Mini 1087 - The Dresden Files Game Over!

[LimMePls]

Fate, even if there is a hypothetical vig out there, why would we want him shooting at Zd anyways? It doesn't make sense. Zd being alive tomorrow proves nothing.

@MOD: T'anks for VC. I CAN HAZ SMARG PROD?

She's not quite at the 72 hours point yet but yes I'll send a preemptive prod.

[Antihero]

Butters? Bulletproof? The flavor already doesn't fit.

Zdenek DOESN'T DIE TODAY.

I don't think I made myself clear enough.

What vig?

This clown's rolefishing though, and needs rope.

Oh, yes. Because your plan would require a hypothetical vig to claim tomorrow to clear Z. That's nothing close to rolefishing.

I think I'll take the advice you game me earlier.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Fate

[Zdenek]

Butters? Bulletproof? The flavor already doesn't fit.

Something else that doesn't fit:

If I haven't read the books, am I going to be able to follow the TV show?

Butters? Bulletproof? The flavor already doesn't fit.

Explain yourself.

[Antihero]

Um, I watched some episodes of the first season of the TV show since I made that post, mr monkey poo flinger.

Butters is the coroner, right?

[Zdenek]

Um, I watched some episodes of the first season of the TV show since I made that post, mr monkey poo flinger.

Butters is the coroner, right?

"He appears briefly in Changes, when he is called over by Molly Carpenter, and ends up trying to revive Harry Dresden with a defibrillator after his heart stops. A hitman then plants two rounds into his back. Butters survives because prior to coming over, he put on a bullet proof suit because of Harry's track record with trouble."

http://dresdenfiles.wikia.com/wiki/Waldo_Butters

Mr. I'm going to attack a claim for no good reason.

[Oopidstay]

Zdenek DOESN'T DIE TODAY.

I don't think I made myself clear enough.

What vig?

This clown's rolefishing though, and needs rope.

You sure you're actually back, Fate? Because this is a whole load of bullshit.

• 1. There is no proof that we have a vig, so making plans that involve using one is completely pointless.
  
  2. Even if we have a vig, having him shooting Zed is also completely pointless.
  
  3. Me ridiculing you for wanting to leave Zed's fate to the hypothetical vig is not rolefishing.

Now put your vote back on Zed, or my black hyena foot will reach through your screen and kick your ass. Got it?

Flavor is absolutely pointless with regards to clearing people. Either any flavor role can be scum, or the mod gave the scum fakeclaims, so they won't get caught by the flavor.

FoS: Antihero

His Fate push looks artificial and contrived.

[smargaret]

I believe Butters as bulletproof. He certainly hangs out with Harry enough that he ought to be dead, but isn't. I'm very uncomfortable with how quickly the wagon built up, and suspect there was scum on it - and oop's rolefishing is enough for me to wagon him. I don't like Fate directing the hypothetical vig, but it's Fate, so it's not a scumtell.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Oop

@ Mod: Sorry, I thought I'd posted yesterday.

[Antihero]

FoS: Antihero

His Fate push looks artificial and contrived.

I've been doing it the whole game, monkey poo flinger #3. Say something substantial or STFU.

Fate's play in this game has been consisting of a bunch of crap attacks, not characteristic of Fatetown.

[Antihero]

Um, I watched some episodes of the first season of the TV show since I made that post, mr monkey poo flinger.

Butters is the coroner, right?

"He appears briefly in Changes, when he is called over by Molly Carpenter, and ends up trying to revive Harry Dresden with a defibrillator after his heart stops. A hitman then plants two rounds into his back. Butters survives because prior to coming over, he put on a bullet proof suit because of Harry's track record with trouble."

http://dresdenfiles.wikia.com/wiki/Waldo_Butters

Mr. I'm going to attack a claim for no good reason.

Screw you. W/ my limited knowledge the flavor didn't fit.

[smargaret]

The flavor doesn't fit with the TV shows, which basically adapt the first book. It does fit with later books. Nulltell to both of you.

(and honestly, if I were a normal human, I'd wear a bulletproof vest before spending any time with Harry Dresden too. His normal human friends tend to wind up dead or turned into vampires.)

[Oopidstay]

<snip> oop's rolefishing <snip>

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Oop

Super HoS: smargaret

The only reason this isn't a vote is because Zed's wagon is bigger and he needs lynching, too.

[Oopidstay]

I've been doing it the whole game, monkey poo flinger #3. Say something substantial or STFU.

Yeah, and it looked fake as hell then, too.

On a side note, you jumped off the wagon of someone whose claim you didn't believe at the time to go after someone who was/is nowhere close to getting lynched today. Hmm...

[Antihero]

I've been doing it the whole game, monkey poo flinger #3. Say something substantial or STFU.

Yeah, and it looked fake as hell then, too.

