Execution Mafia GAMEOVER!

[Haschel Cedricson]

3. COOLDOG (specifically mentioning the "odd mechanic" of the game. Dude, you knew that when you signed up. Stop being so obvscum.)

That's not a good reason. I had no idea what the mechanic was when I signed up, because I couldn't find mallowgeno's post in the Queue thread. I'm basically here because the other theme game in sign-ups had some anime theme.

[Shattered Viewpoint]

My list like Exe's.

Baaaaa.

[Shattered Viewpoint]

3. COOLDOG (specifically mentioning the "odd mechanic" of the game. Dude, you knew that when you signed up. Stop being so obvscum.)

That's not a good reason. I had no idea what the mechanic was when I signed up, because I couldn't find mallowgeno's post in the Queue thread. I'm basically here because the other theme game in sign-ups had some anime theme.

Well then, you obviously suck as a player.

[StrungOver]

I still think not exicuting anyone today would be better... also is a mass claim a bad idea here? It helps tell us who not to kill. I know it's not an open set up so... idk.

[Twistedspoon]

My kill list:

1. Twistedsppon (sheeping by any other name...)
2. vezok (more sheeping. SRSLY just STOP)
3. COOLDOG (specifically mentioning the "odd mechanic" of the game. Dude, you knew that when you signed up. Stop being so obvscum.)

Vote: Exe

Exe = Smart.

Second, I like Exe.

this is not sheeping and I am? seriously. I just said that my ideas were similar to Exe's. It's useful to know the thoughts and ideas of the other players otherwise they might as well not be players.

Third, I'm pretty sure Axe is scum.

Care to say why? or is this baseless conjecture which you're trying to distill into our minds through a kind of reverse freudian slip?
Seriously, you might want to give reasons here if you want to help us execute a witch

anyways, I'd like to see more Umbrage, Amrun and Strungover posting before I make my witch shortlist; it's ridiculous to assume you can make a comprehensive one when we have 0-2 posts from these players

For now I'll

vote:Final Fires

since he seems the most organised of the players here

@StrungOver: not sure a mass claim would be too good mate. The witches could claim any half-baked role and we wouldn't know any better :/
That's just my thought though :s

[Twistedspoon]

EBWOP: In my above post I asked strungover to post more; this was before his above post, so ignore that.

It's just umbrage and Amrun who've had 0-1 posts and we need more of a read on

[Exe]

Trying to get players to follow your ideas or else be put on your hit list is a mafia ruse.

Hardcore misrepresentation.

I am saying that should be able to have scum reads. That's not anti-town.

TS, you are pretty eager to point a finger at whoever you can find, aren't you? Yeah, my list is solid.

Also, regardless of how many situations are available to us, YOU POINTED OUT THREE. You emphasized a bad strategy. It's a subtle tactic.


@Strungover: Erm, no. Definitely not massclaim. And we are not going to no-lynch. That's as retarded as suggesting to no-lynch in a normal game. FFS WHAT IS THIS SHIT.

this is not sheeping and I am? seriously. I just said that my ideas were similar to Exe's. It's useful to know the thoughts and ideas of the other players otherwise they might as well not be players.

Regardless of what is and isn't sheeping, this IS mudslinging.

Ladies n Gents, vote Exe for office and I'll give you a TS on a plate. Kthxbye.

[Tragedy]

Yes, it's League Of Legends.

Also, Ant has a reasonable reason of 'phishing roles' question.

Meanwhile, there's only WITCHES, as some would obviously read and notice from their Role PM as well, amIRight?

[Ant_to_the_max]

@Ant: Why did you feel the need to repeat what I said?
Actually not repeat but add something false. Feels like bussing or distancing to me.

IGMEOY.

Sorry I didn't clarify better. My post was aimed at you. I'll post my points on people when I get home.

[Twistedspoon]

TS, you are pretty eager to point a finger at whoever you can find, aren't you?

Not at all really; quite the opposite.

Seriously quite the opposite

As opposite as you can get

Have i not just been arguing the whole time that it's too early to be pointing fingers?

Sure, questions can lead to fingers but only if you're hiding something, which is why that's my preferred choice of ammo.
Quite the converse to the tactic of 'Post your scumlists now before we have even had all of the players post or die' that you have chosen to adopt.

seriously, i think we can at least wait for us all to post before we make scumlists, that's all I'm arguing.
We have 3.5 weeks, no? stalling might give the mafia advantage in some situations, but making rushed decisions from little conclusive evidence is far worse, isn't it?

