Mini 1112 - Mundania (Game Over)

[Surprise_Carcinogen]

I stand by DP as next lynch, but I'm down for a massclaim as well.

[DemonHybrid]

Sordros is dead =|

herpderp.

Hell, I'll go next, as long as Parama is last, like he said. I'm a Vanilla Townie.

Carcinogen?

[Surprise_Carcinogen]

Vanilla town as well. Bill?

[Bill McQuill]

Vanilla. Take it away, Parama.

Sordros is dead =|

And replaced...

[DemonHybrid]

So, this would mean that Parama is Mason with Reck.

For the record, I think David is a mess right now and wouldn't mind his lynch. Instant cases, asking dead people to claim and slight AtE; I don't think he's sincere in the slightest. But I want a general consensus first and any objections if there are any.

[Parama]

Hmm. I'd vote rightaway but I'm going out for a bit and want to be able to monitor the thread.
Also, I'm not mason .-. But I don't think I'll claim yet.

[Bill McQuill]

...whoa.

Yeah I'm more and more fine with a David lynch. But in the meantime, who the hell would lie about being a mason this late in the game. What is going on? And why did Reck claim miller, come to think of it?

Time to do some re-reading.

[Bill McQuill]

But I don't think I'll claim yet.

Also I think you missed the memo on proposing a massclaim.

[Parama]

I proposed the massclaim for a reason, and was going to claim only under circumstances in which we'd get confirmed scum out of it. Deal with it, it's pro-town for me to not claim yet.

[Bill McQuill]

Deal with it,

Grow up.

it's pro-town for me to not claim yet.

I guess we'll see.

[Parama]

Deal with it,

Grow up.

I appear to be a lot more mature than you, judging from your play this game, so...

[Surprise_Carcinogen]

I'm kind of wary of Parama not claiming, but I can think of a few senarios where his claim could be detrimental to town.

For now, I'm down for DP or Bill. DP for aformentioned reasons, with Bill creeping up due to his recent tendency to attack a person, rather then a play.

[DavidParker]

I don't mind Parama not claiming. We can judge his claim if and when he claims. If he doesn't think it helps that's fine. He's not going to be the lynch for today anyways, so he can use his information how he wants. I'm doing a reread, but my top two picks are carcinogen and Bill at this point.

[Surprise_Carcinogen]

I'm mildly curious as to why you've got me pegged, but I'll be very interested to see any case that ISN'T just OMGUS

[Parama]

got me pegged

...
interesting word choice, I must say.

Everyone should list their top two suspicions IMO. I'm going last again~

[Surprise_Carcinogen]

Not sure what makes it an interesting choice of words either, but whatev. Bill and DP are top choices. Everybody else seems pretty well town to me.

[Parama]

"got me pegged" implies someone who's scum and knows they're scum being called scum by someone they know is town. Townies don't say "you pegged me as scum" often, do they?

[Parama]

Hell. I'd even go so far as to call that a potential scumslip.

[Surprise_Carcinogen]

I find it suspect that you're willing to discard what amounts to a near mountain of evidence against two other people in favor of someone who speaks a bit oddly. Between that and you playing leader to the town, and constantly insisting to go last when you do it makes me add you as a third place on my list.

[Parama]

vote: Surprise_Carcinogen

Wow. I want to see you flailing.

[Surprise_Carcinogen]

There's no flailing to be done. There's literally NO case against me except for a single word you decided you didn't like. I can't exactly defend myself against NOTHING, can I?

[Parama]

SC: Bill + DP
DP: Bill + SC
DH: DP + ???
Bill: DP + ???
Me: DP + Bill

Hmm.

[Parama]

Not sure what makes it an interesting choice of words either, but whatev. Bill and DP are top choices.

Everybody else seems pretty well town to me.

I find it suspect that you're willing to discard what amounts to a near mountain of evidence against two other people in favor of someone who speaks a bit oddly.

Between that and you playing leader to the town, and constantly insisting to go last when you do it

makes me

add you as a third place on my list.

Did my FoS make you change you reads that much?
The second bold happened before the post where you called me "pretty well town" and now you're trying to use it as evidence against me. Hypocrite much?

[DavidParker]

Oh, don't get me wrong I find carcinogen's slot quite off and scummy, and a quick reread just reminded me of why, but I don't think his choice of wording is as big a scum slip as you are laying it out to be. I do find it scummy that carcinogen has done a huge backflip from his "everyone seems town except bill and dp" to now putting parama up there as well.

[Surprise_Carcinogen]

I stand by my statements. You seem pretty well town. But you seem significantly less town then DH does, and since there's only five of us, and I can't exactly pick myself, third and fourth place don't mean much. I stand by the part of my second statement that you DIDN'T bold. You're making a case based on such thin, tenuous evidence as a word you didn't like. "Town don't usually use a word like that" isn't exactly good evidence, and it's not good logic.

preview edit: I'm rethinking this all now, and I realize that if you were in fact scum, you wouldn't be trying to move us away from DP and Bill, since one mis-lynch and we're toast. If you were scum, you'd be trying to pull us towards one of those easy mislynches. I'm still inclined to call you town.

Also, you misused hypocrite, but that's beside the point.

2nd preview edit: DP, you are easily my top choice for doing exactly what you're doing now. Instead of ever having really defended yourself, you either make things a personal attack, or jump on any emergent case. By all means, chase scum, but don't use it as a veil to avoid scrutiny to yourself.