Open 256~Fire and Ice Mafia Over!

[Me=Weird]

votecount

Prodding JesseSheffield.
Robocopter87(1): curiouskarmadog
mallowgeno(2): Scott Brosius, Zed
Zed(2): JesseSheffield, mallowgeno
Not voting(1): Robocopter87

With 6 alive, it's 4 to lynch.
Deadline is November 20.

[JesseSheffield]

Hm. I'm not really sure what to think of CKD in this game. I can't say he's said anything that has really struck me as truly inspiring or convincing or anything of the sorts. I'm pretty convinced Robo is scum but I, like I've said earlier, I don't think he's an Ice so I'm sticking with my vote.

[curiouskarmadog]

Well this is amusing. Your case on me is that I wasn't around during night (whatever that means) and there was no kill? Did you read the beginning of the day where most of us agreed it's 100x more likely that fire and ice shot the same person, thereby canceling out their kills, rather than the very rare possibility of a group forgetting to kill AND the doctor protecting the exact other person who was targeted? It's really bizarre that this is your case especially after you went to such care to discuss the setup and power of the mafia.

As for the setup, we had already discussed cross-kills went through but same kills did not. So yes I knew that. The 1v1v1 situation I did not.

Why would you rather nail fire scum today? To me it's a wash. Lynching Ice means there is only 1 NK, but there are no chances at cross-kills. Lynching fire means the mafia can kill each other, but they could also kill 2 town members.

Well this is amusing. Your case on me is that I wasn't around during night (whatever that means) and there was no kill? Did you read the beginning of the day where most of us agreed it's 100x more likely that fire and ice shot the same person, thereby canceling out their kills,

oh right I forgot about that...killing the same person counters each other.....but my scenario is just as plausible as the other one, is it not?

in reference to the 1v1v1 questions, then if you did not know that, as town, THAT was good knowledge to have...so what was the purpose of busting my balls about asking setup related questions when it as good for the town to know?

[curiouskarmadog]

[quote"curiouskarmadog"]only one kill???

Did you forget about the doctor?

I personally, don't find either of your cases to be very convincing, and I don't plan on looking at scott of robo myself after it.[/quote]

out of my whole post THAT is the only thing worth mentioning?.....can you go over your case for mallow for me again?...why is he scummer than robo?

[curiouskarmadog]

Hm. I'm not really sure what to think of CKD in this game. I can't say he's said anything that has really struck me as truly inspiring or convincing or anything of the sorts. I'm pretty convinced Robo is scum but I, like I've said earlier, I don't think he's an Ice so I'm sticking with my vote.

why do you think robo is scum?

why do you think (tell me again) zed is scum?

[Robocopter87]

I'm pretty convinced Robo is scum

O yeah? Whys that?

[Zed]

only one kill???

Did you forget about the doctor?

I personally, don't find either of your cases to be very convincing, and I don't plan on looking at scott of robo myself after it.

out of my whole post THAT is the only thing worth mentioning?.....can you go over your case for mallow for me again?...why is he scummer than robo?

Yes, that is all I found. All you did was summerize the thread for us, you hardly voiced any opinions. That doesn't really help.

Why should I go over my case against mallow again? I did it three times on the last page. One of them even has links. Go read them yourself.

And I don't find Robo that scummy right now.

[Scott Brosius]

oh right I forgot about that...killing the same person counters each other.....but my scenario is just as plausible as the other one, is it not?

in reference to the 1v1v1 questions, then if you did not know that, as town, THAT was good knowledge to have...so what was the purpose of busting my balls about asking setup related questions when it as good for the town to know?

Just seemed like you disappeared. Didn't want the spot to continue to be vacant that's all.

The scenario of one team forgetting the kill and the other team happening to pick the player that the doctor protected is plausible, but I find it more likely that they shot at the same person. It's pretty WIFOMy anyway.

[curiouskarmadog]

only one kill???

Did you forget about the doctor?

I personally, don't find either of your cases to be very convincing, and I don't plan on looking at scott of robo myself after it.

out of my whole post THAT is the only thing worth mentioning?.....can you go over your case for mallow for me again?...why is he scummer than robo?

Yes, that is all I found. All you did was summerize the thread for us, you hardly voiced any opinions. That doesn't really help.

Why should I go over my case against mallow again? I did it three times on the last page. One of them even has links. Go read them yourself.

And I don't find Robo that scummy right now.

"why should I go over my case"? arent you trying to convince us that you think X is scummy? bonus scum points for that statement. you should be chomping at the bit to convince people that someone "who you supposedly think is scummy" is indeed scummy, but I ask you to do it again and you give me shit? maybe I had a reason for asking for it....shouldnt you be scum hunting?..instead of saying.."here is the link to my case of why i think mallow is scummy, I would really like you stance on this today"..you say "go read them yourself"

I dont believe you really think mallow is scum....

for that,

unvote, vote zed.

[curiouskarmadog]

also that puts him at -1

[mallowgeno]

that gives Robo the hammer.

[mallowgeno]

EBWOP:

I mean that between me and Zed.

[Robocopter87]

No no no, I wanna frikkin get a response from Mister I'mgonnalurkinthebackandthencomebackandcallrandompeoplescumJessesheffield.

[Zed]

"why should I go over my case"? arent you trying to convince us that you think X is scummy? bonus scum points for that statement. you should be chomping at the bit to convince people that someone "who you supposedly think is scummy" is indeed scummy, but I ask you to do it again and you give me shit? maybe I had a reason for asking for it....shouldnt you be scum hunting?..instead of saying.."here is the link to my case of why i think mallow is scummy, I would really like you stance on this today"..you say "go read them yourself"

I dont believe you really think mallow is scum....

for that,

unvote, vote zed.

Thats bull and you know it. But I do apologize for my rudeness, even if I don't find it uncalled for. But I explained my case three times. I did a light outline first. Mallow said that's bull, and I went into detail. I commented on nearly all of his posts in ISO from my phone. Robo said, show me instead of telling me. So I did, I gave links. And still no one commented. Mallow can't even be bothered defending himself, did anyone notice that? Do you know how frustrating that is? And then for someone to ask me to go over it for a fourth time, with not even a whole page between? Thats ridiculous.There is no reason why you can't click the little page numbers and read it yourself.

also that puts

her

at -1

Please to be reading.

Also, I am the doctor. I was hoping to keep that quiet, but I don't trust scott enough not to claim.

And note that mallow was at L-1 for awhile with no claim.

[Zed]

EDWOP: I was also phone posting when I said to go read it yourself. But if I could have linked, I probably would have followed by a snarky comment of some sort.

[Scott Brosius]

Probably no reason to doubt claim. If it is a fake-claim, real doctor please counter.

I would be fine with a mallow or CKD lynch today.

[curiouskarmadog]

unvote.

[curiouskarmadog]

waiting for everyone to check in after the claim...could be scum wanting to draw out the doc.

[curiouskarmadog]

it also should be noted that robo could have hammered.

[JesseSheffield]

I'll be back soon, sorry for the delay.

[mallowgeno]

unvote

Back to square one, though I think my lynch is imminent. I am but a lowly VT.

[Scott Brosius]

anyone alive out there? We need to lynch somebody before deadline.

[curiouskarmadog]

well we got 3 days...and some people have to check in....

Jesse, when you wrote your last post, how far had you read into the game?

[mallowgeno]

vote Robo

Going back to my original vote.

[Robocopter87]

I'll be back soon, sorry for the delay.

*Jeopardy Music*