Open 268: Raise the White Flag (Game Over)

[Equinox]

Vote Count 2.01

rekirtS (2) - bvoigt, Cookie_of_Death
drmyshottyizsik (1) - silverbullet999

Not Voting (6) - andrew94, Chaotic Neutrality, chkflip, drmyshottyizsik, rekirtS, Stefunny

With 9 alive, it's 5 to lynch.

The deadline is Tuesday, December 28, 11:59 PM EST (UTC-5).

[rekirtS]

1st off: lol at the fact that almost no one said anything about shotty's threat

yesterday

.

Now, as for the shotty, I'm kind of thinking now that he's town. I doubt we would see such a reckless hammer from scum.

Wifom.

@ bvoigt Seemed like pretty crucifying evidence at the time. I thought for sure he'd come up scum. There really wasn't much else for me to say, as he didn't even regonize that he crumbed it after it being pointed out.

Wait a second, was that really the issue here? My issue was that he gave me two seemingly contradictory messages with post 53 and post 54.

VOTE: rekirtS

I didn't vote Shotty cause I wanted to hear from him first. no need to rush another quick lynch.

Not sure I get what you mean here. The issue was he crumbed cop and was still played (or I guess genuine...) ignorance after someone (andrew?) pointed it out. If I thought he deliberately crumbed cop the next step was to vote him. There wasnt much I could have expanded upon that hadn't been said.

EDIT: Quote tag corrected.

[drmyshottyizsik]

First off thats not truely WIFOM, and secondly say wifom with out explaination is scummy reki

Second, Andrew stop just posting fluff.

Thirdly, SB if your vote on me was for your reason stated, and then you realized your reason was wrong, then why are you still voting me?

[Cookie_of_Death]

1st off: lol at the fact that almost no one said anything about shotty's threat

yesterday

.

Now, as for the shotty, I'm kind of thinking now that he's town. I doubt we would see such a reckless hammer from scum.

Wifom.

Whatever

I didn't vote Shotty cause I wanted to hear from him first. no need to rush another quick lynch.

There was only 1 vote on shotty at the time and there's 6 to lynch. You seriously didn't vote him because you feared a quicklynch?

[andrew94]

firstly, there isnt a person called striker in this game

to whoever who wants evidence on shotty's idiocy, refer to ALL his games.

i dont think anyone is going to rush a 'quick lynch' after a quick lynch happened on day 1. poor reasoning striker/ whoever that is

[drmyshottyizsik]

hey andrew try spelling rekirtS back wards

[rekirtS]

First off thats not truely WIFOM, and secondly say wifom with out explaination is scummy reki

Wasn't aware its scummy...

Its not? Thought it was. Like "a scum wouldn't make a questionable hammer vote"... or would he? If hes scum did he do it because a scum wouldn't do it? Sounds like Princess Bride to me, but I could be mistaken.

@ Cookie I didn't vote him because I didn't want him lynched. You don't vote someone unless you're willing to lynch them do you? I wanted to hear him talk rather. Read my prior sentence.

Shotty, who do you think are the scum right now? Besides calling me scummy you haven't even contributed anything.

Okay to clarify, "no need to rush another quick lynch" wasn't meant to be said as if I vote him its gonna be a quicklynch. Just meant I wasn't going to vote as hastily as I did the day before.

[bvoigt]

I didn't vote Shotty cause I wanted to hear from him first. no need to rush another quick lynch.

There was only 1 vote on shotty at the time and there's 6 to lynch. You seriously didn't vote him because you feared a quicklynch?

Yeah, I don't like this either. You're trying to appear pro-town by telling us to avoid another quicklynch, when there is really no reason to avoid voting.

Preview Edit: You had no problem placing a hasty 4th vote, but you aren't going to place a hasty 1st vote?

[rekirtS]

I didn't vote Shotty cause I wanted to hear from him first. no need to rush another quick lynch.

There was only 1 vote on shotty at the time and there's 6 to lynch. You seriously didn't vote him because you feared a quicklynch?

Yeah, I don't like this either. You're trying to appear pro-town by telling us to avoid another quicklynch, when there is really no reason to avoid voting.

Preview Edit: You had no problem placing a hasty 4th vote, but you aren't going to place a hasty 1st vote?

I had no problem placing a 'hasty' 4th vote on someone who

breadcrumbed

COP rather than putting a 2nd* vote on someone who I just wanna hear who his scum suspects were.

[drmyshottyizsik]

If I had to pick striker i would say CoD and Stef

[Cookie_of_Death]

Its not? Thought it was. Like "a scum wouldn't make a questionable hammer vote"... or would he? If hes scum did he do it because a scum wouldn't do it? Sounds like Princess Bride to me, but I could be mistaken.

