Newbie 1060: It's a Murder Mystery (Game Over)

[mb53]

Anyone remember us having a wagon on Mammut? If so it was pretty lame, I didn't see any L-1.

I believe i was a L-2 vote, but then it disbanded because he stopped posting and the wagon wasn't going anywhere.

And, hi voided.

[Voidedmafia]

Spoiler:

...Hello?

[mb53]

You didn't say anything about me in your last post.

[Equinox]

Vote Count 1.08

Mhi200 (2) - Primate, mb53
snowjorden (1) - GreyICE
Voidedmafia (1) - snowjorden

Not Voting (5) - Zensei, Voidedmafia, Sarg338, Mhi200, Otolia

With 9 alive, it's 5 to lynch.

The deadline is Friday, March 4, 2011, at 11:59 PM EST (UTC-5).

Mod Notes

Seeking a replacement for Zensei...

[Voidedmafia]

Spoiler:

Oh. My apologies.

Spoiler:

mb:

I still believe you missed my point back when we were talking about Zensei, but if I can't persuade you, we'll just have to agree to disagree. All in all, though, I don't see you as scum.

Spoiler tags corrected. (Equinox)

[Voidedmafia]

EBWOP:

Spoiler:

Oh. My apologies.

Spoiler:

mb:

I still believe you missed my point back when we were talking about Zensei, but if I can't persuade you, we'll just have to agree to disagree. All in all, though, I don't see you as scum.

And I don't know how those extra i's got there, too.

[Mhi200]

Why any Mafia compliment a mafia buddy in the thread, and not in the mafia PM?

[Mhi200]

So you guys remember back when I said I had an idea? Yeah, its that mhi is scum (I wanted to see what would happen with snowjorden first though).

Link please?

Too many examples of agreeing with everyone (without making it too obvious)

Perhaps I just don't want to bother repeating other peoples obvious points? I don't have a lot of time to play this game(Almost none at all), except at one time of day (About the time of this post)

I think both voided and snowjordan actually came out of that argument pretty well.

I would agree, but role claims this early aren't very good.

Oh? And what about:

I read this as a compliment to your scumbuddy (since, you know hes not town because hes your buddy or something)

?

Or is that another of those ambiguous-due-to-the-fact-its-the-internet things I hate so much...?

[mb53]

Why any Mafia compliment a mafia buddy in the thread, and not in the mafia PM?

I thought there wasn't any day talk.

So you guys remember back when I said I had an idea? Yeah, its that mhi is scum (I wanted to see what would happen with snowjorden first though).

Link please?

Too many examples of agreeing with everyone (without making it too obvious)

Perhaps I just don't want to bother repeating other peoples obvious points? I don't have a lot of time to play this game(Almost none at all), except at one time of day (About the time of this post)

What does you only being able to come on once a day have to do with anything?

="Mhi"]

I think both voided and snowjordan actually came out of that argument pretty well.

I would agree, but role claims this early aren't very good.

Oh? And what about:

I read this as a compliment to your scumbuddy (since, you know hes not town because hes your buddy or something)

?

Or is that another of those ambiguous-due-to-the-fact-its-the-internet things I hate so much...?

What the hell are you talking about?

[mb53]

EBWOP

Why any Mafia compliment a mafia buddy in the thread, and not in the mafia PM?

I thought there wasn't any day talk.

So you guys remember back when I said I had an idea? Yeah, its that mhi is scum (I wanted to see what would happen with snowjorden first though).

Link please?

Right below here when you followed the obvious easy wagon

Too many examples of agreeing with everyone (without making it too obvious)

Perhaps I just don't want to bother repeating other peoples obvious points? I don't have a lot of time to play this game(Almost none at all), except at one time of day (About the time of this post)

What does you only being able to come on once a day have to do with anything?

I think both voided and snowjordan actually came out of that argument pretty well.

I would agree, but role claims this early aren't very good.

Oh? And what about:

I read this as a compliment to your scumbuddy (since, you know hes not town because hes your buddy or something)

?

Or is that another of those ambiguous-due-to-the-fact-its-the-internet things I hate so much...?

What the hell are you talking about?

[Mhi200]

It doesn't matter if there's day talk, one can wait.

I meant if I don't come on at this time of day, I'll be in a rush, as you can possibly tell from a previous post. Also, I have other things to do during said time of day, and so if I can save time by quoting others instead of rewriting, then why not?

What did you mean/what were you referring to when you said roleclaims this early aren't good?

[mb53]

jorden claimed VT. At like L-3. Claiming isn't really a good thing and narrows down possible power roles for scum to target.

[Mhi200]

I think both voided and snowjordan actually came out of that argument pretty well.

What did you quote this for then? What does it have to do with the VT roleclaim? (Which he stated was a joke anyway...)

[mb53]

I think both voided and snowjordan actually came out of that argument pretty well.

I would agree, but role claims this early aren't very good.

As in, the argument would have been good if it didn't end with a role claim. And where did he say it was a joke?

[Mhi200]

Oh I see what you meant now, Don't worry about that then.

[Mhi200]

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 4#p2797204

[Sarg338]

Busy lately, lots of Test and homework, saw Tommy Tuberville tonight. Going home for the weekend so I'll read over the thread and vote accordingly by Sunday. Promise.

