped on so many wagons, and got overemotional over

every single thing

. And as Nexus said, she didn't post anything of value at all.
Andrew seems to be following a pattern of "throw shit at everything and relentlessly attack whatever it sticks to," and that itself screams newbscum to me. Not to mention he still hasn't validly explained why that post of mine he's pointed out once or twice now was scummy. Oh and he hasn't said anything remotely insightful either.
So for lack of a better option right now,

vote: Andrew

.

[andrew94]

so thats your foolish defence?

i didnt throw shit at everyopne.
only u and morthax i think?
lol?

[Nexus]

You attempted to throw shit at me, too, in one post.

[Nexus]

Yeah, so from a re-read, my list of most scummiest are:

andrew94
Katsuki/Looker
a2rudeboy
mothrax
Mafuyu

I don't really have anything about the others. Briefly:

andrew94: He is a VI, this has been established out of the game. However, his play is so scummy it's ridiculous. He acts really stupid, he demands things without offering his own stuff, he insults other players, and he posts nothing but rubbish. His "analysis" is nothing worth reading.

Katsuki/Looker: KATSUKI PLAY WAS SCUMMY BECAUSE SHE DIDN'T SAY ANYTHING AT ALL EXCEPT POSTING LIKE THIS. Looker's posted a random thing on the last page, hasn't explained it, and hasn't posted anything else.

a2rudeboy: LURK LURK LURK LURK LURK. He's a pain. He hasn't even really contributed when he comes back from v/la.

mothrax: Massclaim thing. Also posts a random number and won't explain it. WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Mafuyu: Her and Katsuki's plays are basically the same, imo anyway.

But yes, that's what I think.

[Nexus]

Also, VOTE: andrew94

[BlakAdder]

@Andrew: It's not a defense. It's why I think you're scummy.
See that's what's wrong with you. You think "hey, maybe I can put suspicion on someone else instead" is a valid defense. It's not. And that's why you're scummy. And I'm not even trying to defend myself, because you haven't given a valid accusation against me yet.

Also, here's all the posts where you tried to cast suspicion on somebody with no/not enough reasoning.
#30: You call Mongoose a hypocrite for asking for more posts while you apparently believe he hasn't posted enough either. Normally I wouldn't consider this anything but that was your

third post in the game

.
#32: You call Alduskkel out for posting fluff. And, again, this was your fourth post in the game thread.
#109: Calling Nexus out for not posting much. He had an okay excuse because he was V/LA. Meanwhile, you'd been posting a good amount but not actually saying anything.
#142: Sleepless Assassin (now confirmed town) votes you in order to avoid going to no lynch. You flail and try to shift attention to a2rudeboy and Nexus on the grounds that they've been lurking.
#144: "Hurr that post's so obviously scummy but I don't know why it's scummy" *facepalm*
#219: You say that Mothrax attacking Katsuki was bussing (with absolutely no reasoning as to why you think this) and that him giving Looker some reprieve due to being a replacement is him trying to stop bussing (again, offering no reason as to why you think this).
#233: You quote Alduskkel, bold a random chunk of his quote, and say "cough cough." Nothing more. Then you completely ignore everyone that asks you what you meant by this.
#236: Nexus just asked you what you meant by the above post. You counter him with "lololol you lurked in another game!"

My vote stands. Defend yourself.