New Designer Mafia (Victor(s) are crowned)

[populartajo]

are you like restricted to vote for whomever cooldog does?

[chesskid3]

No but it's funny
and he's fully read this thread
and I haven't
and we're fucking alingment confirmed lovers
so i think i'm going to trust him
problem?

[DeathNote]

The problem is blindly following someone who could have a wrong read. Being confirmed town does not mean that he can pick the scummy people out right off.

[chesskid3]

I haven't read the whole thread, so he's bound to do a better job than me

[populartajo]

you dont need to read the whole thread and you know it. I hope you are proud of being confirmed trusting awesome scumhunter cooldog.

[chesskid3]

it's also midterm week
when's the deadline?

[chesskid3]

i.e. i'll try to get caught on up Thurs/Fri/Sat if it's not for awhile
otherwise if we survive the night i'll be caught up then

[Internet Stranger]

Youre seriously going to tell me that CK and Cooldog dont find Xalxe scummy at all? Or Deathnote? But prefer to start a fight with someone new instead?

[Xalxe]

IS, I think you meant "You're seriously going to tell me that CooLDoG is being taken seriously?"

Because that's sure as hell what I'm thinking right now.

[DemonHybrid]

I don't like how you tested the waters with the Xalxe FoS, especially in a theatrical way, then switched to SC when Nocmen pushed you around. Tajo just happened to convince me and push me over the edge whereas you felt like restating your suspicion for Xalxe first. I dont feel comfortable with it.

This is a bad case imo. It's reaching and it doesn't hold up when you consider IS had been after xalxe since forever.

If you had to choose out of deathnote and xalxe who would you choose?

If I HAD to choose? Probably DN, since I'm running mostly a meta case on him.

Also, I'm not talking about IS's Xalxe suspicion being scummy. It's the fact that he went along the SC wagon and pushed it while talking bloody murder for Xalxe, something isn't right about that.

His case on SC: he's scum, tajo and olinea made a good point.
His case on Xalxe: *five paragraphs long regarding Xalxes scum tells and why he is scum*

He only FoSes Xalxe, in fact, twice in the same post. It's a little strange.

[Xalxe]

Oh, if I thought a lyncher role was likely, IS would be my lyncher fo'sho. As it is, this blatant tunneling is annoying and anti-town.

[populartajo]

what dont you like about my case, Nocmen?

I see where your case is working, but no case makes sense when DH is town

tell me why should I trust you

[Amrun]

CoolDog, show me where I have supposedly defended ANYONE -- and more than one person, since you said "that's all I do" -- so I can show you how ridiculously wrong you are.

[ThAdmiral]

Also, I'm not talking about IS's Xalxe suspicion being scummy. It's the fact that he went along the SC wagon and pushed it while talking bloody murder for Xalxe, something isn't right about that.

His case on SC: he's scum, tajo and olinea made a good point.
His case on Xalxe: *five paragraphs long regarding Xalxes scum tells and why he is scum*

He only FoSes Xalxe, in fact, twice in the same post. It's a little strange.

True, it is a little strange. But I don't think that is enough to be wanting his lynch especially when there are, imo, much juicer lynch targets.

[ThAdmiral]

Also @ cooldog: seriously, deathnote or xalxe? I would be much happier having two confirmed town votes influencing the lynch rather than being on a random. You should take your double-voting power more seriously.

[Nocmen]

what dont you like about my case, Nocmen?

I see where your case is working, but no case makes sense when DH is town

tell me why should I trust you

Because in this post:

I dont even want to understand what has happened with all the revival and the 1955 snipping.

Furcolow....
....oh right, now I remember you. You're a VI.

When hunting for possible scumpartners, DemonHybrid came up as second suspect.
Other reasons include voting using weak reasoning and backtracking on his read on me to support a lynch on a townie.

DemonHybrid's Question: Who is scum?

tajo and IS I'd say.

tajo makes the most valid point of all. He's really have gotten better as of late.

Vote: Strangercoug

and killing Plum.

Unvote Vote: Demonhybrid.

Every assumption you've made is wrong.

[populartajo]

1. Using the VI defense to avoid voting for confirmed scum.

2. Backtracking his scum read on me to support a lynch on a confirmed townie.

3. Demonhybrid was one of top Plum suspects.

4. Constant apologizing.

Where is the wrong in my assiumptions?

[populartajo]

I might add the weak case on InternetStrange that its tl;dr is something like he fosed and voted in the same post.

[Nocmen]

1. Using the VI defense to avoid voting for confirmed scum.

2. Backtracking his scum read on me to support a lynch on a confirmed townie.

3. Demonhybrid was one of top Plum suspects.

4. Constant apologizing.

Where is the wrong in my assiumptions?

1 and 2: How is anyone "confirmed" when they were still alive?

3. Because this means that he must have killed Plum....

4. I agree with the AtE, but that was in a different post of yours.

[populartajo]

1 and 2: the idea is that they are confirmed now, which means that at that time, DemonHybridscum defended Furcolowscum with the VI defense and that DemonHybridscum backtracked his scum read on me to support a lynch on StrangerCoug who now wek now is town.

3. no it doesnt but scum kill problematic townies all the time.

4. so?

[Fishythefish]

This game needs more from more people.

DH calling Furc a VI does fit well with him being Furc's partner. Plum kill is interesting - she was known to be a spent loveriser, so I'm guessing whoever killed her is fairly likely to have been a suspect. Xalxe fits well here. Did Plum suspect DH? Can't find it. I don't see the backtrack on tajo and vote for SC as particularly scummy.

[Zajnet]

Sorry I haven't been posting. My life has been annoyingly strange lately... anyways... This game is falling apart imo, nobody seems to be able to agree on anything, and you'd think that the fact that we have two confirmed townies would help, but just our luck one of them is a VI. I have no solid reads other than the fact that I still think that Xalxe is scum, which is really strange in a game this big. Maybe I'm just not putting enough effort into this game, or maybe scum are being really good at hiding, I don't know. Expect more out of me next week since its spring break.

[DemonHybrid]

This game needs more from more people.

DH calling Furc a VI does fit well with him being Furc's partner. Plum kill is interesting - she was known to be a spent loveriser, so I'm guessing whoever killed her is fairly likely to have been a suspect. Xalxe fits well here. Did Plum suspect DH? Can't find it. I don't see the backtrack on tajo and vote for SC as particularly scummy.

Plum didn't fully suspect me, but in her video, she noted that she thought something was up and had questions for me, which I answered and she didnt respond to.

[Xalxe]

Sorry I haven't been posting. My life has been annoyingly strange lately... anyways... This game is falling apart imo, nobody seems to be able to agree on anything, and you'd think that the fact that we have two confirmed townies would help, but just our luck one of them is a VI. I have no solid reads other than the fact that I still think that Xalxe is scum, which is really strange in a game this big. Maybe I'm just not putting enough effort into this game, or maybe scum are being really good at hiding, I don't know. Expect more out of me next week since its spring break.

One of them? I'd classify them both under the VI category.

[Amrun]

Xalxe's lack of content truly frustrates me.

Active lurking at its finest.