Cold War Mafia - GAME OVER!!

[The Fonz]

OK, could someone fill me in on the current issues, summaries of the cases behind the leading wagons etc? I don't want to be essentially inactive for what will probably be close to a week before I get caught up entirely.

[bvoigt]

OK, I figured it was time to stop being lazy.

Town

Beasts of the Sea- I wish he would post more often, because they're good when he does.
Feysal- He provides good questioning and analysis.
DavidParker- He used the wording of his role PM to clear TheAd.
LynchMePls- See the reasons for Feysal.
ThAdmiral- See DP. Of course, I'd have to rethink if one of the two flipped scum.
Lowell- While he doesn't have a lot of content, he has made a few good posts, such as ISO #13.
XScorpion- His tunneling on Amrun doesn't look something scum would do.
Amrun- Between the claim and the reaction to my "hammer," I just don't think she's that likely to be scum anymore.
bvoigt- I know my play has been halfhearted lately, but I'm going to improve.
The Fonz- I like his catchup post so far.

Not Sure

InflatablePie
EGL
Artem- I was leaning town, but his replace-out post is weird.
Furcolow- Ugh.
Scott Brosius

Scum

smargaret- She goes after a lot of the easy candidates. For example, ISO #8 is a very nitpicky point, and ISO #13 basically just goes after a lurker because everyone else is. ISO #45 is also a nitpicky way to push what turned out to be a mislynch.
gonnano- Expect a good case in an upcoming post.
Stephoscope- It feels like he's skating by on the outskirts of the game, and not really doing much scumhunting of his own.
Nachomomma8- My head tells me that he actually appeared more pro-town in Outdoorsmen Mafia 2, where he (as Calcifer) was scum. But my gut says he's scum in this game, too.
Sathrois- Like Steph, he's been skating by, although his play has improved lately. I also don't like his Furc vote in ISO #24; while self-voting is not good play, it's not a scumtell.

[XScorpion]

None of the stuff XScorpion votes over is actually scummy.

Furc was caught lying
FURC WAS LYING
WHY IS HE STILL ALIVE
WTF PEOPLE

[InflatablePie]

XScorp: I have my own reason that I cannot disclose.

Still perfectly fine with a DP lynch though.

[Sathoris]

None of the stuff XScorpion votes over is actually scummy.

Furc was caught lying
FURC WAS LYING
WHY IS HE STILL ALIVE
WTF PEOPLE

I share this sentiment.

Also I'm dissapointed in bvoigt. How can you have DP on your town list and find Artem's replacement vote more in the area of unsure than DP's entire gameplay. And I think I've explained my timely vote on Furc under the self voting quote.

[Stephoscope]

Stephoscope- It feels like he's skating by on the outskirts of the game, and not really doing much scumhunting of his own.

I'm not going to claim that I've been able to be one of the more useful players so far, but please explain why your statement apparently puts me into your "scum" category.

[bvoigt]

Also I'm dissapointed in bvoigt. How can you have DP on your town list and find Artem's replacement vote more in the area of unsure than DP's entire gameplay. And I think I've explained my timely vote on Furc under the self voting quote.

Once someone towntells, I'm inclined to stick with it (and as to why I voted him earlier, I guess I just kind of forgot about it). And yeah, I know you've explained your vote on Furc, but I still don't like it.

Stephoscope- It feels like he's skating by on the outskirts of the game, and not really doing much scumhunting of his own.

I'm not going to claim that I've been able to be one of the more useful players so far, but please explain why your statement apparently puts me into your "scum" category.

Well, posting a low amount of content is an easy way for scum to avoid suspicion. I don't have a problem with posting infrequently, but when combined with your relatively short posts....

[Furcolow]

None of the stuff XScorpion votes over is actually scummy.

Furc was caught lying
FURC WAS LYING
WHY IS HE STILL ALIVE
WTF PEOPLE

this post is so good
you aren't trolling or anything

[Furcolow]

http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 29&start=0
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 54&start=0
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... &start=250
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=51&t=15265

possibly more, but theres 4

[Stephoscope]

Well, posting a low amount of content is an easy way for scum to avoid suspicion. I don't have a problem with posting infrequently, but when combined with your relatively short posts....

(WIFOM ALERT) If I were scum I'd be posting a lot more. I'm more interested in the right lynches than making myself look good. Furcolow is the right lynch for today, for reasons that have very clearly been defined, and I just want to see his lynch as opposed to sitting around. My gut feel is that many of the scum have been exposed and that they're milking this time to plant as many seeds of doubt as they can.

[XScorpion]

this post is so good
you aren't trolling or anything

Omfg that's exactly what I think whenever I read anything you post! How did you know?

[Furcolow]

You thought that when I was linking my scum meta?
I really need to get into a better game. This game has gone to shit, and I'm just a townie, why did CallMeLiam ask me to play then flake?

[XScorpion]

First you're a bulletproof
then something else
then a doctor
now a townie
can you just be dead? seriously.

[Furcolow]

want me to link a game where i made those exact claims in the exact same sequence as town? lol

[Furcolow]

if i bother you so much, you know, you could replace out and troll somewhere else

[InflatablePie]

Good idea, furc.

