ATHF Mafia OVER(roles and whatnot revealed)

[implosion]

Same, I have no fucking idea what's happening, this just needs to end. May as well hammer now since I have internet for the next 30 minutes.

VOTE: VasudeVa

[Untrod Tripod]

SHAKE. BAM! HAMMAH!
BOXXY BROWN. Why you gotta do me like that?
SHAKE. It's nothing personal, Boxxy, I just think you killed Meatwad
BOXXY BROWN. I just a box. I can't move.
SHAKE. Lies and trickery! You will die now!
BOXXY BROWN. Ohhh, high and mighty honkey slave driver. White as the-
GOD. Shut up.

BOXXY BROWN is hit by lightning

SHAKE. BOOM! HAHA!

tl;dr VasudeVa, Boxxy Brown was lynched.

[Untrod Tripod]

GOD. This ends today. Someone make this be done.
SHAKE. I'm too busy masturbating.
GOD. DO THINGS.

Blah blah. With 3 alive it's 2 to lynch.

[Seacore]

Sigh, this game is stupid.

I will be voting for implosion by the end of this post. But first I'll state me reasons.

1) No voting is apparently not an option, that will just extend this game out and I just don't want that. If one of us was scum with the ability to kill, the game would have ended last night. So there's some kind of reason to keep the game running, maybe there's a kill-less scum around.

2) Voting myself is not an option. I know I'm town.

3) Voting podium is not an option. It's "almost" an option, but I'm not going to do it. He was killed by the 'scum kill' flavour text. So he didn't start as that scum team. My Role PM specifically says that he stays the same alignment, and while i"m willing to believe my role PM is lying to me, I'm not going to act on that, because then I'd have to consider voting for myself too.

4) Therefore voting implosion is the only remaining option. It's possible that frylock had the kill power and implosion had other powers and they were the scum team. Although a kill happened after frylock died so I don't know.

Basically I just want this game to be over.

vote implosion

I understand that implosion won't vote for himself so that leaves podium. Podium doubts me, and has since Day 1.
Implosion, I will not be changing my vote to podium for any reason whatsoever, which leaves me as your only option to complete a lynch.
Therefore, podium, the final lynch is in your hands, vote me or implosion. I doubt I'll be making another post this game.

[podium123456]

VOTE: implosion

[Seacore]

Just to save UT the time, I"m not scum. Are you?

[Untrod Tripod]

GOD. Shake...it's time
SHAKE. Noooooooooooooooooooooo!
GOD. You had a pretty good run though, didn't you?
SHAKE. I suppose I did.
GOD. Well then it is time to kill you.
SHAKE. So let's do this.

silence

SHAKE. Where's the lightning.
GOD. I'm going to microwave you.
SHAKE. What?!
GOD. You know you had this coming.
SHAKE. Fair enough.

GOD stuffs SHAKE into a microwave. Shake explodes

GOD. Good. That's over now.

Upon surveying the scene, you all find a picture on the refridgerator

Oh. I guess Shake was the culprit all along.

TOWN WINS!

I'll post role pm's and night actions in a bit.

[Fate]

yaay....

So the masons were scum.


W/e

[Seacore]

So scum either lost their night kill at some point, or implosion just decided to stop using it?

I await the role pms and night actions, but thank god this game is over.

If I recorded wins and loses, I wouldn't record this as a win.

[Fate]

I've added the antithesis to this game to my list make sure it doesn't even exist in my memories.

Last post.

[podium123456]

you shant find this game in my w/l list.

[RedCoyote]

Oh, so RC was right all along!

No, but that doesn't really matter because I handled my claim horribly. I'm glad you guys won in spite of that.

Although I'm not going to defend the idea of no reveal in this setup (although, I understand why you did it, I think, Mod), I liked the flavor a lot. The Mod has a real knack for writing in the same style as ATHF.

gg everybody.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Thank god the insanity is finished.

Untrod you did a great job of mimicing the flavor of the show. Great job there.

Everything else ... not so much. The fact that my invisible votes only showed up in actual vote counts on one or two days was sad. And the elongated and erratic Night schedule killed any interest anyone had in the game, IMO.

