Bomb Mafia -- Game Over

[StrangerCoug]

Oh and for what it's worth I'm thinking scum team is 3 and we have an SK.

***If there is a vig. Claim so Now.

The hell? Why do you want the vig outed?

No vig would've killed either hoopla nor CES. WIthout damn fucking good reasoning. And I'd want to hear it now. Otherwise there will be no accepted claim later.

So you

REALLY

think the benefits of not only outing the vig but also ostracizing him or her outweigh the drawbacks of painting a nightkill target on him, which might as well be a lynch target if the actual vig claims and doesn't explain Hoopla or Cogito Ergo Sum dying to your liking. I don't believe this one bit.

benmage because he passed it to me, fate because it was my last pass and I will let someone who (theoretically) knows what they're doing decide if I'm going to be bombed or not.

This is weird reasoning. Effectively OMGUSing Benmage and passing the bomb to Fate because you trust him with it? I don't get it.

I'm going to wait for the bomb to go off before taking a stance either way. AntB claimed a confirmable role.

StrangerCoug, Fate, hito

You corrected hitorogoshi to Katsuki, but what about the other two of us?

I read over it and I'm pretty sure that its time based

And, I read over it TOO and there can't be any way you could get that from anything publicly mentioned.

FoS: themanhimself

It's possible for a bomb to go off at night, which points towards him being right. The way the mod answered one of Fate's questions points toward a time-count and not a post-count as well.

UNVOTE: Katsuki, but I'm going to wait for Nobody Special to respond before I put the vote back.

[hitogoroshi]

I don't really think we should be voting at all at the moment. Don't want to risk losing our glorious month-day and letting night killers get another crack at the town.

[themanhimself]

Are you kidding me NS?

I'll set up specific

times

before the game starts which will be explosion

times

. Any player who has a bomb in their possession when the explosion

time

hits will be killed. The

times

will be preset within the context of a game playing until the maximum allotted

time

(it's important to me that the players don't think this is just the Mod influencing the game, I plan to literally draw up all the explosion

times

before the game even begins).

This and the fact that he never says post count

and

the fact that bombs can go off at night pretty definitively rule out post count detonation as a plausible theory.
VOTE: Nobody Special for FoS'ing me and misrepping me over something he clearly didn't read or think through and for trying to lead the town astray with obviously false theories.

[Benmage]

Oh and for what it's worth I'm thinking scum team is 3 and we have an SK.

***If there is a vig. Claim so Now.

The hell? Why do you want the vig outed?

No vig would've killed either hoopla nor CES. WIthout damn fucking good reasoning. And I'd want to hear it now. Otherwise there will be no accepted claim later.

So you

REALLY

think the benefits of not only outing the vig but also ostracizing him or her outweigh the drawbacks of painting a nightkill target on him, which might as well be a lynch target if the actual vig claims and doesn't explain Hoopla or Cogito Ergo Sum dying to your liking.

I don't believe this one bit.

What don't you believe buddy?

[themanhimself]

What don't you believe buddy?

That's some seriously poor phrasing.

[StrangerCoug]

What don't you believe buddy?

I don't believe that now is the time to out the vig. Yes, if either of them were killed by a vig, then the person that did it is an idiot, but do we really want to risk making someone an easy mislynch or nightkill target?

[themanhimself]

NS, what are your top three scumreads?

[Nobody Special]

Pre-Game Status

Role PMs being created, randomized, and assigned.

Role PMs going out. All players must confirm and may ask questions about their role or the game. Players with access to QTs may talk during this period. All players may discuss the game in the thread. The game will begin when I receive at least 12 out of 14 confirmations.

All confirmations are in,

explosion times are set,

and the game will begin.

Okay, I guess we were both wrong. Whatever. Can we move on now.

NS, what are your top three scumreads?

themanhimself, Katsuki, and FATE.

[themanhimself]

Pre-Game Status

Role PMs being created, randomized, and assigned.

Role PMs going out. All players must confirm and may ask questions about their role or the game. Players with access to QTs may talk during this period. All players may discuss the game in the thread. The game will begin when I receive at least 12 out of 14 confirmations.

All confirmations are in,

explosion times are set,

and the game will begin.

Okay, I guess we were both wrong. Whatever. Can we move on now.

By what nonsense logic does that make both of us wrong? I said that and you disagreed, that makes you wrong and me right

[Benmage]

What don't you believe buddy?

I don't believe that now is the time to out the vig. Yes, if either of them were killed by a vig, then the person that did it is an idiot, but do we really want to risk making someone an easy mislynch or nightkill target?

Fair enough. I still disagree. But moreover I don't think it was done by a vig. I was hoping a foolish zealous SK might quick claim.

Regardless I don't think you'll be seeing anyone claiming vig this game.

[StrangerCoug]

OK, the line of thinking makes sense.

VOTE: Nobody Special. How does themanhimself saying that the explosions are time-based get proven wrong by you quoting the mod saying "explosion times are set"?

