Mafia 121 -- Picking Simplicity Game Over

[mothrax]

Yes. Especially since he already confirmed in thread which leads me to believe that he is KNOWINGLY conforming to the rest of the group.

And Yugiboy pissed me off in irc once cause he told me everyone hated me and wanted me to GTFO. But he wont remember that cause I was using my usual name. But that's entirely irrelevant and I really need to stop posting exactly what I'm thinking.

Show me where he confirmed in thread bfore this page. He has two posts total, both of which come after 10 plus pages.

[Jack]

Yes. Especially since he already confirmed in thread which leads me to believe that he is KNOWINGLY conforming to the rest of the group.

And Yugiboy pissed me off in irc once cause he told me everyone hated me and wanted me to GTFO. But he wont remember that cause I was using my usual name. But that's entirely irrelevant and I really need to stop posting exactly what I'm thinking.

Show me where he confirmed in thread bfore this page. He has two posts total, both of which come after 10 plus pages.

Interesting tone.

[mothrax]

It looks like haylen is trying to cover for the fact that cj had not posted once all game.

[Jack]

unvote, vote:mothrax

no, she made a point out of him "knowingly" bandwagoning, she says she doesn't buy that it's a random vote, and she's voting for him

[Haylen]

It looks like haylen is trying to cover for the fact that cj had not posted once all game.

Do not misrep me. It's scummy. And in this case it was obvious.

FoS Mothrax

In happy with my vote for now. Would go with a mothrax lynch if asked.

[Haylen]

It looks like haylen is trying to cover for the fact that cj had not posted once all game.

Do not misrep me. It's scummy. And in this case it was obvious.

FoS Mothrax

In happy with my vote for now. Would go with a mothrax lynch if asked.

[Jack]

cj would have hammered first post if she could have, just for kicks...let's go with someone who is trying not to be scummy but failing.

[mothrax]

I'm not misreping you, I am stating a fact. You said he had and he had not unless it was with an alt that I missed.

[Jack]

Nice dodge; bandwagon please.

[Empking]

Yos: Give me a quote where LMP says that he doesn't like Jack's claim and

just

thinks its an unlikerly scum gambit. (other than when he quoted you and said "WIN")

I'm confused here by your thought process, empking; what did you think LMP meant by that line, if not "I think Jack is probably town"? It seemed obvious in context, especially after his next post.

That he considered Jack's claim as beneficial for town.

CJ's vote just strike me as poor play rather than scummy.

[Yosarian2]

Yos: Give me a quote where LMP says that he doesn't like Jack's claim and

just

thinks its an unlikerly scum gambit. (other than when he quoted you and said "WIN")

I'm confused here by your thought process, empking; what did you think LMP meant by that line, if not "I think Jack is probably town"? It seemed obvious in context, especially after his next post.

That he considered Jack's claim as beneficial for town.

That wasn't how I read it, especially not in light of his next post. In any case; are you saying that you think that LMP has some incorrect ideas about mafia theory and about what is beneficial for the town, and that makes him scum?

[UncertainKitten]

@Nika: What, because I haven't blown up and called anyone a moron yet I'm probably scum ?

Unvote, Vote CJMiller

Dammit Glork, you beat me to that one!!!

Still up for Lowell or Snake.

mothrax is doing himself no favors.

Open to meta examples of dumb town CJ behavior. Yes, I'm sure I'm letting you down, AGar, but note I had a qualifier that meta occasionally helps for some players. Mostly for nullifying tells, actually. It's knowing when to use it which isn't very often.

[Nobody Special]

/conform

I'm not getting anything from my read other than

Vote:SnakePlissken

^^^ How the heck did you manage to avoid getting replaced?

I refer you to Rule #12.

[Nobody Special]

Votecount 1.06


SnakePlissken - 6 - Antihero, eldarad, Xine, mothrax, AGar, CJMiller
Empking - 5 - Nikanor, Yosarian2, VasudeVa, LynchMePls, SnakePlissken
CJMiller - 4 - Glork, Lowell, Haylen, UncertainKitten
LynchMePls - 2 - Empking, Azazel
mothrax - 1 - Jack


Not Voting: jmj3000, Sudo_Nym

With 20 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

Deadline: November 17

Random notes:

-- Pumpkins are a fruit, not a vegetable.