[Otolia]

As promised a general analysis :

Sarg338

He is overall very aggressive in his behavior. Keep it cool buddy !
Claim to know VoidedMafia from another forum (scorehero) and we have yet to see the proof of that.
RVS his buddy VoidedMafia.
Not very active after the RVS.
Didn't vote on anyone after that.

I consider him as being scummy.

VoidedMafia

RVS his buddy
Very active.
Participate in the scumhunt very actively.
A little bit gullible.

Definitely Pro-Town

Mhi200

Arrived late and hopped into the wagon of snowjorden.
FoS Primate
Unvote due to "not being in majority" (sic !)
Try to analyzed after that.

Newbie play of townie ?

GreyICE

Seems in control of the game
Convinced VoidedMafia to get over his initial FoS and attack on him.

I am more inclined to see him scum

Snowjorden

Overall newbie plays of Scum : Lame arguments, poor defense because he claims ...

SCUM - Priority number 1

Primate

IC that don't IC ... I thought there were here to help us giving us what normal players consider normal.

Nothing was given so far.

I wish he could participate more (only 9 post so far) that is almost lurking and he shouldn't do that due to his rule of conduct.

Lynch all lurkers !

mb53

Bad habit of masking the OP in his quote. That isn't pro-town.
Seems in control of the game (SE)

Probably town

Zensei

Not active at all, I hope he can come back soon.

No PoV on him.

[Otolia]

As you can see, I have many suspicions on people. Priority are so far in order Snowjorden, GreyICE, Primate and Sarg.

VOTE: Snowjorden

[Voidedmafia]

As promised a general analysis :

Sarg338

He is overall very aggressive in his behavior. Keep it cool buddy !
Claim to know VoidedMafia from another forum (scorehero) and we have yet to see the proof of that.
RVS his buddy VoidedMafia.
Not very active after the RVS.
Didn't vote on anyone after that.

I consider him as being scummy.

Spoiler:

Well, how do you want to to prove he knwos me? I mean, Parama, Sarg, and I know each from scorehero.com, and if you look over some of our conversations in the newbie queue, you can see that we're talking about an even on that forum (namely Scorehero Mafia, which I believe is a kind of open game).

If anything, just go to http://www.scorehero.com and look up Sarg338 (I think) and Voidedalive2x.

VoidedMafia

RVS his buddy
Very active.
Participate in the scumhunt very actively.
A little bit gullible.

Spoiler:

Spoiler:

HEY! I take offense at being gullible!

[GreyICE]

mb53

Bad habit of masking the OP in his quote. That isn't pro-town.
Seems in control of the game (SE)

Probably town

Do elaborate some here. You listed two things that aren't pro-town, and then said "probably town." I can't help feeling something is missing from your reads.

[Otolia]

Well, how do you want to to prove he knwos me? I mean, Parama, Sarg, and I know each from scorehero.com, and if you look over some of our conversations in the newbie queue, you can see that we're talking about an even on that forum (namely Scorehero Mafia, which I believe is a kind of open game).

If anything, just go to http://www.scorehero.com and look up Sarg338 (I think) and Voidedalive2x.

You are not the one targeted here, I want a proof by Sarg that you know each other from that game. You defend someone that might use your friendship as a cover for scuminess (no offense here). You attitude in this answer is overall counter productive for the town. And btw, I can't find anyone (neither you nor Sarg there)

HEY! I take offense at being gullible!

You are gullible, you accepted the proof of GeryICE far too easily. And though you are being overall Pro-Town, that was not the thing to do. You gave up your clue far too easily. It was D1 so you have to pressure someone hard to get things going.
The game has been going on for long enough, it is time to end day one as soon a Zensei or his replacement comes in. And as stated in my previous post, I think the most easy choice for us is Snowjorden. Thus I recommend you to follow that advice. I can do an ISO if necessary but this day the town has been unproductive so far and I wish we could change that.

[Otolia]

mb53

Bad habit of masking the OP in his quote. That isn't pro-town.
Seems in control of the game (SE)

Probably town

Do elaborate some here. You listed two things that aren't pro-town, and then said "probably town." I can't help feeling something is missing from your reads.

My synthesis work isn't finished, and the one I have been particularly monitoring are Sarg338, VoidedMafia, Snowjorden and Primate. This is why I didn't elaborate that much on you, Zensei, Mhi, and mb. Don't worry that will come.

In the mean time, you could have notice that I also describe you as "being in control of the game" which you didn't feel to answer.

[GreyICE]

My synthesis work isn't finished, and the one I have been particularly monitoring are Sarg338, VoidedMafia, Snowjorden and Primate. This is why I didn't elaborate that much on you, Zensei, Mhi, and mb. Don't worry that will come.

In the mean time, you could have notice that I also describe you as "being in control of the game" which you didn't feel to answer.

I don't really feel the need to answer it. I've made my points and made my suggestions, but at no point do I think I'm really trying to lead the town around by the nose or something.

In any case, I'm just wondering what your thought processes were, because I find your reads very interesting.

[GreyICE]

Also, snowjordan, mhi, what's your reads on the new guy?

He's pretty dead on at least that Zensei and Primate NEED to stop lurking right the hell now.