The Big Game

[Dekes]

Seriously, this game....

@CES
You are the only one here I feel no shame in asking: Why?


And for the love of God, don, if you weren't cleared in my book for preventing the Jack lynch on D2, I would vote you on the spot. I have a crazy theory about you but I'd rather go Ockam's Razor here and put you down as idiotic town.
You've spent all of yesterday theorizing about your cop role instead of scum hunting only to suddenly vote Jack based on Uite's RVS vote and subsequent hopping off of Jack's wagon.
And if you are indeed the cop why do I always have to keep asking you about your result? One might think your first instict as an outed cop with scum apparently lacking a nk would be coming forward with a result first thing on the off chance that you are an insane cop. What do you do? Voting no lynch....again....
How about trying something wicked like regular scumhunting instead? Who's scum and why?

If Fate is scum he's at least making an effort. And there's not a lot incriminating on him anyway. There's the fact he flipflopped on Jack being town and scum within two pages twice. But I'vee seen Fate play that way as town in LOTR mafia. I still think he would have no problem bussing Uite to the extreme, since I guess he'd wanna have the whole glory for himself anyway.
But his victory gloating

felt

genuine. And he's at least actively scumhunting throughout the game.

CES has done shit the whole game. CES' D1 was nicely summarized by Jack. On D2, despite having Jack as his 100% scumpartner for Uite, CES hopped on the Zang wagon wihout a single question, because "having a non-sane cop would make it to easy for scum". Yeah, right, because it was apparent that we had either a protective role or even masons or scum lacked a night kill to balance the non-sane cop out. And don even said he was not sanity confirmed.
On D3 he had two posts: Voting Jack and claiming....that's it.
And now on D4 he's going for the apparently obvious choice again after having me not mentioned once before.

Vote: CES

Btw, this will be my last wall of text in this thread, promise.

[don_johnson]

No lynch is best option. If scum has no nk then we no lynch til I find scum.

[Dekes]

Chances are high you're paranoid anyway. So wou'd you target?

[mykonian]

votecount

Dekes (1): Cogito Ergo Sum
Cogito Ergo Sum (1): Dekes
No Lynch (1): don_johnson

not voting (1): Fate

With 4 players, it's 3 to lynch (and 2 to no-lynch)

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Dekes, you're the obvious choice because of process of elimination. Fate is obvtown; don_johnson helped with the Uite-lynch and has a credible claim.

I think my Zangvote makes much more sense if you take into account that I came into this game expecting a C9-type set-up, not whatever freak of nature this set-up is. There's a preponderance of evidence now that we're in a weird set-up, but at the time there was nothing to tip me off. The notion that a non-sane cop would be balanced by a lack of nightkill is not something that occured to me.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

P.S. We're not going to no-lynch, don_johnson, don't be dumb.

[don_johnson]

If we lynch we lynch dekes. I don't see any reason to do so. One more night works to our advantage. It just might win us the game.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

If this game is broken, then I don't care whether we win it or not. No-lynching just wastes our time.

[Dekes]

@CES
PoE isn't gonna cut it.
See, FMPOV you are the one left due to PoE AND unlike you I provided some evidence against how you've been coasting along hopping on any convenient wagon without sharing any info or opinions whatsoever.
Fate assumed in the very first post on D2 that scum might have no nk, so why did you completey ignore this possibility and the possibility of a non-sane cop? Seems like a lot of squirming here to justify your Zang vote.

@don
Pro town-tip: Transparency is a good thing. That applies to your results as well as your scum reads. I know it must suck to draw cop and probably not being able to help town with it. But you still got your brains and now it might be the time to use it. A good start is re-reading the thread and making up your own mind. If you should come to the wrong conclusion that you think I must be the last scum, fine, but at least support it with reasoning instead of going for the easy target and concentrating on whether you are insane or paranoid.

[don_johnson]

Don't tell me how to play. Vote no lynch. If scum has an nk they can use it and narrow down the field. If not I can get one more investigation. Worst case is we end up back here. Why are you both so eager?

[Dekes]

Quit stalling, don. Who did you investigate?

[don_johnson]

I'm not stalling. I'm voting no lynch. If fate votes one of you then ill reveal. Otherwise ill take it to night phase. Capece?

[Fate]

Well I'm not going to vote my mason buddy obviously.

Now claim your damn investigations

[don_johnson]

Guilty on CES. Could have self investigated to determine whether or not I was paranoid, but whatever.

vote: dekes

[Dekes]

If you had a shred of case, reason, whatsoever, don, that would be super dandy. Otherwise I won't be able to take you as a serious mafia player in the future.

[Dekes]

Guess, it's down to Fate to bring sanity to the town...what a fucking scary thought.

[Fate]

Oh so now I'M INSANE???

DIE FUCKER DIE.

[Dekes]

Well, actually I've more problems with don's sanity. And I don't mean role wise.

[don_johnson]

Zang got a guilty on you. I am obviously not sane. So my guess is that Zang was sane. If you werent in such a rush, I could have targeted myself tonight and confirmed my state of mind. Don't blame me because you don't want to cooperate.

[Fate]

This game would be broken D1 by massclaim if one of you were non paranoid
VOTE: No lynch

Die Dekes fucker die.

[Dekes]

Good thing you're only picking on me, don. You can't confirm yourself by targeting yourself. You'll get another guilty whether you're paranoid or insane. Unless you're scum of course.
Why does there have to be a sane cop in this setup?
I also love how your play only revolves aorun you being cop for two days straight. There's more to mafia than following the cop. Especially if it's obvious that there are heavy sanity issues at work here.

Preview edit:
Point being?

[Dekes]

EBWOP:
Also, if you were so interested in confirming yourself why didn't you target yourself last night already? You suggested yesterday that you might be able to confirm yourself by targeting yourself? What stopped you last night?

I hope for your sake that you're the last scum, then gg....otherwise....Jesus Christ.

[don_johnson]

unvote, vote: no lynch

[Fate]

Dj isn't the last scum

[Fate]

I regret no lynching at work. I was hoping for style points, but meh.

D_J as Dekes said investigating yourself is dumb as hell, have you even asked the mod if you can do it yet?

Investigate me instead since I'm confirmed town for not hammering Dekes.

I'd cry if CES was the last scum, but otherwise just go ahead and quicklynch Dekes tomorrow whether I'm alive or not.