Newbie 1046: Game Over

[Haylen]

Just to let you know I'm doing a reread. It's not good to have such weak opinions on so many players in the game at this stage

[StefanB]

Nobody Special: The problem is that everyone is waiting for you at the moment, so people are impatient, you already need a long time for 20 pages.

[GLaDOS]

Day Three Vote Count #2

1 No Lynch (Zachrulez)

With

6

alive it takes

4

to lynch. Deadline is March 9, 2011, at 10:00 AM CST.

Not Voting – 5 – Haylen, hurristat, Nobody Special, Nocmen, StefanB

[hurristat]

and it has been eight hours, after NS said two.

*sighs*

I will admit, NS knows how to delay...

[Nobody Special]

Ack! I'm so sorry. Too many things going on IRL. (And I'm easily distracted.)

Reading now, and (probably-huge) wall post coming.

[Nobody Special]

Vote: no lynch

Town:
Stefan
Nocmen

Neutral (ish):
hurristat

Scummish (kinda):
Zach

Scumtastic:
Haylen

Haylen is really,

really

setting off my radar. I've played with her before, and she's just not the Haylen I know and love.

Stefan is very town.

I need to stop replacing into games. I always seem to get into the slots that are the worst-perceived.

@Mod: Some mods have a rule that no-lynch only requires half the living players. Will it take 3 or 4 votes for no lynch?

[StefanB]

Interesting reads, from Nobody Special.
3 strange points.
Nocmen:
From your analysis when you joint the game, you thought the following post had Ghostlin teaching a scumbuddy. We know now this is wrong, but could you make clear why you believe that.
The Post was:

StefanB wrote:
Just to ad somethink that we should take into accont. A lot of people are very quite, to quite to read them. Most people should post more. As alternative to lynch WIR I would sugest to lynch one of the worst lurkers, the problem is who? Lurking through game is a strategie of mafia, but to much townies are using it at the moment too. Form opinions, ask questions do somethink!
Lurkers at the Moment: Chkflip, huristat (the only one I won't lynch, because the problems should be over soon), nikitakit (still waiting on your 3rd post)
Hell: Deer and WIR could be called semilurkers at the moment and I really wait for Haylen to post. (If you subtract the IC posts there isn't that much Haylenplayerpostings) The last one may be me being impatient, she has better reason than some others, but it's frustrating.

Important: IF the DISCUSION between Ghostlin and me is the problem, just ignore it. It isn't at the front at the moment, just start to play.

The Ghostlinpost:

This is acutally a fairly decent post: I don't believe in lynching all lurkers; however inactivity at certain times can be an indicator of scumminess. I'm hoping for more posts from nikita, quite frankly, and more content from huristat.

I wouldn't advocate the bolded seriously, tho'. If it impares your reading now, skip over it, but RETURN to it. Read both of us in iso and what we're really trying to say as the days drag on. Do not discard anything anyone says, and don't afraid to apply pressure when you've got something to latch onto.

Oh, and Ghostlin's number one mafia rule of things that annoy Ghostlin: do not ever argue, 'well, that's stupid, town/scum would never play that way.' First off, there are people who do suboptimal play in all alignments. Some of them do it as a gambit. Two, you can turn this into a case without resorting to 'too stupid to be town/scum.' Three, it's vaguely insulting. I'd rather advocate that people are competent, even if new, then not.

I quoted mine for content also.

Haylen: Somethink doesn't add up. You said that learning if you have scum-Haylen or town-Haylen is easy, so why do you win so often as scum?

My theorotical question isn't so theoretical. Deer(now NobodySpecial) and Chkflip (now Zach) voted each other in RVS. Too obvious or posible distancing?

NS: This time you are definitive not so inocent, that your slot is looked at. The long time you needed for that post hurt that slot. For me thats not enough to go into night, yet.

Nobody Special and Zach voting it is interesting.

[Zachrulez]

Stefan, you think lynching is the optimal play today?

[StefanB]

Nope, but I think ending the day quickly is bad play.

[Zachrulez]

If no lynching is the best play, then there's no point of discussion or info gathering because from this point to the next day phase, the only faction that benefits from it is scum.

[Nobody Special]

Exactly.

[Nocmen]

Stefan, it was the point where Ghost posted about the reading the iso's that seemed like he was guiding someone to find some sort of case. Also, in his ISO, there were a few posts that really seemed like he wanted to get opinions out in addtion to the one you linked.

Why

would

we vote him?

.

As it moved on, I felt better about him D2, but I feel his play was pretty scummy D1, especially with his votes on WIR.

Vote: No Lynch

I'm comfortable with today ending

[Haylen]

Haylen: Somethink doesn't add up. You said that learning if you have scum-Haylen or town-Haylen is easy, so why do you win so often as scum?

To be honest, I haven't got a clue

[Haylen]

Is Zach a player in this game or the mod? If he's a player ask him about my meta, he knows it well enough. I presume it's something to do with being able to talk yourself out of 99% of situations as scum and barely any as town.

[Nobody Special]

HOW CAN YOU NOT KNOW WHO YOUR FELLOW PLAYERS ARE?

[Haylen]

I'm currently ICing two games. Zachs modding one and playing in another. And my memory is shit.

[Haylen]

And I get confused very easily; I called my partner by my name yesterday. Twice.

[hurristat]

Now that NS has posted content, I have no qualms doing this:

Vote: No Lynch

(L-1)

[GLaDOS]

Day Three Vote Count #3

4 No Lynch (Zachrulez, Nobody Special, Nocmen, hurristat)

With

6

alive it takes

4

to lynch. Deadline is March 9, 2011, at 10:00 AM CST.

Not Voting – 2 – Haylen, StefanB

[GLaDOS]

No Lynch

It is now

Night Three

. Deadline for night choices is February 26 at 12:30 AM CST.

Mod Note

: I require a full majority for No Lynching.

[GLaDOS]

StefanB, Townie, has been killed!

It is now

Day Four

. With

5

alive it takes

3

to lynch. Deadline is March 20 at 2:30 PM CST.

[hurristat]

Okay, it's now lylo. I'm thinking mass claim, and get the reports from the cop? What do you guys think?

[Nobody Special]

I agree with Massclaim.

[StefanB]

/bah GO TOWN

[Nocmen]

I'm okay with a Mass Claim as well.