Mafia 124 - Dilemma Mafia (Day 6)

[DavidParker]

VOTE FATE

[Fate]

Its a shame that you are town Yosarian, that makes you a rusted old sack of a player who's reads are terrible and who's imagination is lackluster and who thinks that I would actually "fake an innocent" on Marble as scum.

[Fate]

Oh see look, now you gave David an excuse not to produce content, what the hell Yosarian?

Mason recruiter.

'nuff said.

[DavidParker]

WAIT SO YOS IS TOWN FATE?????????? WAT IS GOING ON HERE?

[Fate]

Yeah he's probably just terribad town, which meas his wagonw will be delicious to look at later.

Anway lets get on with voting Darla.

I SEE U2 JAHUNDOZ

[Fate]

*taps foot*

[Yosarian2]

...

...

Something seriously weird is going on here.

Llama, I'm going to need to hear a conformation on Fate's claim from you before I say anything else.

[Jahudo]

I was just grabbing some popcorn, this new drama had potential. But I can settle for a Darla lynch.

[DavidParker]

THIS WAS KEEPING ME UP AS WELL. DISAPPOINTED NOW. AND ONLY 3 HOURS OF SLEEP TO BE HAD. VERY DISAPPOINTED.

[Fishythefish]

1. Tries to undermine Llama because the latter writes in capitals. Painting your opponent as desperate scum is always easier than actually analysing their play.
2. Calls Llama's case on BB weak because it's built on the contradictions of Llama changing on DBE, and of disliking both DBE and BB. This is incredibly weak. First, he makes no attempt to address Llama's (entirely believable) claim that his reads changed while he was catching up. Second, Llama's contradiction, or lack of it, is totally irrelevant to his case on BB. It's totally valid to call both DBE and BB scummy, and be more certain about either than the other. Thirdly, BB simply doesn't bother to defend the actual points! Trying to discredit the attacker instead of defending yourself is a scummy way to go about things.

Both of those points are incredibly weak, and fairly obviously so. Llama's insistence on doing MASSIVE ALL CAPS ANGRY OMGUS RESPONSES to people attacking him was actually scummy; it was a sign that he was desperate scum, and a pretty clear appeal to emotion.

Firstly, it's kind of odd to quote the first two points of a three point lynch. At this stage, Llama had written a few sentences in CAPS. I think that anger is a terrible scumtell; it's only a sign that's he's desperate scum if you're scraping around for signs that Llama is scum. The second point you don't actually say anything about. It's 100% valid. BB's criticisms of Llama's case here are terrible.

I'm not talking about the MW vote. I'm talking about how he's consistently used his vote as a tool to attack people just because he doesn't like that they've been attacking him. He's gone through and systematically attacked everyone voting for him, just like you've gone through and systematically attacked everyone voting for him. The only person who wanted to lynch Llama that the two of you guys realized you couldn't attack yesterday was Fires (after a quick, aborted effort by Llama when he realized it wouldn't work) , but he conveniently turned up dead instead.

Llama has seriously gone after exactly two people; I have gone after three. You just haven't shown that Llama's play was designed to stop his lynch.

If you're attacking me just because you think I'm wrong, then when we lynch Llama and he flips scum, proving that I was right all along, how are you going to respond?

If we lynch Llama and he flips scum, my perspective on this game is 100% wrong. I will need to rethink everything. I don't think that's going to happen.

Massive preview edit: oooooooh! That's exciting.

UNVOTE:

[DavidParker]

UNVOTE

[werewolf555]

It seems like david parker is trying too hard to be town and be "reckless"
Not at all like this game where he was town
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 11&t=15559

[DavidParker]

LOL.

I was about to go to sleep having unvoted one of my town reads and leave it there but that is too funny.

mega vote: werewolf

Are you serious?!?!? LIKE SERIOUS???!??!

[Fate]

I hate you werewolf, all this and thats all you have to fuckin say.

You useless fucking slot.

[DavidParker]

Lack-of-sleep-delirium aside... My recent posts have been rather sarcastic. I was awaiting for the Yos/Fate drama to come to some kind of conclusion, and just posting random interjections in between. My vote wasn't serious either. (THIS ONE IS). Oh right, but using all CAPS = Reckless. Of course! (not).

And you find a single game of me being town where I'm cautious and what??? Have you looked at my games?? Really??? REALLLLY?

[Jahudo]

unvote;
Vote: Darla

David, have you gotten to the part where Darla votes bobsnox? Look at that, then ISO her behavior at the end of the day, which to me look faked.

* I find it suspicious that her bobs case (which is alot more confident than her normal play) disappeared there.
* Especially when she also calls llamarable an appealing lynch after calling him townish.
* There's also her claim that she assumed the two vote changes before her llamarble vote had come off Whiskey, even though one of them included the "unvote fishythefish" line and it was the exact post before her.

-----

Is this normal werewolf? Have you seen him before Fate, or are you just getting the vibe that this is all he's going to do this game?

[Fate]

I've never seen him before, but his behavior is very null to me at this point, and frustratingly so.

[werewolf555]

it was a game that I had played with you
I think by using capital letters you are trying to score more pro-town points, appearing eager to catch scum

[Yosarian2]

:twiddles thumbs impatiently:

[Fate]

I could spoil it for ya

[Fate]

Aren't you going to beg?

[Yosarian2]

I got to say, I'm a little fuzzy on why you quoted the normal game whitelist if you were going to claim a role that actually wasn't on there at all.

[Fate]

Claim?

I never claimed anything.

Just quotes and devil-advocate speculation that's all

<3

[Fate]

Happy Valentine's Gambit Yos.

Now tell me, are you going to try and make me believe that you actually have damning role information on Marble, a claimed VT and popular lynch wagon, instead of using your role on a NULL read, one of the many lurkers?

Because I'm not going to buy it.

Now let's compromise on a Darla lynch.

[bobsnox]

It seems like david parker is trying too hard to be town and be "reckless"
Not at all like this game where he was town
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 11&t=15559

I hate you werewolf, all this and thats all you have to fuckin say.

You useless fucking slot.

lolqft