Blackest Night Mafia (GAME OVER!)

[tanstalas]

LOL NICE TAKING A QUOTE OUT OF CONTEXT.
For the record this was a comment directed at SENSFAN.

I know it was directed at Sensfan, however the point stands, why don't you take your own advice?

Not really, no. Considering you've done absolutely nothing except post giant walls of fluff.

That's your opinion. What have YOU done this game?

TAKE SOME MORE POSTS OUT OF CONTEXT PLEASE!

Those posts you quoted of mine came before ANY ring discussion took place.

Uhh, No they didn't - IT WAS MENTIONED AS EARLY AS ON THE FIRST PAGE (caps IS fun) check post #19, for comparison your post was #259

CAPSLAWKALLIANCE = ALIGNMENT CONFIRMED MASONS, NEXT!

So, you are saying you guys did arrange to submit the same colors?

And this is right after I explicitly stated that I was in class and was SKIMMING.
YOU ALSO NEED TO READ SINCE I'VE ALREADY EXPLAINED MANY TIMES WHY ATTACKING RECK AT THAT POINT WAS SCUMMYYYYYY.

You said you were in class in the post BEFORE this one. You said and I quote in your post #17 "Will be back after class, actually learning important stuff nao." then an HOUR later you made the post I referenced #18. Since you said you would be back AFTER class I would assume class was done, so why the heck are you still skimming. So my previous question still stands.

Why would you mention if anyone attacked reck for townpoints? Would you say that is a scumtell? If you think it is a scumtell why wouldn't you look since you just said you were re-reading? So you went back and looked, but you didn't look

Lies, thanks.

Yes, you did.

[Katsuki]

Is this going to be a repeat of Castlevania where you spent pages questioning the validity of my roadtrip?...

I also like how you keep asking me to say that I've done this game. Is iso'ing me that hard? I can see you refuse to iso considering you repeated one of your questions that I already stated that I have answered. Many times at that.

CAPSLAWKALLIANCE = ALIGNMENT CONFIRMED MASONS, NEXT!

So, you are saying you guys did arrange to submit the same colors?

YES, TOTALLY RELATED TO SCUMHUNTING.
Tell me, what does this say about us hmm? And what does it say about me?

[tanstalas]

Is this going to be a repeat of Castlevania where you spent pages questioning the validity of my roadtrip?...

I also like how you keep asking me to say that I've done this game. Is iso'ing me that hard? I can see you refuse to iso considering you repeated one of your questions that I already stated that I have answered. Many times at that.

Ironic that you mention Castlevania considering that was the one game where I was town and you were in fact scum.

You could have mentioned one of the other (what was it 2 or 3) games we were in where we were both town?

CAPSLAWKALLIANCE = ALIGNMENT CONFIRMED MASONS, NEXT!

So, you are saying you guys did arrange to submit the same colors?

YES, TOTALLY RELATED TO SCUMHUNTING.
Tell me, what does this say about us hmm? And what does it say about me?

For this part. I think I will just reference other peoples quotes to answer it:

This also raises another thought in my mind, something that is irrelevant now, bu may be relevant down the road, given the size of the signup thread. I wonder if players PMed each other ahead of time and tried to coordinate putting the same colors in to try and get on the same team.

Toogeloo - While there is an integrity issue here - sort of similar to how people don't like Plum and Pomegranate playing in the same games - proposing that people intentionally chose to team up before the game started pretty much undermines the integrity of the entire site, since we're playing on the honor system.

Although I'm sure some people would do it anyway. <_<

As an aside, and to be fair the following comment should be taken with a grain of salt, but I am starting to ponder the idea that the people in this game that love to be in alliances (capslock or otherwise) get some sort of thrill of being in cahoots with others, so I wouldn't hold it against them to want to be

officially in cahoots with others and therefore select to be scum

. Something to think about.

The only way you could be sure you would be on the same team and speak to one another would be if you were on the same scumteam. Picking a town color and hoping to be masons would be pretty farfetched since we do not even know if there are masons in the game

[xvart]

And pray tell where have I called you scum, xvart? Funny you should think so though.

