I never suspected Jedo or Liar's slot. I wouldn't go so far as to call Jedo obv town, but he makes a good choice. Snake's protect dilemma... what are the odds that there are a real doc and a weak doc in any given setup? Is it usually one or the other? (Note; not asking for real doc to step forward in the event there is one). I think it's fairly obvious to say that a weak doc is going to take extreme care to pick their target, and hopefully Snake took his time reading the thread during the time from he replaced through night phase. The problem is he doesn't have enough posts to convincingly prove who he chose.
What we do gain, however is a 50/50 - He either protected (soft)claimed power, or he protected someone obv town. The latter leaves out myself, umbrage, CK and probably Nero. Obviously he didn't protect Jedo. Unfortunately, the pool it leaves is too big to really make a case on, and unfortunately again I can't really make heads or tails of someone who posted so little.
On AV v. Umbrage - I think there's a small chance that this is just town arguing amongst themselves, but AV getting waved at does not confirm his own alignment. However if Wraith
is
town, that is the one-shot he was talking about, and has thrown his suspicion AV's way even (though I don't get the logic in it, unless Wraith's deduction is "well if I thought AV was so town, maybe Snake thought so too"). Umbrage looked pretty bad all day, and had bad interaction with confirmed town. AV has made decent enough points, so it's a good place to start.VOTE: Umbrage