Somehow I don't think that much thought went into shotty's hammer.

@ Cookie I didn't vote him because I didn't want him lynched. You don't vote someone unless you're willing to lynch them do you? I wanted to hear him talk rather. Read my prior sentence.

Well, I disagree with that, but this isn't MD so I don't think a debate on this is going to be productive.

P.Edit: striker didn't mean for you to use random.org, shotty.

[rekirtS]

If I had to pick striker i would say CoD and Stef

Thank you. Now not to be an entire pain in the ass but if you could give a short one or two sentence on why that'd be splendid.

@ Cookie I'm not saying it did, just saying its complete WIFOM. Hes not townie because "a scum wouldn't make it that blatant" or whatever crap was that.

[silverbullet999]

OK so 1st off V/LA for undetermined amount of time (feel free to replace me or what not if needed) My laptop is out of commission and needs to be fixed thus I do not know when I'll be able to hop on.

Noted.

-shotty

Thirdly, SB if your vote on me was for your reason stated, and then you realized your reason was wrong, then why are you still voting me?

Please read post 117

-Andy

if you think shotty is being the typical idiot , why did you vote him. hurr hurr

LEARN TO READ YOU FRACKEN VI!

[silverbullet999]

*also meant to apologize for the V/LA*

[andrew94]

^^ read WHAT

[Chaotic Neutrality]

I think being an anti town player and being part of the mafia can be two different things. Yes, shotty hammered, but I'm getting the feeling that he just does that kind of stuff, scum or not.

It can, but it's very difficult to tell the difference. Shotty gave a warning, sure. That doesn't mean his hammer wasn't scummy. He made 3 posts before hammering; the first declared V/LA and willingness to hammer, the second simply said wolf is scummy, and the third was a second warning of the upcoming hammer. That gives

nothing

. No contribution to town, no reasoning, just a willingness to ride the biggest bandwagon. Even if that

is

his meta, we can't simply ignore every scummy thing he says and dismiss it as meta.

VOTE:

drmyshottyizsik

*

*Vote subject to change later tonight when I get around to re-reading day 1

1st off: lol at the fact that almost no one said anything about shotty's threat

yesterday

.

He only hammered just yesterday. I really didn't see the problem with him until I read it all in ISO.

Now, as for the shotty, I'm kind of thinking now that he's town.

Wait, what?

I doubt we would see such a reckless hammer from scum.

Are you really trying to argue he's TOWN because he hammered so ridiculously? I think that's the most ridiculous argument I've ever heard to keep VI scum

in

the game. "He's so scummy he MUST be town!"

[bvoigt]

@Shotty: could you please provide the links to a couple of your completed town games, and a couple of your completed scum games?

[andrew94]

@ bvoigt, just in all his games he plays like that, in those that he is not lynched, he ends up being scum

fos: chaotic neutral for that small pint

[drmyshottyizsik]

ok so finally i am not busy. The show i was in ended tonight so i will be all yours mod.

@Striker- for CoD- he seems to either blow off what people say about him or twist what they say. Also he has an underlying push for my lynch in most of his posts.

and Stef, mainly because i am very null about her, and I have a decent town read from all others.

[Cookie_of_Death]

@Striker- for CoD- he seems to either blow off what people say about him

That's because what people have said about me are insignificant and stupid.

or twist what they say.

Where was this?

Also he has an underlying push for my lynch in most of his posts.

You do know I called you town...right?

Are you really trying to argue he's TOWN because he hammered so ridiculously? I think that's the most ridiculous argument I've ever heard to keep VI scum in the game. "He's so scummy he MUST be town!"

But...shotty isn't scummy.
My arguement is that your scumtell doesn't hold.

[drmyshottyizsik]

I never said the last one, and I know you said I was town, but it's always seemed back handed to me

[drmyshottyizsik]

Scum games

Open 255: Fake God's Double cop mafia =DDD
Open 243: Elscouta's Polygamist Mafia (best game ever!)
Open 262: Gandalf's Hard boiled
Open 257: Muffin's Science Mafia

Town Games!

Mini 1057: Chevre's Unsubsized Mafia
Open 258: Smashbro's Night Watch
Excedrin's Newbie 983

[Stefunny]

Sorry, Emergency V/LA. Family member in the hospital. I'll try and check in soon.

Noted.

[Equinox]

Really, guys, 20 hours and no posts? I was hoping you'd bump this for me. Sigh.

chkflip will be prodded if he doesn't post in 7 hours.

chkflip has been prodded.

silverbullet999 is V/LA for an indefinite period.
Stefunny is V/LA until December 19.

[Equinox]

Bump for vote count.