SMBM 1: IoBC GAME OVER! CONGRATULATIONS: TOWN AND KAMIKAZE!

[chkflip]

I love it when neighbors get wifi for Christmas. That's always the best. <3

I don't think anybody (save maybe Lord Bowser) is mad at you, ish happens.

[Bunnylover]

@Chkflip: Their is one, the shark person named Jonathan Jones, to his friends Johnny.

[curiouskarmadog]

vote Bunnylover

got a feeling....also not buying the above vote.

bunny why no comment on this?

[Bunnylover]

vote Bunnylover

got a feeling....also not buying the above vote.

bunny why no comment on this?

How do I comment on ones gut feeling?
Your not buying me vote, thats fine. I don't need your approval to keep my vote, but at least I know your opinion.

Also the main reason I didn't comment was because in past game I over react when defending myself to one or two votes, which causes more votes on me. I'm trying to play a little differently this time.

[danakillsu]

I'm not going to vote yet, because I think a vote without reasoning is usually scummy, and I have no reasoning to back a vote right now.

what was your motivation behind this useless post?

Making sure that everyone knew what I thought of some of the recent votes

without reasoning and that everyone knew I was still here, reading this game.

lets go into detail on this....what votes...I think i am missing what votes this is directed towards.

DavidParker's, Iecerint's, and yours.

[mallowgeno]

As I recall from the game, Valentina is one of Booster's cronies. Why would Valentina be a townie? She stole the throne from Mallow and she attacks with her pesky dodo bird.

[Iecerint]

You could ask the same question of Belome (already flipped town).

And nope, Valentina is a separate agent. Nothing to do with Booster.

[DavidParker]

I know nothing of the flavour to this specific mario game so will not be voting with relation to flavor unless someone has a hugely-convincing case with regard to it.

[curiouskarmadog]

I'm not going to vote yet, because I think a vote without reasoning is usually scummy, and I have no reasoning to back a vote right now.

what was your motivation behind this useless post?

Making sure that everyone knew what I thought of some of the recent votes

without reasoning and that everyone knew I was still here, reading this game.

lets go into detail on this....what votes...I think i am missing what votes this is directed towards.

DavidParker's, Iecerint's, and yours.

You posted the original post on 608…at that time.

vote Bunnylover

got a feeling....also not buying the above vote.

Since one of the flips is a hero from the rpg, and a town flip at that, I also wonder at you saying that we need to look at the villian claims. Especially given that you questioned DP who claimed a Mario affiliated character.

Huh?

VOTE: Midnight's Sorrow

Gut s/p listing the two flipped scum by name in that last post + iso that focuses on commentary and mechanics-y stuff rather than analysis

Also, my other gut suspect (jimfinn) got town points upon iso for the fake daykill.

pull em off the spit: bunnylover

Cook to a crisp: swiftstrike

RVS is over, this guy is scum.

Ok, I get David parker…but Iece provides his reasoning as do I..

So if we are scummy, isn’t that a reason to vote?

[curiouskarmadog]

vote Bunnylover

got a feeling....also not buying the above vote.

bunny why no comment on this?

How do I comment on ones gut feeling?
Your not buying me vote, thats fine. I don't need your approval to keep my vote, but at least I know your opinion.

Also the main reason I didn't comment was because in past game I over react when defending myself to one or two votes, which causes more votes on me. I'm trying to play a little differently this time.

ok, this seems like an acceptable answer..downgrade to an Fos then...

unvote, vote danakillsu

not liking his posting today..."X is scummy, I am directing this toward 3 people who are doing X, I dont have reason to vote"....that post looks like someone who is trying to look town...if you think someone is scummy for doing something...that is a god damn reason to vote. your post doesnt makes since if you really believed what you are saying....

[danakillsu]

You posted the original post on 608…at that time.

Not sure what you're saying, but what I said still stands.

not liking his posting today..."X is scummy, I am directing this toward 3 people who are doing X, I dont have reason to vote"....that post looks like someone who is trying to look town...if you think someone is scummy for doing something...that is a god damn reason to vote. your post doesnt makes since if you really believed what you are saying....

Wrong. It's not a reason to vote because 3 people did it. How am I supposed to decide whether to vote you, DP, or Iecerint? Iecerint has not said anything else scummy this game, voting you would look like OMGUS, and DP always looks scummy. I'm waiting for further information, although this blind attack on me helps.

[jimfinn]

"Voting you would look like OMGUS" - very concerned with not doing something that looks scummy, which is itself indicative of the scum's state of mind of avoiding potential slips. Combine that with the case on three people without voting any.

unvote

Vote:dana

[Swiftstrike]

Going back over the game to see if anything stands out nothing of particular has struck me anyone than it has before, as such I still find Midnight sorrow lack of any real substance to post in now 28 posts really sticks out.