On a side note, you jumped off the wagon of someone whose claim you didn't believe at the time to go after someone who was/is nowhere close to getting lynched today. Hmm...

Your hair looks as purple as hell.

Just because I say it doesn't make it so. Back it up.

You're starting to piss me off with this chainsawing for no damn reason, hyena. I'm going to say what I said before. Say something substantial or STFU.

Excuse me, where did I say I didn't believe the claim? I said the flavor was off, and now that that's resolved, there's no reason to not believe the claim. Get your head out of your ass, please.

[TheButtonmen]

Just a reminder people;

Quck n' Dirty Rule Set:

2. Keep it at least moderately polite and respectful.

I don't feel it necessary to step in at the moment but we are slowly approaching the point where I feel the need to demonstrate what a cruel and capricious mod I am.

[Fate]

The hypothetical vig is not shooting Zdenek, that was an oversight on my part.

The existence of the hypothetical vig shooting someone else makes Zdenek's role plausible.

Hence, Zdenek doesn't die today and we go after new targets.

I almost want to wagon Enigma because my Oopids read isn;t that strong and SMARGTRZ of all people voted him.

Speaking of Smargaret...

[Fate]

Smargaret why didn't you post on the day I had come back and posted content?

Unvote:
Vote: Smargaret

"I thought I had posted in this game yesterday"

Just reeks scum to me. Like she is only trying to post in this game as minimal as possible (and reading her ISO it is really friggin bare) to coast by, instead of actually READING and following along with this game and posting when she has something to say.

[Antihero]

Sorry, mod, I just had a "I hate the world" moment. I'm sure hyena is great person whose head is very far away from his ass.

[Oopidstay]

The hypothetical vig is not shooting Zdenek, that was an oversight on my part.

The existence of the hypothetical vig shooting someone else makes Zdenek's role plausible.

Hence, Zdenek doesn't die today and we go after new targets.

Ok, I can buy this idea for now.

Unvote: Zdenek

Vote: smargaret

[smargaret]

Fate, like you, I'm dealing with some stuff IRL. I'm coasting a bit this week, unless you want me posting under the influence of benadryl. Pot, meet kettle? And speaking of coasting, let's look at CityofAs and Enigma. Actually, CityofAs hasn't moved his vote at all day 1, nor has he commented on anyone but me. Tunneling much? Also, David Parker promised a content post on Saturday and hasn't posted it yet. Plus,

I think he may be due for a prod too.

I'm still not following the vig thing. We don't know if we have a vig (and I don't want to know), and even if we do, I don't get how the vig shooting someone other than Zdenek clears him. Sure, having a vig and a bulletproof townie is one way to balance things, but a bulletproof townie is also balance for an overpowered scum team, or lack of a doc, or any number of things.

[Fate]

Ok but you never explained you were dealing with anything, you just lurked.


And your Oopids vote is pretty bad.

Like I said I Could be down for an Enigma vote and I think I had CityofAs as scum at one point but I've completely forgot any content from him at all.


Also this week? Hasn't this thread been open for 2 weeks+?

[smargaret]

Yes, and I was participating last week (well, better than this week, anyway). How is my oop vote bad? He did something scummy, I wagoned him, he proceeded to OMGUS me and it's not the first scummy thing he's done.

[Fate]

Show me a case on him, if you have time and are up for an ISO.

[smargaret]

A brief case:

He's sheeping - Antihero's arguments on Mari, your arguments on me, LMP's arguments on Zdenek. The FOS's all rub me the wrong way - one or two, okay, but the pattern of FOS someone and then two-three posts later vote them seems off, like testing the waters. That may be a meta thing and I need to read some other games and see if it is. He keeps contradicting himself - Mariyta's reaction to the daykill is scummy, but it's legitimate for town not to want to die? He disagrees with fitz's push on LMP, votes LMP anyway, and says he has his own reason for it but doesn't ever describe it? Quick reversals - he FOS's LMP, but then suddenly LMP is town as town can be - I strongly suspect that there is a connection between LMP and Oop. The previously mentioned points. The overly-long and unnecessary wallposts that make it look like he's contributing a lot (see the objection! post).

I'll flesh it out tomorrow if you want specific post numbers and quotes.

[Fate]

I'll have to re-ISO him myself, but you didn't comment on his Fitz interaction which I think takes up a chunk of his ISO.

[Fate]

Hmmm I ISO'd Oopidstay:

Bad news smarg, I think you're scum who took 25mins to make a case on him because he wasn't actually a suspect of yours prior to you jumping on the bandwagon I was starting. Then when I asked you for a case you went through his ISO and posted whatever stuck out as scummy.

Instead of going through his ISO genuinely trying to get a read on him (which is what I JUST DID, and I got a town read).

I hope things get better for you IRL, they will though-trust me.