Sorry, Sotty, but

I request replacement

. I've lost interest in this game; it's not your fault as mod, though.

Before I go, I might as well give my reads:
1 Beasts of the Sea - town
4 EGL - null
5 (pappums rat) Feysal - null
6 DavidParker - scum
7 LynchMePls - town
8 ThAdmiral - null/town
9 Artem - town
10 Furcolow - town
11 Lowell - null/town
12 XScorpion - null/scum
13 smargaret - null/scum
14 Scott Brosius - null/town
16 (PoisonIvy) Amrum - null/scum
17 gonnano - scum
18 bvoigt - null/town
19 Stephoscope - null
21 nachomma8 - null
22 (jmj3000) (mothrax) The Fonz - town
24 Sathrois - null/town

[Furcolow]

Good. I disagree with your Fonz read, though it doesn't matter now!
I say good because I feel you aren't that good at scumhunting.

[ThAdmiral]

I normally wouldn't ask like this but 4 people in an 11 player game I am hosting just dropped out/were deactivated for cheating.

Would anyone be willing to replace in? here's a link

[Furcolow]

to clarify the above, as I just read the game:
3 dropped our for cheating, causing 1 to ask for replacement.
Still, a bad situation. However, I do not believe this is the time, nor the place!

[ThAdmiral]

It's not. Soz. But some very excellent people (you included) have filled the slots so you won't hear another word about it!

[Sathoris]

You thought that when I was linking my scum meta?
I really need to get into a better game. This game has gone to shit, and I'm just a townie, why did CallMeLiam ask me to play then flake?

And now it's just a townie..

People please vote this guy, it's getting ridiculous he's still alive now.

[Sotty7]

Day 2, vote count 11

DavidParker - 6 -

LynchMePls, InflatablePie, Lowell, EGL, Beasts of the Sea, Nachomamma8

Furcolow - 4 -

Scott Brosius, XScorpion, Stephoscope, Sathoris

gonnano - 1 -

Amrun

Amrun -2 -

gonnano, Furcolow

smargaret - 2 -

Artem, ThAdmiral

Stephoscope - 1 -

smargaret

Nachomamma8 - 1 -

bvoigt

Not voting - 3 -

The Fonz, Feysal, DavidParker

With

20

alive, it takes

11

to lynch.

Deadline for the end of day two is Tuesday 23rd March @11am CST

Looking for replacements for

Artem

and

InflatablePie

EGL

has been prodded.

[ThAdmiral]

Sad to see artem go. His posts were concise and logical. IP was also on my more-likely-town-than-scum list.

A lot of people are saying they think smarg is scum but no one is voting for her.
C'mon guys lets give the smargwagon a try - it's got a good chance of being pushed through to an actual lynch (unlike so many other wagons in this game so far), and has a very good chance of hitting scum. It's a win-win!

[ThAdmiral]

OK, could someone fill me in on the current issues, summaries of the cases behind the leading wagons etc? I don't want to be essentially inactive for what will probably be close to a week before I get caught up entirely.

Furc wagon - he keeps lying about shit basically
Dp wagon - Furc was about to be lynched and lmp pointed this out:

Furc, you suck. You had this lynch coming. Stop your all caps/rage as if it's town's fault/mistake (if you are town), it's your own bloody fault for this mess.

"Yes you're a mislynch, and I recognize that, but it's your own fault, so you can't complain."

DP is scum.

Unvote
Vote: DP

People should seriously switch here. DP is obviously scum. I mean seriously, look at the language here. "you had this lynch coming". Wow.

Smarg wagon - ok this isn't really a wagon per se, but it could/should be!
The reason for it is in two parts Part One: where I look at the bunny wagon that lead to his lynch because of a slip-that-wasn't-actually-a-slip, and Part Two: where I iso smarg and decide that out of the potential scum candidates she is the best bet.

[LimMePls]

Town

Beasts of the Sea- I wish he would post more often, because they're good when he does.
Feysal- He provides good questioning and analysis.
DavidParker- He used the wording of his role PM to clear TheAd.
LynchMePls- See the reasons for Feysal.
ThAdmiral- See DP. Of course, I'd have to rethink if one of the two flipped scum.
Lowell- While he doesn't have a lot of content, he has made a few good posts, such as ISO #13.
XScorpion- His tunneling on Amrun doesn't look something scum would do.
Amrun- Between the claim and the reaction to my "hammer," I just don't think she's that likely to be scum anymore.
bvoigt- I know my play has been halfhearted lately, but I'm going to improve.
The Fonz- I like his catchup post so far.

I have so many problems with this town list. For one, how on EARTH does DP's claimed "wording of his role PM to clear ThAd" make him town? Even more bizarre is how does it make ThAd town!? XScorpion tunneling on Amrun doesn't look like something scum would do. I think my head just exploded. OF COURSE SCUM WOULD DO THAT IF THEY ARE PUSHING A MISLYNCH/CHAINSAWING FOR A BUDDY! WHY WOULDN'T SCUM TUNNEL AMRUN!?!?!?!? MAKES ABSOLUTELY 0 SENSE!

Plus I hate hate Hate HATE putting yourself on your town list. With a passion.

This game is so full of fail it's starting to feel like a chore. Are you guys competing for scummiest player of the year awards or something?