For future reference - if you have a game with consistent lack of alignment flips or even delayed flips you SHOULD advertise it specifically.

I'd say good job Town except I really only know for certain that Seacore, Podium and myself were Town.

[implosion]

JUST SO YOU ALL KNOW I DID NOT KNOW I WAS SCUM UNTIL DAY SIX, THIS WAS THE MOST IRRITATING THING I'VE EVER DONE IN MY LIFE.

[implosion]

So lets see in retrospect. In retrospect, I was scum (with ghostwriter? i'm not sure) who had no nightkill, had an ability that revealed info that would be claimed in-thread anyway, did not know my own alignment, and literally could not tell anything that was going on.

Lack of alignment flips is honestly much less of a concern than lack of KNOWING MY DAMN ALIGNMENT.

[implosion]

you shant find this game in my w/l list.

[VasudeVa]

This game was improperly labeled 'slightly bastardous'. >.>

[Seacore]

The scum didn't know they were scum? This just keeps getting worse!

How were the night kills determined? Why did they cease in the last few days, effectively removing implosion's chance to win at all?

If scum didn't know they were scum, this wasn't even a game of mafia. Mafia, by definition, is about an

informed

minority.

Was this game reviewed in any way?

Also, I'm going to disagree with the praise about the flavour text. Maybe I view ATHF different due to the fact I'm Australian, or pretentious or some other factor, but I find ATHF far more subtle and clever, where this was just crude for the sake of being crude. There are suggestions that shake masturbates, for example, not scenes dedicated to it. But I care far less about the flavour then about the mechanics.

I will also echo MoI, the terrible mechanics and the poor flavour text could have been stomached a little better if the game was run consistently.

There were long periods of the game not running, that's unacceptable, that's why you should have a back up mod. Also, MoI suggests that his invisible vote was not applied consistently. That's also unacceptable.

I'm not saying this to be mean, I'm suggesting that there are many lessons in this game about how to properly prepare and mod a game.

[implosion]

So scum either lost their night kill at some point, or implosion just decided to stop using it?

I await the role pms and night actions, but thank god this game is over.

If I recorded wins and loses, I wouldn't record this as a win.

What night kill?

[Untrod Tripod]

I really want to apologize for how this game turned out and I'm really embarrassed about how I handled some of the issues that arose from my, ahem, idiotic setup ideas.

I'd rather be done with it than post everything. If you guys want to discuss it with me, PM me. There are more wrinkles than I posted in the thread, and honestly I made some really bad choices about how to keep the game going when some things went wrong.

As it stands, I would really prefer to just lock the thread and be done with all of this.

I really appreciate all of you sticking with the game when it all went to hell. You guys are great people for continuing to play instead of abandoning it/replacing out. I understand if you guys avoid any future games of mine.

[Kcdaspot]

Did you unlock this?

Untrod You tried your best and I don't blame you much, but some things could have been avoided.

I wouldn't mind playing in a future game of yours but you gotta be on top of things.

[RedCoyote]

Since this is unlocked again, I just wanted to say I think y'all are being a little bit harsh on him. I mean, I understand your frustration at feeling a little underwhelmed at the lack of role reveal and the long periods between day and night, but you have to at least hand it to our Mod for finishing the game out and admitting he did a few things wrong. Additionally, I'm glad he resisted the temptation to just try and "fix" the game mid-game, which can often times make the situation worse.

[GhostWriter]

Not gonna lie, I figured that Shake had killed Meatwad. Then when there was a Boxy Brown claim, I figured he and a hidden Meatwad had faked Meatwad's death and were the mafia. Never really figured I was mafia. My moveset didn't really make it make sense. Shake, however, could get away with it, since his one power seemed mainly to be a way to hinder me if he died.

Could we maybe get all the details of the game? I'm interested to see what the ideal mechanic that you were going for was.

[Nachomamma8]

I WAS A DOCTOR

[Untrod Tripod]

I'm making a few big explanatory posts right now, I'll put the role PMs in one of them.