I skimmed through his ISO and didn't find much... but then I noticed in ISO 34/Post 379, Umbrage basically has a way out for almost all of his reads.
oritz: calls him town, but says he's "trying to see the case on him". Could be used later by saying "Well, I see the case on him now!"
Cyberbob: calls him lurking town, but "wouldn't weep at his lynch". Self-explanatory imo.
TheAdmiral: calls him out for lurking, but mostly a nullread. Says there's bigger fish to fry. Could be used later by saying "He's been lurking", or something to that effect, plus the "fish to fry" statement gives off a vibe similar to the statement about Cyberbob.
chamber: says he possible scum due to gut. Could be used later by saying "Gee, I just knew he was scum" or something.
Fur: calls him anti-town for being a VI and not improving his play. Says he's scum if el simo is scum. Wouldn't be too hard to fall back on the VI thing as reasoning.
el simo: calls him impatient scum, also notes the furcolow connection. Since Umbrage thinks he's scum, it's easy to use this as a reason for voting later.
Pie: casts suspicion on me with the 3k->soras and "buddying" thing. Says we need more info of alignment. Can fall back on the former as reasoning later.
soras: was voting him at the time, self-explanatory
Olinea: "Probably the person I suspect the least. Therefore, I suspect him." ...
3K: Gut town read. Can be dismissed in the same way a gut scum read can be elaborated on.
TL: says his posts are bullshit. Plus null-read. Can use the former as basis voting for the replacement.
Aside from having some sort of possible backdoor for every read he has, there's this:
Umbrage wrote:Soras, that thing you said about explaining why these arguments are bullshit is a VERY good thing to do. Because right now I want you lynched, and it will take more than "this is utter bullshit" to change my mind.
Soras never explained anything, yet Umbrage switches to Fugi with a terrible reason (and then votes fur later) and PRETTY MUCH NEVER MENTIONS SORAS AGAIN. WHAT HAPPENED TO YOUR SCUMREAD? Instead, he latches on to fur as opposed to Thirdkoopa once the 3K wagon gains steam.
On that note,
FoS: soras
for not adding anything to discussion in his recent posts, or explaining why our attacks on him were bad like he promised. He can go tomorrow, or 3K can go tomorrow, but I really don't care about that right now.
I am not liking the fact that Umbrage calls 3K "gut-read town", sways the wagon off of 3K to soras (which I admittedly joined, yes), and when it's between 3K and fur he pushes fur like crazy. If 3K is scum, so is Umbrage, but it's completely possible that Umbrage is scum without 3K being scum. Combine all this with what I noticed about his reads and his IMO highly suspicious confirm vote on fur, plus his attempt at outing a softclaim (and voting the softclaimer to try and get a wagon started on them, lols):
Unvote, Vote: Umbrage
