Mini 1057: Unsubsidized Mafia (Game Over!)

[Nexus]

VOTE: jimfinn

Should never have taken my vote off.

[saporovirus]

...suspense...

[Chevre]

Vote Count 13

(5) jimfinn (ThAdmiral, Far_Cry, redtail896, Thor665, Nexus)
(2) Far_Cry (jimfinn, DemonHybrid)

(2) Not Voting (nhammen, saporovirus)

With

9

players alive, it takes

5

votes to lynch!
Deadline is

October 29th

.
Replacing nhammen.

jimfinn,

Townie

, lynched Day 2.

It is now

Night 2

. You have 72 hours to submit any actions you may have. The deadline is

October 28th

.

EDIT: For some reason it is saying I posted this 5 hours earlier than I actually did, and is therefore before saporovirus's post somehow magically.

[Chevre]

drmyshottyizsik replaces nhammen.

[drmyshottyizsik]

/confirm

mod please lock this thread

[Chevre]

Night 2 Results

Nexus,

Sane Cop

, killed Night 2.

It is now

Day 3

. With

7

alive, it takes

4

to lynch!



Vote Count 14

(7) Not Voting (DemonHybrid, drmyshottyizsik, Far_Cry, redtail896, saporovirus, ThAdmiral, Thor665)

Deadline is

November 15th

.

[Far_Cry]

Either we don't have a doctor or we have a stupid one. The choice to kill shotty was an interesting one, considering that he was one of the most suspicious.

I'm obvscum now. So go ahead and vote for me, see what happens.

[redtail896]

Rereading this tonight; I'll have saner thoughts in the morning than what I have now.

[DemonHybrid]

Vote: Far_Cry

Glad to be of service.

[ThAdmiral]

Still will not support a lynch on thor, redtail, sapovirus or farcry.

waiting to hear what the dr has to say, but Demonhybrid is the obvious choice for me today. Went through yesterday way to sure that jimfinn was town.

vote: demonhybrid

[DemonHybrid]

Unvote, Vote: ThAdmiral

I like that that's your only reasoning, and not the fact that I may have actually gotten a read right, which is what I usually do. I actually had a big feeling that this is what you were going to do this day.

I'd like to know how "I was way too sure he was town" when I provided reasoning on why I thought he was town. My stance on jim has NEVER changed.

[DemonHybrid]

Also, if there is a non-sane cop, you need to out yourself right now and give us your actions and results.

And if there is a non-sane cop, this is not a normal set up. =| But lets not hinder town.

[Thor665]

Either we don't have a doctor or we have a stupid one.

Obvious obvious statement is obvious

The choice to kill shotty was an interesting one, considering that he was one of the most suspicious.

By shotty do you mean Nexus?
If you mean Nexus then how was he most suspicious as an uncounterclaimed cop?
If you mean shotty then...???

I'm obvscum now. So go ahead and vote for me, see what happens.

Is this some sort of really awkward reverse psychology thing? You're on my list now for this if nothing else (I'll make up the nothing else if/when I vote you later today )

I actually had a big feeling that this is what you were going to do this day.

This comment screams to have itself explained more. Where you already suspicious of ThAdmiral yesterday and I missed it? Why is this action of his so worthy of a vote when you're so certain of Far_Cry?

[DemonHybrid]

This comment screams to have itself explained more. Where you already suspicious of ThAdmiral yesterday and I missed it? Why is this action of his so worthy of a vote when you're so certain of Far_Cry?

Yes.

Also, I had predicted someone on jim's wagon was going to blame me for "being too sure he was town" and completely discount my read, and I knew that that was definitely the person to go for. While I'm not going to go out of my way to clear Far_Cry, his AtE seems frustrated.

I was more focused on asking Admiral questions than explaining myself, so apologies.

[DemonHybrid]

To delve deeper: That's a classic scum attack. Someone gets a read right, and they try to undermine the read at the source: "It definitely couldn't have been right because you already knew it." Which is a downright logical fallacy. I had legitimate evidence supporting my read on jimfinn. The only thing that changed is that I gave up trying to convince people to step off of his wagon due to frustration (I am human, of course).

[DemonHybrid]

drshotty, please give your opinions of the game so far.

[ThAdmiral]

@ dh: but you never made it clear why you had such a strong town read on jimfinn, you just said it was sooo obviously a terrible lynch. It was suspicious then and it's suspicious now.

[DemonHybrid]

How is jimfinn obvious town? I'm not seeing it.

Assuming Far_Cry is scum (see what I see for a moment), everything that he's posted has little to no scum motivation. He hardly parroted, made a good case against Far Cry, even picked out my flaws and is straight shooting instead of causing deliberate confusion. jimfinn is just a bad lynch, I shouldn't have to tell you guys this again.

[saporovirus]

Hey, ThAdmiral: I think you're probably reading too much into DH thinking jim's a stupid lynch. He also seemed to be extremely prejudiced against far_cry. I however don't like how he's attacking your suspicions as scummy cuz you've been quite townsmanlike throughout.

I'm currently interested in nhammen/ shotty and Far_Cry. Will scrutinize them laters.

