Fringe Mafia (Game Over, role PMs posted)

[bv310]

vote: Empking

My thoughts: Smarg was the shapeshifter. Not like anyone's gonna believe me now, despite the fact that we had a shapeshifter-cop claim before, but hopefully you guys can still win this after you get rid of me.

Search for TM

[Empking]

Vote: bv

[Zang]

Vote: bv310

My thoughts: Smarg was the shapeshifter. Not like anyone's gonna believe me now, despite the fact that we had a shapeshifter-cop claim before, but hopefully you guys can still win this after you get rid of me.

She could not have been a shapeshifter because shapeshifters kill the person that they are becoming before shapeshifting so there can still only be one.

We need to lynch BV before Doombunny and TM are found dead.

[bv310]

How do you know that?

[bv310]

And now to see who the last scum is (since smarg was #1, and Emp is #2)

[Zang]

How do you know that?

Because I watch the show.

[bv310]

Well, that'll teach me to not keep watching after watching season 1 to back up for this game.

Now I'm wondering what the hell's going on with 2 Peter Bishops. IIRC, he's the only one without an alternate.

[Zang]

Which proves that you are scum.

[Primate]

Vote bv310

I think it's pretty obvious he's the scum. I suck at this game.

[bv310]

GG Scum. Emp, you're a devious SOB to get out of a cop guilty on you. Congratulations.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

So... uh... that's a lynch and possible game over? =/

[bv310]

Definitely a lynch, likely game, unless TM and DB both make miraculous comebacks.

[Zang]

So... uh... that's a lynch and possible game over? =/

Possible but very unlikely.

[bv310]

What motivation would I have to lie now Zang? You lynched another Townie, despite a Guilty. With two scum left and the other two missing, short of them returning it's game over.

[esuriospiritus]

[

DAY FOUR END

]

With great haste, Empking, Zang, and Primate string up bv310.

He was

Peter Bishop - TOWN Jack-of-all-Trades

.

From there, Empking and Primate make quick work of Zang and DizzyIzzy.

The scum team has won! Congratulations to Empking, Primate... and smargaret.

[esuriospiritus]

[

Non-Bastardy Role Names

]

TonyMontana - Nina Sharp - Chief Operating Officer (Shapeshifter Cop), Massive Dynamic
Furcolow - Brandon - Vanilla Townie
Zang - Olivia Dunham - Traverser of Worlds (passive)

sorasgoof/smargaret - Charlie Francis (alternate) - Shapeshifter

Shattered Viewpoint/ChannelDelibird - Phillip Broyles - Neighbourizer
foilist13/bv310 - Peter Bishop - Jack of all Trades
Doombunny9 - Astrid Farnsworth - Vanilla Townie

GhostWriter/Primate - Thomas Newton - Roleblocker
Empking - David Robert Jones - One-Shot Ninja

LordChronos - Gene the Cow - Vanilla Townie
Nocmen - Walter Bishop - Pathologist
HopOnMyJoystick - William Bell - Commuter

---

Commentary, Role PMs, etc to come soonishly.

[RobCapone]

TOLD YOU BITCHES EMP AND SMAR WERE SCUM

this is hop btw

town fails, how the fuck do you ignore the guilty on emp?

WOW JUST PLAIN FUCKING WOW

[Zang]

sorasgoof/smargaret - Charlie Francis (alternate) - Shapeshifter

shapeshifters kill the person that they are becoming before shapeshifting so there can still only be one.

[Primate]

TOLD YOU BITCHES EMP AND SMAR WERE SCUM

this is hop btw

town fails, how the fuck do you ignore the guilty on emp?

WOW JUST PLAIN FUCKING WOW

To be fair to the town, there was a point where lynching Emp and Smarg were functionally equivalent and they lynched Smarg, 'revealing' him as a liar.

Cheers to both my buddies, most of this win was you.

[Doombunny9]

Blargh. It was inevitable that bv was the lynch this last day but like I said D3, Emp really should have been the lynch.

I feel like inactivity and refusal to do anything was one of the big reasons that the town lost as at times it felt like a struggle to get people to actually do anything and as a result Emp and primate basically just got a free ride when they did the same thing.

I'm interested in seeing if anyone had any secret abilities hinted at N2.

[Primate]

I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of it was to do with the pages of crap that were D1/D2. Seems like that's the reason you lost CDB when you needed him, you nearly lost me (I was tempted to replace out soon after coming in), and it made rereading so unfun I just didn't bother.

[smargaret]

The only reason we won was because Emp got an extra kill and I got to frame bv.

The massclaim didn't make sense from a town POV; it told us that there was nothing town could do to prevent both kidnaps and it wasn't necessary because town could have gone for a no-lynch.

I don't think Emp was the right lynch day 3 from the town POV. You knew that one of BV and I was scum - it's a 50-50 shot that you guess right. However, you have a 50-50 shot that BV is town and telling the truth about the guilty on Emp, and then you have to worry about sanity issues, so the odds that Emp is scum given what town knew at that point were actually less than the odds that I was.

[smargaret]

Oh yeah, Hop, I was flying today which is why I didn't post in the qt. Sorry.

[TonyMontana]

Congrats to scum.

I appreciate you looking for me, bv. :p I still wouldn't have lynched you

WE SHOULD HAVE KNOWN FROM THE SILVERY BLOOD THAT SMARG WAS A SHAPESHIFTER.

I actually thought about pushing for an Empking lynch and then investigating Smarg, but I guess i would have been dead either way.

[Doombunny9]

I don't think Emp was the right lynch day 3 from the town POV. You knew that one of BV and I was scum - it's a 50-50 shot that you guess right. However, you have a 50-50 shot that BV is town and telling the truth about the guilty on Emp, and then you have to worry about sanity issues, so the odds that Emp is scum given what town knew at that point were actually less than the odds that I was.

If we lynched Emp first we would have pretty much known that you were scum and lynched you the day after whilst bv would be almost clear vs. what really happened. So while we didn't know it at the time, Emp should have been the lynch.