Vote Midnight Sorrow

And masterfully Bowser can you prod Head Honcho please as he hasn't posted in sometime now.

[Zdenek]

Mod: I will be V/LA until Jan. 4

However, I will hopefully have time to read through today or tomorrow and post.

[Zdenek]

So less has happened than I'd thought . . .

My top two at the moment are Midnight's Sorrow and Dana for reasons given yesterday, and they've done nothing to help me change my opinion.

I'm also waiting to see if there is a chef torte in the game.

[danakillsu]

"Voting you would look like OMGUS" - very concerned with not doing something that looks scummy, which is itself indicative of the scum's state of mind of avoiding potential slips. Combine that with the case on three people without voting any.

unvote

Vote:dana

So wait...you read WHY I didn't vote anybody, but voted me because I didn't? That's idiotic. As far as the first thing, how am I going to get someone lynched if my vote looks like OMGUS? Even as a townie, it's hard to get anywhere with a vote that looks like OMGUS.

[jimfinn]

Yes - I read your reason for not voting anyone and I think it is a terrible reason. So I vote you.

[curiouskarmadog]

You posted the original post on 608…at that time.

Not sure what you're saying, but what I said still stands.

not liking his posting today..."X is scummy, I am directing this toward 3 people who are doing X, I dont have reason to vote"....that post looks like someone who is trying to look town...if you think someone is scummy for doing something...that is a god damn reason to vote. your post doesnt makes since if you really believed what you are saying....

Wrong. It's not a reason to vote because 3 people did it. How am I supposed to decide whether to vote you, DP, or Iecerint? Iecerint has not said anything else scummy this game, voting you would look like OMGUS, and DP always looks scummy. I'm waiting for further information, although this blind attack on me helps.

so you are doing stuff based on what you would look like?...if you think I am scum..vote me..who cares if it looks OMGUS...

what is blind about my attack?

[curiouskarmadog]

"Voting you would look like OMGUS" - very concerned with not doing something that looks scummy, which is itself indicative of the scum's state of mind of avoiding potential slips. Combine that with the case on three people without voting any.

unvote

Vote:dana

have you ever heard scum say that though?

[Bunnylover]

Ok, I understand CKD vote on Dana. It make sense.
But Dana explanation makes more sense.
He is right in saying that if 3 people are doing the exact same thing, how do you decide which one to attack?
But CKD vote is fine.
What I don't like, is Jimfinn vote.
Jimfinn vote to me looks fake. Everyone is self conscious about not looking scummy. No townie wants to look like scum, because they will create a mislynch.

Unvote, Vote: Jimfinn

[chkflip]

@BL: BAH! I knew that, but I was waiting for that person to come out and say that. If they came back and insisted it said Johnny, I would think of that as a scumslip. Am I crazy in thinking this, Bunny?

[Bunnylover]

Sorry about that Chkflip .
After I posted, I kinda wanted to get rid of it, as I just gave a person an excuse an a way out of a possible slip.

[danakillsu]

You posted the original post on 608…at that time.

Not sure what you're saying, but what I said still stands.

not liking his posting today..."X is scummy, I am directing this toward 3 people who are doing X, I dont have reason to vote"....that post looks like someone who is trying to look town...if you think someone is scummy for doing something...that is a god damn reason to vote. your post doesnt makes since if you really believed what you are saying....

Wrong. It's not a reason to vote because 3 people did it. How am I supposed to decide whether to vote you, DP, or Iecerint? Iecerint has not said anything else scummy this game, voting you would look like OMGUS, and DP always looks scummy. I'm waiting for further information, although this blind attack on me helps.

so you are doing stuff based on what you would look like?...if you think I am scum..vote me..who cares if it looks OMGUS...

what is blind about my attack?

First question is already answered.
Second question...maybe you would prefer...baseless? I agree that blind might not be quite the right word.

On the jimfinn front, I agree with Bunnylover. This merits more scumpoints than voting without a reason did for the three I already mentioned.

unvote? vote: jimfinn

[danakillsu]

And btw, although I can't remember what game it was, I have seen scum use the "are you careful about what others think of you?" argument against me before. Not trying to use this as proof, just saying that I have good reason to vote jimfiin.

[Baby Spice]

Sick of this. Really.

Head Honcho is Chef Torte, a mason.

He hasn't posted to the thread or the mason chat in about 25 days, and I've been asking our lord and master about it since around the third.


One thing I wanted from this game was someone to talk too, and lo both the hydra partner and the mason partner flake on me.

Not going to replace out because I know there's no replacements, though I really feel like it.