[DemonHybrid]

I find it opportunistic that Admiral is attacking me because I was the only one originally against jimfinn's lynch. That's all there is to it.

[drmyshottyizsik]

@ dh: but you never made it clear why you had such a strong town read on jimfinn, you just said it was sooo obviously a terrible lynch. It was suspicious then and it's suspicious now.

It's called gut, please don't dis it, it is real

[drmyshottyizsik]

I find it opportunistic that Admiral is attacking me because I was the only one originally against jimfinn's lynch. That's all there is to it.

I agree with this, Admiral was my top suspect and so far today he hasn't helped himself any

[DemonHybrid]

No, shotty, it wasn't "gut".

[Far_Cry]

Vote: Far_Cry

Glad to be of service.

So you are the only person to take my post literally. Interesting...

Still will not support a lynch on thor, redtail, sapovirus or farcry.

waiting to hear what the dr has to say, but Demonhybrid is the obvious choice for me today. Went through yesterday way to sure that jimfinn was town.

vote: demonhybrid

Why is Thor, redtail, sapo, and I not scummy in your eyes? (excuse me, that came out as bad grammar.)

Unvote, Vote: ThAdmiral

I like that that's your only reasoning, and not the fact that I may have actually gotten a read right, which is what I usually do. I actually had a big feeling that this is what you were going to do this day.

I'd like to know how "I was way too sure he was town" when I provided reasoning on why I thought he was town. My stance on jim has NEVER changed.

So you OMGUS vote him. Interesting. Was your vote on me a trap, that you are hoping that Admiral or somebody else might fall into?

This comment screams to have itself explained more. Where you already suspicious of ThAdmiral yesterday and I missed it? Why is this action of his so worthy of a vote when you're so certain of Far_Cry?

Yes.

Also, I had predicted someone on jim's wagon was going to blame me for "being too sure he was town" and completely discount my read, and I knew that that was definitely the person to go for. While I'm not going to go out of my way to clear Far_Cry, his AtE seems frustrated.

I was more focused on asking Admiral questions than explaining myself, so apologies.

But realize, we don't know how to take your defense of jimfinn. You could have just made a mistake, or you could be buddying.

To delve deeper: That's a classic scum attack. Someone gets a read right, and they try to undermine the read at the source: "It definitely couldn't have been right because you already knew it." Which is a downright logical fallacy. I had legitimate evidence supporting my read on jimfinn. The only thing that changed is that I gave up trying to convince people to step off of his wagon due to frustration (I am human, of course).

You've been doing quite a lot of defense. I'm not sure whether to take this as town or scummy. Need some time to think.

Hey, ThAdmiral: I think you're probably reading too much into DH thinking jim's a stupid lynch. He also seemed to be extremely prejudiced against far_cry. I however don't like how he's attacking your suspicions as scummy cuz you've been quite townsmanlike throughout.

I'm currently interested in nhammen/ shotty and Far_Cry. Will scrutinize them laters.

This is a baaad post. Are you coaching Admral? Because it looks like it to me. You say he getting too much into DH ("Shame shame, Admiral! You know you can't do that!"), then say, "Oh, he's quite likely town." I don't know about you, but I see some buddying here.

@Thor: Ignore my post on Nexus. It was late when I wrote the post and I don't know what the hell I was thinking.

[DemonHybrid]

Ugh.

So you are the only person to take my post literally. Interesting...

It had nothing to do with your post. It had to do with jim's flip and my suspicions from yesterday, I took your AtE as scummy at the time until Admiral posted.

So you OMGUS vote him. Interesting. Was your vote on me a trap, that you are hoping that Admiral or somebody else might fall into?

For the love of christ, why does everyone improperly use the term "OMGUS"?

You guys are supposed to be better than me at mafia. I'm the newbie here, seriously, what the hell?

Textbook definition of OMGUS:

Player A: "Vote: Player B. He's mad scummy because he seemed like he auto-knew someone was town."
Player B: "DUDE, go fuck yourself! Vote: Player A"
Player A: "Oh my, OMGUS!"

NOT OMGUS:

Player A: "Vote: Player B. He's mad scummy because he seemed like he auto-knew someone was town."
Player B: "Vote: Player A. I don't like the fact that you're attacking me because of it, it seems opportunistic. I just happened to get my read right."
Player A: "Oh my, OM

NO. WRONG.

OMGUS is only OMGUS when the counter-vote has no reasoning to back it up. Please stop trying to pin suspicion on me.

And no. Admiral legitimately skyrocketed above you on scumminess. You are second on my list.

But realize, we don't know how to take your defense of jimfinn. You could have just made a mistake, or you could be buddying.

Uh....made a mistake? I made a good read. I proved it with evidence. That's not a "mistake"; you guys were the ones that made the mistake.

Let's not get out of hand with this.

Does everyone agree that my reasoning for not suspecting jimfinn is valid?

Please refer to my recent reply to Admiral; I brought the post back up.

You've been doing quite a lot of defense. I'm not sure whether to take this as town or scummy. Need some time to think.

So, I'm forced to defend myself, and when I do, it "could be scummy". You realize how ridiculous that sounds, right?