New Designer Mafia (Victor(s) are crowned)

[populartajo]

DemonHybrid, whats wrong with having FoSes and Votes in the same post?
Also if IS thinks both Xalxe and Coug are scum, whats wrong on him restating his Xalxe suspicion?

I feel as if the xalxe suspicion has been a constant backup. He sort of rides along on his SC vote while making a stronger case against Xalxe, yet not voting for him. I don't find it authentic; somethings off.
And yes, a majority of cases where FoSes and votes happen in the same post, it's bad news. That's for mafia discussion and not here though. It's certainly not the basis of my argument, as IS did it all bandwagon.

You are missing the point. If IS thinks both Coug and Xalxe are scum, then its not bad to vote for one and restate his suspicion on the other. Having a stronger case is irrelevant in the context of a wagon with a lot of momentum.
Also, link me to those cases where FoSes and votes in the same post mean bad news.

[Amrun]

I'm not feeling the DemonHybrid wagon either. I won't be joining it unless something changes.

[Olinea]

Olinea(1) - Tasky

is this votecount correct?



UNVOTE: ,VOTE: DemonHybrid

I PM'ed the mods about this and they haven't exactly gotten back to me. Keep your vote on me, I'd like to see if it was mod error or the work of a Roleblocker or something.

[Nocmen]

what dont you like about my case, Nocmen?

I see where your case is working, but no case makes sense when DH is town

[WhenInRome]

I'm not feeling the DemonHybrid wagon either. I won't be joining it unless something changes.

[populartajo]

WIR, why the hell did you target me yesterday?

[CooLDoG]

Hi. I've read through the entire thread, but I'm still formulating my thoughts.

Immediately, though:

I'm not assuming ender is town. Why would a town want us to lynch a town member instead of continuing to scumhunt? Implies explicit knowledge that Olinea is town.

But, again, why would mafia do that? Maybe he's a mafia bomb or something like that.

Or maybe he's a jester.


Or just a bad player. Who knows.

I don't know about Furc.

On the one hand, he's scummy.

On the other, he's ALWAYS scummy, regardless of alignment.

What I mean is I think he's fitting his town meta so far. Trying to keep an eye on the situation, though.

What do you mean?

I think they're all saying the exact same thing, just clarifying each other.

I see scumtells in his play. (Everyone should.) I ALWAYS see scumtells in his play.

I have a hell of a time reading him.

Right now, I think he's playing more like his town meta, but in reality there's very little difference between the two.

So, I can't get a read on him yet. My read on him is essentially null.

Everyone should watch their null reads carefully, so that's what I plan to do.


How does that not make sense?

Oh, and, I'd be more willing to lynch him than someone I have a strong town read, but I'd rather go for someone I have a scum read on.

I'm not going to lynch someone who always plays like a VI OVER someone who is giving me scumtells I trust, but I WILL lynch someone who is always a VI over someone I think is town.

In the meantime, I'm going to keep an eye on him to see if I can pick something out of the mire that is useful either way.

I hope that makes sense, at least.

And also, running through your iso every single goddamn post you make is about jesters. Would you mind to stop talking about them?

[DemonHybrid]

DemonHybrid, whats wrong with having FoSes and Votes in the same post?
Also if IS thinks both Xalxe and Coug are scum, whats wrong on him restating his Xalxe suspicion?

I feel as if the xalxe suspicion has been a constant backup. He sort of rides along on his SC vote while making a stronger case against Xalxe, yet not voting for him. I don't find it authentic; somethings off.
And yes, a majority of cases where FoSes and votes happen in the same post, it's bad news. That's for mafia discussion and not here though. It's certainly not the basis of my argument, as IS did it all bandwagon.

You are missing the point. If IS thinks both Coug and Xalxe are scum, then its not bad to vote for one and restate his suspicion on the other. Having a stronger case is irrelevant in the context of a wagon with a lot of momentum.
Also, link me to those cases where FoSes and votes in the same post mean bad news.

