Mini 1077 Lost: Season Two (Over)

[xRECKONERx]

|

0

|

0

|

7

|

0

|

0

|

Enigma (2): MagnaofIllusion, jasonT1981
Vren (1): dramonic
Callandor (3): Enigma, AGar, gandalf5166
Toon Fighter (2): Dekes, Callandor
MagnaofIllusion (2): chesskid3, vezokpiraka
dramonic (1): Toon Fighter

Not voting (1): Vren

SHUT UP SHUT UP SHUT UP.
I'LL PROD

MON AMOUR

WHEN HE GETS ON SKYPE TO TALK TO ME IN A COUPLE HOURS.

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.
Deadline is November 24th at 6:00PM.

[vezokpiraka]

So what are we going to do now?

[vezokpiraka]

AHHH. Sorry forgot about questions.

Well what I said still stands. If jason is not confirmed by tomorrow we lynch him.

[vezokpiraka]

And MoI i really think you are scum this game.
Gut Read on you.

[MagnaofIllusion]

And MoI i really think you are scum this game.
Gut Read on you.

Glad you have explained your read.

Any comment as to why you don’t appear to be reading the thread (in regards to saying I’m not giving suspicions)?

[vezokpiraka]

I read the thread i just forgot that.

I thought you didn't give any reads and only answered questions. Sorry I had a busy day I think I forgot some things.

[vezokpiraka]

Also I want your top two scum picks now.

[gandalf5166]

> 4 8 15 16 23 42
EXECUTE

[xRECKONERx]

Prodding dramonic & Dekes.
Searching for a Vren replacement.

[dramonic]

*Figurative stretch*

Let's see here...

We have Toon going for the deflection act with a oomph of hypocrisy...
We have Vezok wanting Jason to get confirmed and then lynched...
We have AGar going psycho-tunnel on Callandor, and trying to direct a potential vig...
We have Callandor who seems non-commital in his reads...
We have Jason who's managing to be full of posts with very little content, also pre-emptive claiming
We have Enigma who still seems stuck in the RVS...
We have Gandalf whose claim and demands are getting more ridiculous with every post...
We have Chesskid whose contribution is "vig that guy. Blow that guy up. Lynch that guy. Action me."
We have Vren who's getting replaced...
We have Dekes who's fairly conf-town for now...
We have MoI who wants to numb my brains with wall'o'texts...

And we have me abusing ...

Okay, all kidding aside, if we have to give a three player pool to Jason, it should be Dekes, MoI and Chess by my perspective.

Vezok is going to have to clarify why he wants to confirm Jason as town and tehn lynch her. Also, not to be against the trend but failure to confirm an ability really doesn't hold that much weight as a reason to lynch IMO. It's roleblocker fodder however.

Toon Fighter is a silly thing, calling me out as a bigger lurker when I have more posts with content that, you know, actually relate to the current game state? He gets a cookie for now, and some rope tomorrow, as he's now my priority guy.

Enigma needs a rope now. At first I was just saying he's playing light-hearted and stuff, but it's been going for 9 days now. His content has in no way gotten better, his posts are still jesting. About 4 out of 5 are sarcasm and joke posts, the other ones are just pokes he doesn't pursue ever. He's trying to show a contribution on his part this isn't even there. I am not satisfied.

Before somebody points it out, I'm aware I don't have a lot of content myself. At least I'm not trying to pass off crap as if it were.

Unvote
Vote: Enigma

[AGar]

So you're willing to blindly buy into your townread of a player and risk the town getting duped into him picking his scumbuddy as the "confirmer."

Are you thinking about this argument regarding Jason picking a scum-buddy before you make it? If we are indeed in a 9-2-1 set-up Jason, as scum who made a horrible fake-claim with little pressure on him, choosing his scum-partner to fake confirm him would be a horrible move. It would out the scum team immediately if either one was ever shown to be scum. That’s a very high risk for the minimal reward.

The problem with that theory though, is what I pointed out - nowhere has Jason said that his confirmation has to be to a town-aligned player. So unless you're saying we get the confirmation and then lynch him anyways, then there's no real risk in his choosing his scumbuddy.

