SMBM 1: IoBC GAME OVER! CONGRATULATIONS: TOWN AND KAMIKAZE!

[diddin]

/confirmmmmmmm

[diddin]

Is there a problem, my lord?

Also plenty of new faces. Hi everyone!

[diddin]

I propose a policy lynch of GIS.

Vote: GandalfIzSik

Zodiark probably has a post restriction but it isn't one that gets in the way or anything.

[diddin]

You are correct sir, but I am not here.

[diddin]

diddin, does your character wear clothes? Shells don't count.

Why does it matter other than for your rolefishing needs?

unvote, Vote:chkflip

[diddin]

I propose a policy lynch of GIS.

Vote: GandalfIzSik

Zodiark probably has a post restriction but it isn't one that gets in the way or anything.

I second this unless Shotty isn't with him.
Then if Gandalf survives, not a big deal to me.

Alas I would pursue this lynch but chk is already incredi-scummy so GIS can wait.

Glad this game doesn't look like it has too much vigbait... to any vig out there: GIS if Shotty is being Shotty is a great shot. Bunny and Mongoose are good shots too based on past games and the like.

[diddin]

Your reaction is townish. You're still slightly scummy but I wouldn't lynch you just for that.

Vote: GIS

Back to dat policy lynchin

[diddin]

GIS setup speculation is baaaaaad. In Kingdom of Loathing Mafia some of the "Guild Chiefs" who helped the hero were part of the Penguin Mafia. Not to mention this is a bastardmod game. Not to mention you're speculating in a quite scummy matter.

@MOD: My Vote is on GIS/Gandalf despite what your log says.

unvote, Vote: GandalfIzSik

if you need me to vote again.

According to your last vote post, you did not unvote someone you have already voted.

[diddin]

@Zdenek: 3rd party members can be scum. Scum is defined as any faction deliberately anti-town. Serial Killers, for example, count as scum.

[diddin]

If you lynch a serial killer that is one whole kill that doesn't happen every night that can hurt the town. It is equally desirable to lynch either.

[diddin]

I'm actually voting him for more of a reason than a policy lynch now, Dana.

Apologies to the mod, I did not realize unvoting was required.

[diddin]

posting from my phone v/la till sunday

Acknowledged.

[diddin]

Aww hell, I think I might have a voting restriction.

Some things I noticed so far-

-Mallow and Midnight are both good vigbait. Mallow has an activelurker meta and Midnight just posts a ton of fluff.
-Muh's demend of an early lynch is scummy. It looks like he's scum who wants to get more info about the setup.
-Still not seeing what's so scummy about chkflip. I've seen reactionfishing like that before and I actually find town more likely to do it.

Extinguish: chkflip

Set Fire To: Muh13

Now that we don't have to worry about Shotty I'm less uneasy about Gandalf. Still a little weary of the spot with all the setup speculation coming from it.

This game is bastard mod. That means there are probably no vanilla townies, so it is worthless to PR speculate at this point.

[diddin]

Also to the potential dayvig: *favepalm*. Dayvigs aren't supposed to shoot D1. They're supposed to shoot a guilty or if there are two very scummy lynch candidates later on, one of them.

[diddin]

I said a policy lynch. I never said anything about how quick the lynch had to be.

[diddin]

GIS setup speculation is baaaaaad. In Kingdom of Loathing Mafia some of the "Guild Chiefs" who helped the hero were part of the Penguin Mafia. Not to mention this is a bastardmod game. Not to mention you're speculating in a quite scummy matter.

@MOD: My Vote is on GIS/Gandalf despite what your log says.

unvote, Vote: GandalfIzSik

if you need me to vote again.

According to your last vote post, you did not unvote someone you have already voted.

I actually did explain my ISO 10 right up there^. I was voting GIS for his scummy speculation.

FoS David

for sheeping off Gollum

[diddin]

Ugh, my weekend V/LA has given me little to no time to catch up. I'll respond to a few things.

-@My Gandalf Vote: I don't always think setup speculation is scummy, but I think the way Gandalf did it was.

/confirm

Am I the only person with a really vague role PM?

The way this was worded it looks like a rolefishing question, and I don't like that, when he gets flak for it, he just uses meta defense by claiming he softclaims every game. It looks like he was trying to cover his tracks.

-@Dana- I really haven't been able to spend a lot of time on this game yet. Also, I don't believe you have played with me before on D1. My D1 play is generally a lot worse than my play later on because D1 is always such a mess to me.

-@Shark- I know David said he was suspicious of me before, but he never explained anything. He just said it looked like I could be scum with MS. It looks to me like he's trying to piggyback off of other's suspicion.

[diddin]

*goodposting* from chkflip.

I'm failing to see the scum case on Dana... I'll look it over this weekend.

[diddin]

I mentioned vigbait because, by extent, I would not want to lynch that person yet.

[diddin]

There isn't one.

While this may be true to some degree so far, I'm pretty sure come D-2 one will magically appear out someone's ass, as they're prone to do.

Man... I can already smell the nauseating stench of BS in the guise of brilliant deduction.

Took you long enough to post again. Still posting garbage I see...

Anywho, I like the wagon on muh so I will...

extinguish Midnight
burn muh

This is the first time mallow has said anything about muh. At all. BAAAAAAAAH? BAAAAAAAAA!

Prepare an extra match for: mallowgeno

[diddin]

Congrats Aurorus (Sig)

Hello, standard "I'm trying to be active" fluff.

I'm actually ok with Shotty coming in. My policy lynch call was actually semi-serious, but it was also partially a move to generate discussion. If Shotty starts being Shotty again, I will re-pursue the PL.

2 things wrong with muh's claim:

1. He claimed Vanilla in a game that, as a bastard game, I believe to be vanillaless.
2. He didn't claim a character name.

FAKECLAIM CAUGHT

[diddin]

Unvote

I believe Muh's claim is legitimate.

I'm going back to my old vote

Fry Midnight Sorrow

This guy should burn tomorrow, methinks.

[diddin]

People asking David to nameclaim-=scummy. He roleclaimed to prove a point, in which the name should not matter. However Muh not nameclaming so close to lynch is a sign of a fakeclaim.

[diddin]

So... your entire case on him is "He's posted nothing of worth"... why shouldn't we lynch you tomorrow based on the back of the exact same reasons?

^

Posting fluff is in Midnight's meta. He's really hard to read. However Mallow's attacking of Midnight for something like that is complete, total hypocrisy.

[diddin]

Hail Lord Bowser!

Reverted due to the rules.

[diddin]

Wait so how did I die?

Good game to all.

[diddin]

ok I see. I was switched to target Gandalf and everyone who targeted him died cause of Kamikaze.