[eldarad]

I'm still more than happy with a Snake lynch, I reckon this is the play for Today. I'm not liking the CJwagon.

I agree with the general sentiment "how the hell did you get to page 12 without posting?" but I think all of these CJMiller votes are being made out of annoyance that the player has not made a single post up until now rather than because they think he is scum. Glork's reason is slightly different but is still just a variation on the theme.

It doesn't make CJ scum, it just makes him absent for the past week. Regardless of whether you blame him, the mod or the players (or a combination of the three) for letting him get this far his absence isn't a scumtell.

[Jack]

@eldarad: what do you think of mothrax?

[EtherDent]

Open to meta examples of dumb town CJ behavior.

I haven't played with him on the forums, but based on some experience with him on scumchat games a while back, I'd expect him to be a VI. I realize that kind of meta isn't usually very useful, but let's just say that based on that I would have been surprised to see him make posts that were especially coherent.

[Yosarian2]

Dangit, wrong account. I keep doing that, sorry.

[LimMePls]

I'm still more than happy with a Snake lynch, I reckon this is the play for Today. I'm not liking the CJwagon.

I agree with the general sentiment "how the hell did you get to page 12 without posting?" but I think all of these CJMiller votes are being made out of annoyance that the player has not made a single post up until now rather than because they think he is scum. Glork's reason is slightly different but is still just a variation on the theme.

It doesn't make CJ scum, it just makes him absent for the past week. Regardless of whether you blame him, the mod or the players (or a combination of the three) for letting him get this far his absence isn't a scumtell.

What do you think about the Empking case?

[Empking]

Yos: Give me a quote where LMP says that he doesn't like Jack's claim and

just

thinks its an unlikerly scum gambit. (other than when he quoted you and said "WIN")

I'm confused here by your thought process, empking; what did you think LMP meant by that line, if not "I think Jack is probably town"? It seemed obvious in context, especially after his next post.

That he considered Jack's claim as beneficial for town.

That wasn't how I read it, especially not in light of his next post. In any case; are you saying that you think that LMP has some incorrect ideas about mafia theory and about what is beneficial for the town, and that makes him scum?

Being happy about a page three claim by one of our two power roles in not "some incorrect ideas" it goes far beyond that (into scum).

[LimMePls]

Yos: Give me a quote where LMP says that he doesn't like Jack's claim and

just

thinks its an unlikerly scum gambit. (other than when he quoted you and said "WIN")

I'm confused here by your thought process, empking; what did you think LMP meant by that line, if not "I think Jack is probably town"? It seemed obvious in context, especially after his next post.

That he considered Jack's claim as beneficial for town.

That wasn't how I read it, especially not in light of his next post. In any case; are you saying that you think that LMP has some incorrect ideas about mafia theory and about what is beneficial for the town, and that makes him scum?

Being happy about a page three claim by one of our two power roles in not "some incorrect ideas" it goes far beyond that (into scum).

This is absurd. I wasn't happy about the claim because it was a page3 PR claim, I was happy because it was likely a VT gambit that would spur discussion and not actually help the scum, even if he telling the truth. I thought it was pretty clearly a gambit, ESPECIALLY given that it is Jack we're talking about, and I didn't see how it would make sense as a scum gambit.

[AGar]

Yes. Especially since he already confirmed in thread which leads me to believe that he is KNOWINGLY conforming to the rest of the group.

/conform

I'm not getting anything from my read other than

Vote:SnakePlissken

A wizard did it.

Iso ends

Show me where he confirmed in thread bfore this page. He has two posts total, both of which come after 10 plus pages.

I don't see the misrep.

---

no, she made a point out of him "knowingly" bandwagoning, she says she doesn't buy that it's a random vote, and she's voting for him

She did, but she also had faulty logic. What say you to that?

---

It looks like haylen is trying to cover for the fact that cj had not posted once all game.

Do not misrep me. It's scummy. And in this case it was obvious.

FoS Mothrax

In happy with my vote for now. Would go with a mothrax lynch if asked.

Obvious scum is obvious.

[AGar]

CJ wagon is fail-wagon if you're looking for scum. If you're looking for a lynch to rid the town of a non-productive player, go for it. But Snake/Hayl > CJ.

[Glork]

Meh, fiiine.

Unvote
Vote: Snake

[Glork]

EBWOP: If Snake flips town, though, I will be all over some of these people like stink on shit.