Open 269: Multirole Mafia: Over. Town Win

[Chronopie]

Gandalf has requested replacement.

Edit: Filled by Shotty, no night extension granted.

[drmyshottyizsik]

/confirm

[Chronopie]

Due to a Mod Error, Night deadline is extended 24 hours. (That's about 2.5 days from this post)

Also, Happy News Years

[Chronopie]

A new day dawns on the once peaceful Town of Multia.

After the fiasco of yesterday's hanging, you hope the night has bought you better tidings.

Your hope was in Vain.

The first you found was

JesseSheffield

, who appears to have been tortured, brutally, before having his throat cut. No one heard his screaming. Or maybe no one wanted to...

Going through his pockets, you find a nothing but a bloodstained i.d, and you realise he was just a townie, caught up in the madness.

As if that wasn't enough, you head back to the meeting room you hung Chesskid in yesterday, only to find a trail of blood, leading straight to the body of

Chaotic Neutrality

.

You didn't need to go though his pockets however, as the killer made it clear just who, and what, his victim was. The Knife in his Pocket, still sticky with the blood of Jesse, further confirms your suspicions.

Looks like you have a second killer in your midst.

JesseSheffield (VT)

Stabbed Night One

Chaotic Neutrality (Mafia Goon)

Shot Night One

--

It is now Day 2, deadline is two weeks from this post.

[andrew94]

what mod error...

If you don't know, you don't need to...

[ThAdmiral]

Quite a few people look bad from yesterdays wagon, the worst for mine were the last three to jump on: smashbro, sleepless and gandalf.

also, i'm going to

vote: chesskid

to start. Not particularly liking his idea of a policy lynch, also, something interesting in ISO.

Nah, gandalf is town in this one.

I wouldn't mind some dead gandalf.

so, chesskid. reasoning behind this?

Not liking the policy lynch is a very weak reason to vote, especially since chess stopped pushing for it. Also chess often contradicts himself like the example above. As weird as it may seem it isn't a scumtell for chess.

Ok, so Chesskid and Smashbro are scum. Akira and implosion are town.

Vote Chesskid

To anyone with a problem with L-1 this early, suck it.

I've seen a few chesskid games where he says stupid shit and I'm thinking "the guy's obvtown" while he's being attacked. This isn't one of those games.

There is lots of things about this post that is bad. Saying certain people are scum and town with no reason is bad. Also not explaining what is different about this game to other games where chess is obvtown is bad. There is also a strong difference between someone being not obvtown and scum.

VOTE: chesskid

I realize he's on vacation, but if he has time to do that, he has time to explain his opinion-flip.

Hammering without a claim. Wtf?

All three are terribly scummy. I will decide who I want to vote after all three have responded.

[ThAdmiral]

Actually gandalf obviously can't respond...

vote: sleepless

I feel he was the scummiest by a slight margin.

[Akira]

Sleepless should post more, and I agree with what ThAdmiral said regarding him, as much as I like being called town (jk it doesn't mean anything without a reason).
VOTE: Sleepless

Also, the only thing I know about shotty is that I'm lucky to have never met him in a game yet. Is he an andrew-like VI?

[Akira]

Whoops I didn't mean to call shotty a VI, more like just I.

[chkflip]

He's nowhere near as bad as andrew, IMO, but he does have his nonsensical moments.

[drmyshottyizsik]

Yes I do, but that's not what we should be focusing on here now is it?

[chkflip]

Nah, but I figured I should come in and give a positive response instead of waiting for someone to be a jerk about it.

Have you read the thread?

[drmyshottyizsik]

On page 4 atm

[drmyshottyizsik]

ok i just finished reading my thoughts will come later, sorry I have to go now

[andrew94]

= =

explain gandalfs hammer

[drmyshottyizsik]

Ummm... ya I can't explain it, at all. He's weird, I asked him about it last night when I was at his house and he didn't have much to say about it.

[gandalf5166]

I didn't really think it would be appropriate to give him any info that a normal replacement wouldn't have. Just thought I should clear that up.

You replaced out.
Shut it.
<.<

[drmyshottyizsik]

true

[chesskid3]

I didn't really think it would be appropriate to give him any info that a normal replacement wouldn't have. Just thought I should clear that up.

You replaced out.
Shut it.
<.<

yeah, shut it.

/bah

[andrew94]

thadmiral, akira and chkflip are scummy as hell

[smashbro_of_the_SSS]

another player made these in my last game, thought it was helpful, so I'll be making the updated VCs too. Thanks Lateralus22.

The first Vote Count of Day One

Chesskid3

(3): Andrew, implosion, Akira

Gandalf5166

(1): Chevre

implosion

(1): ThAdmiral

ThAdmiral

(1):

Chaotic Neutrality

Chevre

(2):

Chesskid3

, gandalf5166

The second Vote Count of Day One

Chesskid3

(3): Andrew, Akira, Chevre

Chevre

(2): gandalf5166, implosion

implosion

(1): ThAdmiral

ThAdmiral

(1):

Chaotic Neutrality

Akira

(1):

Chesskid3

The Third Vote Count of Day One

Chesskid3

(6): Andrew, Akira, Chevre,

Chaotic Neutrality

, smashbro_of_the_SSS, Sleepless Assassin [L-1]

Chevre

(2): gandalf5166, implosion

implosion

(1): ThAdmiral

JesseSheffield

(1): chkflip

Akira

(1):

Chesskid3

The Final Vote Count of Day One

Chesskid3

(7): Andrew, Akira, Chevre,

Chaotic Neutrality

, smashbro_of_the_SSS, Sleepless Assassin, gandalf5166

Chevre

(1): implosion

implosion

(1): ThAdmiral

JesseSheffield

(1): chkflip

Akira

(1):

Chesskid3

@ andrew

how come ThAD is scummy? also, you have 3 people up there, and it should be 2 scum left. If you had to pick 2 of those 3, which would you choose as the final 2 scum, and why?



I'm a little worried to write gandalf/shotty off as scum, because even though it was a very scummy hammer, it seems almost too scummy. SA is definitely my top pick, having one post aside from his original right now, and it isn't bursting with towniness. Not voting though, in light of how quick the voting went yesterday. Looking forward to what shotty has to say about gandalf's play.

@ ThAD

--- I figured that I could get a better read on players by joining a wagon, and I decided it would either be chess or chevre for best effect. I wasn't very convinced about Chevre being scum, and chess seemed to be scummier, so I thought I would vote him, and point out the contradiction, which had yet to be mentioned. I assumed that people would know that I agreed with what they called him scummy for. Still, I definitely wasn't ready for a lynch on him, and was surprised when it happened.

[Chronopie]

The First Vote Count of Day Two

Sleepless Assassin (2)

: ThAdmiral, Akira

Not Voting (7): Everyone else

[drmyshottyizsik]

thadmiral, akira and chkflip are scummy as hell

for once I agree with andrew these were my first reads too

[implosion]

Sorry for low activity. I'd like to see SA post a bit more, and I'll look more at day one later.

[ThAdmiral]

@ ThAD

--- I figured that I could get a better read on players by joining a wagon, and I decided it would either be chess or chevre for best effect. I wasn't very convinced about Chevre being scum, and chess seemed to be scummier, so I thought I would vote him, and point out the contradiction, which had yet to be mentioned. I assumed that people would know that I agreed with what they called him scummy for. Still, I definitely wasn't ready for a lynch on him, and was surprised when it happened.

Ok.