Mafia 126 - Lovers Mafia! [Game Over]

[vezokpiraka]

My lover is snake.

Please tell me that GreyICE is not a nakamura gimmick or poggy gimmick. Or even jordman gimmick.

Seriously who the fuck are you GreyIce?

In the mean time let's do some mindless sheeping of Reck.

unvote
vote emptiger

[q21]

Lover Claim: Umbrage

... and on that note.

Oh. My. God. You. SUCK!

Bitchslap Vote implosion

That said, I disagree with my lovers attack on Emptypger and happen to agree that GreyICE's tentative, wishy-washy-ness around the massclaim issue on page one was scummy, therefore.

Vote GreyICE

<--- That one's real.

[q21]

Wait... so vezo is mindlessly sheeping reck who is mindless sheeping espy...

lulz.

[Espeonage]

We really need a votecount. I know we are nowhere near an accidental lynch but I think it would be useful to see how many votes are actually legit.

[Kise]

I'm going to give it another week before putting the nail in the coffin, because I know how you good folks like to talk for as long as you can each phase. I'll wait until you get tiresome, then upgrade my Radio Flyer into a voluptuous wagon that none of you can resist.

[Espeonage]

Town is talking about krap anyway.

Entertain me.

[GreyICE]

GreyIce:
Don't want the other part to be lost. Why do you think that mafia wouldn't pretend to be unaware of the mafia role PM? (or werewolves of the werewolf PM?) You handwaved that away as "because it's stupid". But it seems to me much more likely than mafia wanting to seem very acquainted with that PM.

Because I don't frequently see people do the play where they pretend to be ignorant of the game setup. I especially don't see them doing it the way Reck did - taking, by assumption, something to be true that is not true. The Werewolves/Mafia know there's no night kill, a 4 player hive mind isn't going to miss that one. Reck proceeded under the direct assumption that it didn't exist, with not the least bit of contrivance in his posting to indicate any self-awareness that his assumption was utterly false.

That says town to me.

Now, I think my vote is doing something useless right now. Lemme read what's been posted since last night...

Unvote

Vote: Espeonage

Could you be a

little

more nonconfrontational and skim the thread a

bit

harder? You've got a list of posts contributing nothing but creating a "solid" history of "helpful" posting... yeah, this would be the top scumread so far.

[Espeonage]

This is probably one of maybe two or three games where I actually havn't skimmed.

[vezokpiraka]

@Espy: GreyICE is scum. He is just trying to make a case on someone who knows is easy to be lynched. He didn't read any posts in this thread but he is accusing you of that. Hypocritical scum.

[Mariyta]

Heh it seems like we can just no-lynch into eternity if we're feeling indecisive with a deadline looming. What's to prevent that?

Does anyone think Umbrage is already chainsawing for GreyIce during RVS?
Emp's case on GreyIce is weak, sure, but getoutofRVSreasoning is always stretchy.
Then again maybe Thingy (Emplover) referring to both scumteams as "wolves" is a slip and he's forgotten there are different types than his own?

Well, that would certainly benefit scum, now wouldn't it? I like my vote. The point about Thingy is interesting, though. I'll have to take a look at it.

Well, it appears as though my lover is MIA. Story of my life. Oh well. Anyone want a threesome? I'm very open-minded.

Lover: Tragedy

Since she's failed to appear at this point, I'll take matters into my own hands.

[Umbrage]

I confirm q21 as my lover.

Here's an idea: would it be possible to put your lover's name in your signature? Or would it violate site rules?

[SensFan]

In class, so votecount will come in a couple hours. Do not make any direct reference to this game anywhere but in the channels specifically provided for this game. Thanks.

[Kcdaspot]

Confirmed with partner.

Lover: Baby Spice

u jelly?

[Espeonage]

Lucky Bastard

[GreyICE]

IIoA:

EmpTyger - Thingyman
GreyICE - Antihero
Llamarble - DarlaBlueEyes
Implosion - Kise
xRECKONERx - Nero Cain
VezokPiraka - SnakePlissken
q21 - Umbrage
Maryita - Tragedy
Kcdaspot - Baby Spice

[Purple Orange]

Lucky Bastard

I'm crushed.

ConfirmLover: Espy

[q21]

@Espy: GreyICE is scum. He is just trying to make a case on someone who knows is easy to be lynched. He didn't read any posts in this thread but he is accusing you of that. Hypocritical scum.

So you think GreyICE is scum... but you're blindly sheeping reck to vote emp who is attacking GreyIce...

Right, you're scum too.

[GreyICE]

It's been a while since I dipped my toes in the water of MTGS, but if I remember VezokPiraka, that's fairly standard levels of analysis from him. I'm glad we have his partner Snake, we can hopefully get something from him since he posted on...

IIoA:
EmpTyger - Thingyman
GreyICE - Antihero
Llamarble - DarlaBlueEyes
Implosion - Kise
xRECKONERx - Nero Cain
VezokPiraka - SnakePlissken
q21 - Umbrage
Maryita - Tragedy
Kcdaspot - Baby Spice
PurpleOrange - Espeonage

[q21]

Why the jump to his defense, Grey?

[vezokpiraka]

Blindly sheeping Reck was RVS.


And I still like it. Maybe when my lover says something I will vote GreyICE.

[EmpTyger]

Kise:
How do you know that Reckoner read the role in signups? Because if so, that merits a lot more than FoSs, and a lot sooner than in-a-week.


Espeonage:
Player A: We should not do [thing that helps town]
Player B: No, we should do [thing that helps town]
Player C: I'm not going to do [thing that helps town]
You: Obviously we should do [thing that helps town]. vote B for discussing an irrelevant issue.

I mean, I realize I have at least 2 biases here, but your rationale for going after Thingy doesn't match what actually has happened.


GreyIce:

Because I don't frequently see people do the play where they pretend to be ignorant of the game setup. I especially don't see them doing it the way Reck did - taking, by assumption, something to be true that is not true. The Werewolves/Mafia know there's no night kill, a 4 player hive mind isn't going to miss that one. Reck proceeded under the direct assumption that it didn't exist, with not the least bit of contrivance in his posting to indicate any self-awareness that his assumption was utterly false.
That says town to me.

You're saying that mafia/werewolf couldn't possibly do something which simultaneously leads the town in the wrong direction *and* makes it look like they're unfamiliar with the mafia/werewolf role PM?
Because the antitown's number one priority of the mafia/werewolf is tricking the town into thinking they have received a protown role PM. That's not a contrivance, it's what they're already trying to do.
Morevoer, you seem remarkably unconcerned that Kise seems to have direct evidence against your little theory.


vezok:
Is it because you think I'm guilty or because you think Reckoner is town? (or both?)

[GreyICE]

Why the jump to his defense, Grey?

Because i've seen a speed lynch of vezok before, it doesn't necessarily end in a scum flip. I'd rather get some more reads and lynch scum.

[GreyICE]

EMP: stop confusing "impossible" and "unlikely" right the hell now. It seems like you don't want anyone to have a town read on anyone.

[EmpTyger]

GreyIce:
I think it's neither "unlikely" nor "impossible". Especially after what Kise just said. Which is why I wonder why you keep insisting that it is.
(And way to hyperbolicly go from "Reckoner" -> "everyone")

[GreyICE]

GreyIce:
I think it's neither "unlikely" nor "impossible". Especially after what Kise just said. Which is why I wonder why you keep insisting that it is.
(And way to hyperbolicly go from "Reckoner" -> "everyone")

And purple orange. but yes, I think you're trying to make everyone as suspect as possible. You had one town read, on a minor null, and it was based on your awful reading comprehension.