So we must agree to disagree here.

as for your mudslinging conjecture; I was merely questioning the player's definition of sheeping; I felt wrongly accused of it, so it's only fair to defend myself isn't it?

[Exe]

@Tragedy: We should play together. I <3 LoL.

@TS: You're trying way too hard to be nonconfrontational. I don't like it.

[Umbrage]

My kill list:

1) Ant (already said why)
2) SV (I get scum vibes for some reason)

Tragedy needs to make more content. My read on TS is confused town. I don't see anything scummy there.

[Tragedy]

I don't like agreeing to no-lynch. We're just guessing as to the number of scum. If it turns out there are five, we just wasted a lynch. It's a gamble, and I don't like it upon first impression. Also, FF's certainty as to the number of scum troubles me.

Maybe it is the best plan, maybe I'm just tired right now, but this is likely the very first thing the mod or whoever thought of when designing the setup. I doubt it'll work.

I agree with having a different executioner for day and night. Otherwise we're putting all our eggs in one basket.

I don't want to bank on any investigative roles. Great if we have them, but don't count on it.

FF strikes me as town. Exe is probably town. Ant could go either way.

You mentioned about 5 scums and wasting a lynch. I'd gamble, but you're such a parter pooper.
The best plan? What do you have on your mind?
Obviously, anyone wants a different executioner for day/night. What if we ended up voting for a

Witch

during the next few pre-execution debates? As some other person mentioned, choose the most trustful Townsperson as the Executioner.
Meep Meep.

@Exe: I lost interesting playing LoL on my first try.

[Shattered Viewpoint]

My kill list:

1) Ant (already said why)
2) SV (I get scum vibes for some reason)

Tragedy needs to make more content. My read on TS is confused town.

I don't see anything scummy there.

Then, my dear Umbrage, YOU ARE BLIND.

My new list:

1) UMBRAGE
2) COOLDOG
3) TRAINSPOTTINGSPOON
4) vezok

[Final Fires]

Also my question wasn't designed for rolefishing. It was designed for something else but whatever. If I am going to have to fight with you over one question I prefer it to end now.

Then what was it designed for? No matter what answer you got, you would've gotten a clue on whether twisted was a PR or not. I'm sorry but I can't just end it now, considering that so far that's the most scummy thing that has happened on this thread.

I still think not exicuting anyone today would be better... also is a mass claim a bad idea here? It helps tell us who not to kill. I know it's not an open set up so... idk.

I think a mass claim would be a huge mistake. And we'll give people an opportunity to claim before they get killed, so if they do have a powerful role we can adjust who we kill.

Can anyone explain to me exactly what the case is against Twisted?

Exe, please respond to questions on post 45.

[Shattered Viewpoint]

The case on twistedspork is: sheeping, rolefishing, and blatant buddying.

[Twistedspoon]

@TS: You're trying way too hard to be nonconfrontational. I don't like it.

I'm sorry you don't like it, but that's the way I choose to play until i feel that I can make a reliable conclusion.
Hopefully we can look beyond our different methods of scum hunting and work towards the interests of the town

But don't worry, I'll be confrontational when the time comes

The case on twistedspork is: sheeping, rolefishing, and blatant buddying.

I have already said what I have to say to your sheeping claims, and tbh there is little difference between sheeping and buddying, unless you've found a post somewhere where I say that I'll stick by another player till death do us part :/
I haven't buddied/sheeped anyone. My vote was entirely independent, and that's what counts. I have merely stated my opinions and how they are in some ways similar to that of other players. I have also made it clear where they contrast too. In the interests of the town I have requested that the players who have yet to post do so, so that we can get a read on them.

Rolefishing? really? I don't recall saying 'so who's the doc here then?' or anything along those lines, not like it would be of any help to us if they were confused enough to reveal their role so early. :/

anyways, that's it for me today
~Twistedspoon

[Final Fires]

The case on twistedspork is: sheeping, rolefishing, and blatant buddying.

For what it's worth, vezok has done all three of those too; except to a much higher degree. He rolefished for the doctor/cop role. He has been hardcore buddying with exe. As you pointed out in post 51, he's also sheeping exe. At this point, I think he's scummier than Twisted.

Also, where did twisted rolefish? As of now I still have a town read on twisted, but if you could point that out it might change.

[Shattered Viewpoint]

Twisted went rolefshing in his VERY FIRST POST. All that setup speculation, tossing out the possibility of "investigative roles" and "protective roles" -- why not just ask the cop and the doc to raise their hands?