My apologies if I misread two of your posts, but I assumed that, based on the context of the first post below and my advocacy of the SpyreX wagon, you were saying that I was one of the people that was operating under the guise of looking town by "OMG YOU CLAIMED ORANGE" (SpyreX seemed to be under the same incorrect observation that that was why I was pushing his wagon). Then, and this I can see my error with this post in and of itself only, the second quote below I read it as I was one of the two "beloved scum" since I have been the biggest proponent of SpyreX's wagon (plus the question asking Vi's opinion about me at the end). I guess I should have seen that you also made the statement about the votes piling on when Vi called Reck the SKer since I never said anything about that being part of my justification for voting him. I withdraw the question.

@Vi: By spyspy wagon I meant the one in the early pages where people piled onto him for his choice of orange despite the explanations. It's just so easy imo for scum to go like "OMG YOU CLAIMED ORANGE SCUMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM /VOTE" with the guise of looking town.
Which is also somewhat my reasoning for the reck votes that accumulated shortly after your analysis calling reck SK.

@Vi: Skimming right now, but it was kdub, xvart and tans who jumped on spyspy.
Aka, two of our beloved scum.

What are your thoughts on xvart?

Questions Patiently Awaiting Answers:

1. SpyreX
   - is vote hopping scummy? (423)
   
2. SpyreX
   - is it scummy to speculate on scumteams? (419, 423)
   
3. xRECKONERx
   - explain you conflicting dramonic read: him being unlikely scum (the whole biggggg if comment) versus him being on the scum team you detailed out. (433, 475)

[CupcakePanda]

Once again, another wall of FLUFF from dear tans.

[Katsuki]

Once again, another wall of FLUFF from dear tans.

p.s. Don't you guys just love the above avatar? ^^

[tanstalas]

Once again, another deflection from Katsuki, still no answering my questions.

Going to take a page out of your book now.

@Vi - What are your thoughts on Katsuki?

[Katsuki]

I can't answer something that has nothing to respond to.

Unless you want me to state that for the record, the roadtrip only applied to one game that we've ever played together in aka Castlevania?
The point is that you were arguing timestamps and the fact that I was using roadtrip as an excuse and that I couldn't have possibly only slept for 4hrs etc. instead of scumhunting for pages and pages.

[Toogeloo]

There are a couple people on both leading lynches I don't really care for.


In other news, I've counted thus far at least 4 people who put Orange in one of the two colors based on the way things have been phrased and such. Of those 4, SpyreX is the only one who stated he put it second. Many have not yet commented on their color choice selection in such an obvious way though, so I am betting there were more.


My TOWN safe camp at the moment is currently:
Andrius
xvart


I like these two, and I am getting town vibes from a couple other people, but not willing to put them in my safe camp just yet.

[tanstalas]

I can't answer something that has nothing to respond to.

That's your opinion. What have YOU done this game?

Why would you mention if anyone attacked reck for townpoints? Would you say that is a scumtell? If you think it is a scumtell why wouldn't you look since you just said you were re-reading? So you went back and looked, but you didn't look

At above you said you were in class but as I already pointed out:

You said you were in class in the post BEFORE this one. You said and I quote in your post #17 "Will be back after class, actually learning important stuff nao." then an HOUR later you made the post I referenced #18. Since you said you would be back AFTER class I would assume class was done, so why the heck are you still skimming. So my previous question still stands.

TAKE SOME MORE POSTS OUT OF CONTEXT PLEASE!

Those posts you quoted of mine came before ANY ring discussion took place.

Uhh, No they didn't - IT WAS MENTIONED AS EARLY AS ON THE FIRST PAGE (caps IS fun) check post #19, for comparison your post was #259

As was brought up by others the SK can probably take/steal our rings if we have one. I'd say there is some motivation in taking the SK out.

At above. Wouldn't you agree?

[CupcakePanda]

We have no idea what the SK actually does. Hence why would you SK-hunt instead of scum-hunt?

Re: Classes, you do realize classes last longer than an hour, right?

You keep requoting questions that I have provided answers for, including one that has been quoted for the third time now.
Nice job faking activity.

[Katsuki]

We have no idea what the SK actually does. Hence why would you SK-hunt instead of scum-hunt?

Re: Classes, you do realize classes last longer than an hour, right?

You keep requoting questions that I have provided answers for, including one that has been quoted for the third time now.
Nice job faking activity.