@Callandor

If we manage to put one of the scum in the 3 and it's Jason's scumbuddy, then oh well. But we're minimalizing the chance for that to happen by choosing 3 town agreed upon reads.

My 3 would be Dekes, MoI and Chess.

So so far, based on what people have said, this is what we're looking at:

MoI: AGar, Dekes, Callandor
CK3: Chesskid3, Dekes, Callandor
Dram: Chesskid3, Dekes, MoI
Me: Chesskid3, Dekes, MoI

Still need input from Vezok, TF, gandalf, Enigma, Call, Dekes and Vren-replacement.

I think everyone can agree that it's a bad idea for Jason to list.

[AGar]

Also, big shoutout to Gandalf for coming in, taking the time to check that it's the hatch post, posting that and then disappearing again. You're worth fuckall so far this game.

[AGar]

Also... Dram, could it be... scumreads that aren't gut?!?!?!?!

Muchos aplausos, senor.

[dramonic]

harlot

[AGar]

[MagnaofIllusion]

Also I want your top two scum picks now.

How about this. I’ve already listed three reads with reasonings. When you can provide two solid reads with more significant support than ‘gut’ we can talk.

The problem with that theory though, is what I pointed out - nowhere has Jason said that his confirmation has to be to a town-aligned player. So unless you're saying we get the confirmation and then lynch him anyways, then there's no real risk in his choosing his scumbuddy.

It doesn’t make any sense for Jason, as any sort of scum, to have an ability that confirms he is not Town. That's the equivalent of a penalty power. If he’s scum he’s outright lying about his role or has an ability that allows him to have Reck make a false statement on his behalf. No other option makes any sense.

In the first case he would absolutely have to use his scum-buddy since he can’t bluff towards a Town player. But there would be ZERO reason to fake-claim as he did then. As I’ve said … little potential gain with huge potential downside.

In the second case he would absolutely want anyone other than his partner to receive the message.

I don’t see the first scenario as likely. The second scenario only exists if Reck is willing to be a bastard about the content of a potential message.

In any event I’m fine with proceeding as planned and giving Jason a concensus group of 3 players to target.

I think everyone can agree that it's a bad idea for Jason to list.

For some reason this really made me laugh.

@Enigma

– Once your studying has slowed down I’d love for you to make an appearance and list your three top reads for Jason’s pool.

@Toon

– Still waiting for your response to my and other’s points about your recent ‘case’.

[AGar]

MoI: We agree, we're just not saying it the same. Don't worry, I get what you're saying, and I agree.

[MagnaofIllusion]

AGar

- Have you given Enigma a look lately? I think he really warrants some close scrutiny at this point, especially with Jason's pre-emptive claim taking him of the table as a viable lynch for today.

[dramonic]

Enigma (1): MagnaofIllusion, jasonT1981
Vren (2): dramonic

Mod error, or...?

[xRECKONERx]

Fixed.

[gandalf5166]

Dekes, MoI, vezokpiraka

I can say for the sake of transparency(not because I think jason would actually consider it) that jason's action would not convert me.

[chesskid3]

You bitches all like living so much that I'm the only one so far who self-nominated.
Interesting.

[vezokpiraka]

Jason can pick between me , chess and dram.

[AGar]

You bitches all like living so much that I'm the only one so far who self-nominated.
Interesting.

Not really.

---

Updated:

MoI: AGar, Dekes, Callandor
CK3: Chesskid3, Dekes, Callandor
Dram: Chesskid3, Dekes, MoI
Me: Chesskid3, Dekes, MoI
Gandalf: Dekes, MoI, vezokpiraka
Vezok: Dramonic, Chesskid3, vezokpiraka

Dekes at 5, Chesskid at 4, MoI at 3, vezok and Callandor at 2, myself and Dramonic at 1.

MoI:

I'll look into him, but I'm going to be V/LA from this post until Monday afternoon, so it won't be for a bit.

[chesskid3]

Didn't self nominate:
MoI,Dram,AGar

Did:
CK,Vezok

Orly?