[Umbrage]

LOL at SV's OMGUS.

I'm getting more certain of SV being scum. He's pushing the TS wagon too hard. I still read TS as newbie confused town, I see no rolefishing going on, and I think SV is really reaching.

[Haschel Cedricson]

Revelation.

/Unvote; Vote: Exe

Everybody else should do the same preferably in their very next post.

[charter]

Third, I'm pretty sure Axe is scum.

Could you explain this?

His frequent posting, but saying nothing, especially post 14.

Twisted is also scummy. I wouldn't mind him getting killed, either. After Shattered mentions his name and sheeping, he immediately accuses other players of sheeping. Pretty poor defense.

With Umbrage thinking TS is town (no idea how anyone can think that) and having Ant on the top of his list, I'm gonna change mine to TS then Umbrage then Ant.

The case on twistedspork is: sheeping, rolefishing, and blatant buddying.

Don't forget failure to be town.

I think we should elect Exe, kill TS, and then at night elect whoever is willing to kill Umbrage after TS flips scum.

Haschel and SV also look mighty town.

[Exe]

Charter is a decent 2nd choice if people don't vote for me. I am personally a fan of me being the executioner however. I mean, my name is even in the word

SV seems pretty pro-town as well.

TS still reads scum.

@FF: Answer to your question? Answer is no, I can't really elaborate on Ant-scum much. It's mostly gut, but I just don't sense enough town motivation.

[CooLDoG]

look I just made a statement of fact, come on guys.

[Ant_to_the_max]

twistedspoon strikes me as someone who knows too much. Why would there be an investigative role or some type of doctor? How are you so certain of that?

I see no pro-town reason why anyone would say this. How were you hoping twisted would answer you? "I know because I am a cop/doc?" This question just seemed like it was designed to out a PR. Plus by saying this you're suggesting that you're not an investigate role or some type of doctor - why would you be softclaiming so early?

The fact that he's already rolefishing (especially for a doctor/cop) and suggested that he's not a doctor or cop is a huge red flag for me.

That is what I tried to say in my post towards vezokpiraka.

anyways, reading the posts Exe seems to have everything under control; his ideas make the most sense

Your blatant sheeping has been noted for later examination.

A lot of other people could also be called out for sheeping like this too...why just pick on him?

The case on twistedspork is: sheeping, rolefishing, and blatant buddying.

Sheeping like other people have, more speculation that rolefishing (which others have already done here, but not him), and buddying like others have done.

TS, you are pretty eager to point a finger at whoever you can find, aren't you?

this is not sheeping and I am? seriously. I just said that my ideas were similar to Exe's. It's useful to know the thoughts and ideas of the other players otherwise they might as well not be players.

Regardless of what is and isn't sheeping, this IS mudslinging.

But he wasn't pointing a finger. He was pointing out the fact that he was being singled out for something other people have done too in this game. How is that mudslinging?

LOL at SV's OMGUS.

I'm getting more certain of SV being scum. He's pushing the TS wagon too hard. I still read TS as newbie confused town, I see no rolefishing going on, and I think SV is really reaching.

Not only is Shattered Viewpoint pushing it hard, but Exe as well. Wait....add charter to that list as well.

Third, I'm pretty sure Axe is scum.

Could you explain this?

His frequent posting, but saying nothing, especially post 14.

Wait wait wait...have you been talking about me? O.o

Twisted is also scummy. I wouldn't mind him getting killed, either. After Shattered mentions his name and sheeping, he immediately accuses other players of sheeping. Pretty poor defense.

Seriously...wtf is wrong with people here.

I think we should elect Exe, kill TS, and then at night elect whoever is willing to kill Umbrage after TS flips scum.

Haschel and SV also look mighty town.

And what happens if he flips town?

Revelation.

/Unvote; Vote: Exe

Everybody else should do the same preferably in their very next post.

OMG LOOK!!!!!!
Do you guys want to accuse him of sheeping too?

Hey, so what is going to happen to Amrun? Will he be prodded or replaced?

People I am willing to kill:

charter - very poor bandwagoning attack on twistedspoon
StrungOver - Post 1: Not understanding how this game works. Post 2: Still not understanding how the game works. Post 3: Asks for a mass claim.
vezokpiraka - sheeping (lololololol), role phishing

As for my vote, I am not going to give it to Exe here. I am not feeling this wagon on twistedspoon at all.