SMBM 1: IoBC GAME OVER! CONGRATULATIONS: TOWN AND KAMIKAZE!

[jimfinn]

In my experience, scum are far more self-conscious about looking scummy than town. I'm not saying I've actually heard scum say an exact phrase of that, but it feels like a very self-conscious thing for him to have written - which IMO is more indicative of scum than town, though certainly not the most powerful tell in the world

[curiouskarmadog]

In my experience, scum are far more self-conscious about looking scummy than town. I'm not saying I've actually heard scum say an exact phrase of that, but it feels like a very self-conscious thing for him to have written - which IMO is more indicative of scum than town, though certainly not the most powerful tell in the world

of course scum what to look town..but there is nothing scum-like about someone saying it out loud.

[jimfinn]

Scum wouldn't say it out loud on purpose - that's why it's a slip. The line of thinking is a scummy way of thought, but the player didn't realize it betrayed scum motivation.

[curiouskarmadog]

jim, have you been scum before?

[jimfinn]

yes, in a newbie and and M&L mafia and in Lie to Me Mafia and I think that's it. Maybe 2 newbies.

[DavidParker]

So, baby spice the fact you just claimed using the whole "sigh my life/role sucks reasoning", i'm guessing you're a scum mason who is trying to take over from your master chef because you are jealous of him??? HMMMM!M!?!??!?


I think one of dana or jimm is probably scum.

Midnight sorrow's wagon is still an appealing one too.

The swiftstrike wagon isnt going to happen i feel.

Today's lynch seems to be one of those first 3.

V/LA until jan 4th (holidaaays)

Unvote, vote: dana

[jimfinn]

http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=50&t=14870
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=54&t=15160
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=54&t=15161

I think that's all

[chkflip]

I have a problem with building more of a case against someone who's voted me first for the same reason, does that make me scum jimfinn? All I'm saying is that's a pretty loose reason for a vote. Seems like you're to garner more attention than it's worth to it.

FoS

!~

[jimfinn]

I wasn't trying to make this big of a deal out of it. It was a vote in response to a somewhat scummy statement, but it's certainly not the most interesting case out there and should not be monopolizing this discussion like it is.

[chkflip]

Which is the most interesting case out there?

[curiouskarmadog]

So, baby spice the fact you just claimed using the whole "sigh my life/role sucks reasoning", i'm guessing you're a scum mason who is trying to take over from your master chef because you are jealous of him??? HMMMM!M!?!??!?


I think one of dana or jimm is probably scum.

Midnight sorrow's wagon is still an appealing one too.

The swiftstrike wagon isnt going to happen i feel.

Today's lynch seems to be one of those first 3.

V/LA until jan 4th (holidaaays)

Unvote, vote: dana

interesting change of opinion with the waves of the game.

unvote, vote DavidParker

[Bunnylover]

V/L for the next 3 days, or at least limited access till Monday

[chkflip]

mallowgeno- MA MOLE
Gollum- Magikoopa
Nexus- johnny jones
Lowell- No-name
Bunnylover- Jinx
GhostWriter- Frogfucius
SharkFinn- Croco
DavidParker/MehPlusRawr- Toadofsky
Iecerint- Valentina
Midnight's Sorrow- Booster
curiouskarmadog- Mallow
chkflip- Princess Toadstool
danakillsu- Grate Guy
jimfinn- Yoshi
Zdenek- Toad
SwiftStrike- MARIO
Lakitu(Babyspice?)- Assistant to Chef Torte
Head_Honcho- Chef Torta

Lowell, even Baby Spice has an idea about his role. There's got to be something that's an easier/bigger clue.

[danakillsu]

Scum wouldn't say it out loud on purpose - that's why it's a slip. The line of thinking is a scummy way of thought, but the player didn't realize it betrayed scum motivation.

I have played as scum at least three times, although I might not be able to point you to all of them. I'm not retarded, and I don't think out loud. I don't really understand why you think I would talk truthfully about how I didn't want to appear if I was scum.

[SharkFinn]

Ok. sorry I havent posted in a while. Thoughts.

1. I have town reads on DP (reading dead players) and Baby Spice.
2. JimFinn: why did you ask for a mass name claim?
3. I still dont understand the RVS at the beginning of today.
4. Dont know how I feel about danakillsu/jimfinn/midnight's sorrow

[Midnight's Sorrow]

I see your up to your old hypocritical tricks again, mallowgeno.

How very showing.

But, if that is how you want to play, mallowgeno, then so be it. I'll play your game with out hesitation~

Unvote:BunnyLover
VOTE: mallowgeno

[Bowser]

Holidays PART 1 is over. Now, to go poke people with my claw.

Honcho is getting modkilled if he doesn't reply by the 3rd, unless I have a replacement.

Tentative deadline set for the 15th of January.

Any questions?

[Iecerint]

The chance that mallowgeno is scum is pretty low. I can't imagine Pa Mole being in the game without Ma Mole. They're both really minor characters. It also explains MG's otherwise-bizarre behavior yesterday.

[SharkFinn]

@iec: But do you think mallow is behaving like town or scum? This is bastard mod so pa mole can stillbe scum.

[Iecerint]

MG, could you more clearly characterize your role's relation to muh's?

[SharkFinn]

@Iec: could you answer or acknowledge the question above?

[Iecerint]

I thought about your question, and the answer I came up with led me to ask MG that question.

[mallowgeno]

@ Bowser, can you PM me my role again plz? I accidently deleted it >.>

As for the question, I thought it made sense that PA MOLE was a VT since I was a VT. If he had claimed a PR I would have spoken up.

As for now my vote shall remain unchanged on the OMGUSing MS

[Iecerint]

OK...then that means you're neither Neighbors nor Masons...

That is not what I expected.

Still, leaning town on /outguess, especially because both the flipped scum have been standard suspects. Could be scum if it's a fakeclaim, but I'm leaning against that because my role (= Valentina) implies scum shouldn't necessarily need fakeclaims AFAICT.

EDIT: Though those sentences kinda contradict one another now that I look at them... <_<

[SharkFinn]

Iec: why are you attempting to scumhunt using rolenames in a known bastard mod? Who knows, pa mole might be a wolf now that ma died. I don't think that's a good idea, but that's just my opinion. If you got a valid reason, I'd love to hear it.