NY 118 - BBM's Large Normal Mafia (Game!)

[Wraith]

Oh shit. I was totally convinced flinter was the last scum.

Vote: Antihero

Damn good game, dude. I didn't suspect you much until about Day 5.

[EtherDent]

I don't feel like I actually did that much, but Yosarian really did do a lot of reading and effort and shit, so I won't answer for him. :P

I found it fun while I was actually around. More than half of you other people were scum and you were

still

more productive and helpful than some towns I've worked with lately. I'll probably have to read this game sooner or later for meta notes.

Serial killers...definitely aren't one of my favorite roles, and seeing one who either crosskilled or directly caused the deaths of 4/5ths of the mafia through his nightkill really doesn't make me feel better about them. (Naturally, I'm going to disregard that and run a game with one anyway.)

-Ether

[evilpacman18]

A_A

[DemonHybrid]

I guess it's safe to start talking now.

I wonder why you decided on EPM, Anti.

What a fun game, though. I'm glad I made EPM look really town, after all was said and done. I never told him I was going to bus him Day 7, so I wanted an element of surprise in there. I knew that whether or not he got lynched or I did, we would have gotten away with the win. Unlucky enough to have EPM nightkilled though....and I fucking love EPM forever for choosing not to night kill, what a pro move.

Also, I was 90% certain Wraith was the SK.

[evilpacman18]

In that case:

GODDAMMIT ANTI

[flinter]

Oh shit. I was totally convinced flinter was the last scum.

Vote: Antihero

Damn good game, dude. I didn't suspect you much until about Day 5.

There weren't many that agreed with you. In the votecounts, I can only count 2 votes for me. I think mysterio voted me too.

A no-kill would have made much more sense for the SK. I don't actually see the benefit for the mafia (although they have lost anyway)

[DemonHybrid]

SKs can't no kill, but no-killing for mafia would make you guys assume that mafia was done for. I tried to make my bah post as miserable as possible to hint at that =P

[evilpacman18]

I aimed for Anti in case he was bluffing and I figured if he wasn't and I didn't get my kill, I could argue that DH must have been the last scum and that Anti was the only remaining anti-town player.

I actually wasn't aware that mafia had the option to no-kill, I thought they didn't.

[DemonHybrid]

Regardless, it was a good play.

And yeah, they can forgo their night kill, but SKs can't. If they don't send in an action, it's randomized.

[EtherDent]

I think that's only very rarely true, DemonHybrid. Maybe on a few other sites, but I'm pretty sure SKs here can usually no-kill if they feel like it.

if he wasn't and I didn't get my kill, I could argue that DH must have been the last scum and that Anti was the only remaining anti-town player.

I'd have fallen for it, too. x_x

-Ether

[evilpacman18]

I had a lot of fun with this game, I'm just REALLY disappointed that we lost because of such a silly reason.

Btw, Town MVP: Xite

[flinter]

I'm glad you thought him just as annoying

[Wraith]

I'm so glad I managed to nail two scum this game. My play's been pretty shit in almost all my other games.

Also, I KNEW in my gut that something was up with ConfidAnon. I thought CA was scum for a while, but once dana got shoved in my eye I practically dropped him.

[flinter]

sorry xite, I didn't mean that badly, but I thought you were scum for a long time because you were so wrong about me.

[evilpacman18]

I can't believe we couldn't figure out the SK for all that time. Every single one of our guesses was off. Xite, flinter, Gorrad, Shanba, everybody we speculated was wrong.

[Wraith]

Xite should not have defended dana so hard D3. If he had been scum I could cite it as the epitome of chainsaw defense.

I do have to say that the singersigner lynch was not my finest hour. My gut was nagging me from the moment I put my vote down on her. I never should have gone alone with it.

I thought it was Gorrad and SHanba first, but once they flipped I was pretty sure it was Antihero or flinter. Near the end of D7 I was pretty certain flinter was the fifth scum and Anti was SK.

[evilpacman18]

Ugh omg. Can't believe he killed me because he was aiming for town -___________________-

[Wraith]

It's a compliment silly

You had us so convinced that you were town. I think he thought flinter was the last scum too.

[DemonHybrid]

Hey, at least I like my bussing skills....I fail and I make the other person look TOO town, haha

[evilpacman18]

Hey, at least I like my bussing skills....I fail and I make the other person look TOO town, haha

High-5.

[DemonHybrid]

Anti, you singlehandedly wiped out 66% of us. What gave us away? lol

[DemonHybrid]

well, 60%, forgot there was only 5 mafia.

[evilpacman18]

Anti needs to get in here so I can /raeg at him.

[singersigner]

Haha. It's funny how accurate my final "bah" post was before the hammer. I wasn't right about Anti being scum, but I was right that he wasn't pro-town. And I stand by my "revenge" theory. Anti was just bitter that I had him and quadz so pegged in another game we were in (it's finished now).

Though, EPM, honestly...I knew you were scum as soon as you hammered without acknowledging my post. If it had been anyone else, you would've been high on my list.

Town got veeery lucky. Sorry I played so shitty for a while.

[EtherDent]

80%, right? He killed the cop, too, directly leading to Danakillsu's lynch.

-Ether