[themanhimself]

What don't you believe buddy?

I don't believe that now is the time to out the vig. Yes, if either of them were killed by a vig, then the person that did it is an idiot, but do we really want to risk making someone an easy mislynch or nightkill target?

Fair enough. I still disagree. But moreover I don't think it was done by a vig. I was hoping a foolish zealous SK might quick claim.

Regardless I don't think you'll be seeing anyone claiming vig this game.

That actually occurred to me after saying a vig-claim was stupid and I felt like kind of an idiot

[Nobody Special]

OK, the line of thinking makes sense.

VOTE: Nobody Special. How does themanhimself saying that the explosions are time-based get proven wrong by you quoting the mod saying "explosion times are set"?

I only meant that we were both wrong in arguing a moot point. What is this, the Spanish Inquisition?

[Benmage]

What is this, the Spanish Inquisition?

As a matter of fact yeah.....welcome to mafia.

I don't get how you go 7 days without a post...then pop in to say you're here....then are needed to be dragged to give reads or anything of substance.

Where at all does this seem town-like? How do you think a townie should be playing?

I know we're gonna be twiddling around all day for bombs to blow up..but If not I'd be A-O-K with you hanging.

[themanhimself]

Well you weren't expecting it so in that regard it is similar to the Spanish inquisition

[Fate]

awwww why is tmh still alive

[Fate]

Are you kidding me NS?

I'll set up specific

times

before the game starts which will be explosion

times

. Any player who has a bomb in their possession when the explosion

time

hits will be killed. The

times

will be preset within the context of a game playing until the maximum allotted

time

(it's important to me that the players don't think this is just the Mod influencing the game, I plan to literally draw up all the explosion

times

before the game even begins).

This and the fact that he never says post count

and

the fact that bombs can go off at night pretty definitively rule out post count detonation as a plausible theory.
VOTE: Nobody Special for FoS'ing me and misrepping me over something he clearly didn't read or think through and for trying to lead the town astray with obviously false theories.

STRANGERCOUG.

YOURE BETTER THAN THIS. YOU KNOW NOT TO FUCKIN VOTE NS AFTER A SHITPOST LIKE THAT.

O WAIT UR TOWN SC, THAT MEANS YOU ARENT BETTER THAN THIS?
FFFFFFFFF

[hitogoroshi]

YOU KNOW NOT TO FUCKIN VOTE NS AFTER A SHITPOST LIKE THAT.

Afraid I'm not understanding what you're saying here. Explanation for the slow kid?

[Fate]

YOURE NOT SLOW HITO:

READ THIS AGAIN:

This and the fact that he never says post count and the fact that bombs can go off at night pretty definitively rule out post count detonation as a plausible theory.
VOTE: Nobody Special for FoS'ing me and misrepping me over something he clearly didn't read or think through and for trying to lead the town astray with obviously false theories.

TELL ME WHATS WRONG WITH THAT POST OR ALL YOUR BROWNIETOWNIES GO IN THE FUCKINGTRASH

[hitogoroshi]

Oh, no question that's a bad vote from SC. The reasons contradict each other - if he didn't think it through, he's not "trying" to lead the town astray with false theories. It's voting someone for being a scum mastermind when in your previous breath you admitted they're simply being negligent.

But I'm still not understanding "you know not to vote after a shitpost like that." Unless you were saying "You know not to vote townies because they aren't paying attention", I can't figure out an interpretation of that sentence that makes sense.

[themanhimself]

All caps, damn, guess fate must be right

[Fate]

SHUT UP AND DIE

[Fate]

Oh, no question that's a bad vote from SC. The reasons contradict each other - if he didn't think it through, he's not "trying" to lead the town astray with false theories. It's voting someone for being a scum mastermind when in your previous breath you admitted they're simply being negligent.

But I'm still not understanding "you know not to vote after a shitpost like that." Unless you were saying "You know not to vote townies because they aren't paying attention", I can't figure out an interpretation of that sentence that makes sense.

WHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSH

I was saying it as a BAD vote because SC was VOTING

WITH

TMH-scum after TMH made such an AWFUL vote on NS.

AND THAT ID EXPECT SC TO KNOW BETTER THAN THAT

[themanhimself]

Oh, no question that's a bad vote from SC. The reasons contradict each other - if he didn't think it through, he's not "trying" to lead the town astray with false theories.

NS has something he wants the town to believe and he said that that was the only conclusion one could draw from the facts without looking at the facts. Why wouldn't he look at the facts if he was going to propagate this theory? He doesn't care whether or not the facts support it, he has something he wants the town to believe and so he's going to push it regardless of the facts. It's lazy scum. If he was town then he wouldn't have said that only one conclusion could be drawn from a set of facts that he didn't even examine. I'm not saying townies don't get lazy and skim, I'm saying that when they do, they don't start calling people scummy over things they didn't read.

[themanhimself]

Benmage, why aren't you voting NS if you think he's scummy?