[Toogeloo]

SK is still an anti-town faction. I simply posted my observation, and if I were truly hunting I would have implicated the players who said they placed orange, and mentioned as to who I thought was most likely to be it. But it should also be known that so long as a NOT TOWN player gets lynched, is all that matters.

[Katsuki]

Scumhunting includes the SK.
SK-hunting however is exclusively SK.

[tanstalas]

We have no idea what the SK actually does. Hence why would you SK-hunt instead of scum-hunt?

Re: Classes, you do realize classes last longer than an hour, right?

You said in your ISO-17 that you would be back

AFTER

class, you then posted an hour later... I assumed class was done since well, you said in the post directly before ISO-18 that you would be back

AFTER

You keep requoting questions that I have provided answers for, including one that has been quoted for the third time now.
Nice job faking activity.

Are you referring to:

i like how once vi calls reck sk

everyone starts piling votes onto reck

this is almost a repeat of spyspy wagon early on all this sk voting needs looking at

as the answer to:

Why would you mention if anyone attacked reck for townpoints? Would you say that is a scumtell? If you think it is a scumtell why wouldn't you look since you just said you were re-reading? So you went back and looked, but you didn't look

and then you also said:

Ok so just went back and looked I think

nopoint was the only one who voted reck

after V's SK analysis post. Not sure if anyone attacked reck for townpoints though, did not look.

And you say I am faking activity? lulz

And anyways the main part of that question was basically why would you bring up that you did not know if anyone had attacked Reck for townpoints when you didn't even look? Did you expect us to go look for you?

Also going back to this quote:

personally im of the belief that we shouldnt necessarily be worrying about orange for the time being but thats just me

this

only scum would be sk hunting

which reminds me

tans was doing this too in the beginning when spyspy mentioned picking orange

When I asked you your comment on this you said rings talk wasn't brought up yet, I corrected you, since you obviously have reading comprehension issues, and even directed you to the post where it was mentioned on the first page. I bring this up, because you made a point of saying I was sk hunting where you said just before that only scum would be sk hunting, hence, implying I was scum.

Now, knowing at the point where I was "sk hunting" as you call it that the SK posed a threat to the town would you say that the above was scummy of me to be SK hunting?

And if you call what I was doing up until that point SK-hunting and not scum-hunting I will laugh at you. As at that point I was already way past the SK thing and onto kdub. FTR: and to save you the time to look it up I mentioned the SK thing in my ISO-7 (Sun Jan 02, 2011 9:52 pm) by the time you posted the above I was already 6 posts past that and pushing Kdub. So I must have been scumhunting and not just SK-hunting, wouldn't you agree? So why even try to link the two together if you say scumhunting is pro-town and includes the SK by this next quote?

Scumhunting includes the SK.
SK-hunting however is exclusively SK.

I assume you meant SK

only

hunting is exclusively

scum

?

[The Stove]

Page 21?

Really?

FFFFFFFFfff

brb

[The Stove]

-PZ

(fffff)

[Jack]

Yes. We should put more steam behind the starbuck lynch.

[nopointinactingup]

@Reck: You choose to avoid all concerns and tunnel. That's perfectly scum play in my book because it shows you don't care about reasoning others to go with your read. You just want a target to lash at and "produce content". So answer xvart's repeated question: If I'm scum because dramonic is bussing me and SenFan is linked to dramonic then why are you voting me? The only logic I see in this is that you are scum with SenFan/dramonic and plan to change your mind about them when I flip town.
With that in mind, I believe a SenFan lynch will be most informative. Reck, join me if you dare

Unvote.Vote:SenFan

[Andrius]

OH MY GOD.
KINETIC AND MAFIASSK.
I FINALLY UNDERSTAND THEIR AVATARS.



I was

wondering

what those strange symbols meant... /fail

Posting later. Just wanted to share my

stupidity[/i] enlightenment.

[nopointinactingup]

What do they mean?

[Jack]

@nopoint: something's missing from that post

p-edit: 518

[nopointinactingup]

I have no opinion on starbuck ^^

[Starbuck]

Checking in real quick. First couple days after the holidays are always busy in my office. I was trying to plan a full re-read so that I can contribute more than just the flavor stuff.

Maybe my mafia break was a little too long.

[Jack]

scum list:
starbuck
nopoint
katsuki

icky list:
xreck
spyrex