You are missing mine. He states much more for a case for Xalxe, and instead if voting him or convincing people of his scumminess, he gives a weak reason for hopping on the SC wagon but keeps his Xalxe suspicion running. In that context, I find it scummy. Xalxe, no matter the alignment, is an easy lynch, and I think that if IS was genuine on how much he suspects xalxe, he wouldnhave left SC alone. I don't find it genuine.

In my current state, I cant link you anything. Regardless, I can't li k you meta. I've been in one position where someone did that and they were scum. I've only ever seen it done that one time. I'm talking common sense scum tell though. Would you agree that FoSing someone and voting them at the same time, while scum, makes it a lot easier to have an out? If so, would you then agree that it's appealing?

[Internet Stranger]

You dont see me switching to DeathNote now, do you?

[Fashion Llama]

Vote Count

Xalxe(7) - Internet Stranger, DeathNote, fishythefish, Nocmen, Sevei, CooLDoG, chesskid3
DeathNote(4) - Amrun, WhenInRome, Xalxe, ThAdmiral
Demonhybrid(1) - populartajo
Tasky(1) - Olinea
Internet Stranger(2) - DemonHybrid, Tasky

Not Voting(3) - Zajnet, brokenscraps, zoraster

With 18 alive it takes 10 to lynch
Deadline for day three is Friday March 25th, 8PM PST

[ThAdmiral]

I normally wouldn't ask like this but 4 people in an 11 player game I am hosting just dropped out/were deactivated for cheating.

Would anyone be willing to replace in? here's a link

[Fashion Llama]

~Votecounts in #755 and #785 are corrected to fix mod errors

brokenscraps and Zajnet have been prodded

[WhenInRome]

WIR, why the hell did you target me yesterday?

I don't know. I didn't have anything important to talk about, so I picked randomly. Same thing with day 1.

[chesskid3]

i'm probably going to try to kill amrun tonight
idk
I'm so fucking busy

[ThAdmiral]

Some very fine people have filled the slots in my game. Thank you to them, and to everyone else you won't hear another word about it!

Back to the scumhunt...

[ThAdmiral]

I don't like how you tested the waters with the Xalxe FoS, especially in a theatrical way, then switched to SC when Nocmen pushed you around. Tajo just happened to convince me and push me over the edge whereas you felt like restating your suspicion for Xalxe first. I dont feel comfortable with it.

This is a bad case imo. It's reaching and it doesn't hold up when you consider IS had been after xalxe since forever.

If you had to choose out of deathnote and xalxe who would you choose?

[CooLDoG]

Seeing that they we aren't close to deadline, I would like to

[b/]

unvote, vote: Amrun[/b]. I meant to do it last night, long story if you really want to hear it.

I just don't like how every single post she makes is about jesters or to defend a confirmed scum.

[CooLDoG]

damn you bold tags,

unvote, vote: Amrun

[populartajo]

WIR, why the hell did you target me yesterday?

I don't know. I didn't have anything important to talk about, so I picked randomly. Same thing with day 1.

do you realize that what you did is extremely scummy?

To all, WIR's ability targetted me yesterday. Ill let him explain what that ability did and why it is scummy as hell.

[Xalxe]

Oh, hey, I'm going to try and catch up tonight, but before I go back to work, WIR targetted me night before last. And I don't see it as scummy.

[Internet Stranger]

Does he assrape you at night or something? What's his deal?

[Xalxe]

Does he assrape you at night or something? What's his deal?

Quite the opposite.

[populartajo]

He told me he targetted you night 1. Didnt he tell you what his ability did?

[Xalxe]

He told me he targetted you night 1. Didnt he tell you what his ability did?

Unless he has an additional one, no, but I'll let him claim.

[chesskid3]

Unvote

Vote: Amrun

I glanced over this thread
I like this vote
Cooldog likes this vote too
lets do this