Mini 1135: Deadmines - DONE. PRAISE AZEROTH.

[xRECKONERx]

Hey Kai, can you spot the misrep in the third post?

[Kairyuu]

Man, I've missed Kairyuu.

Though I do think you're taking the "obv scum" thing Bub said a bit too seriously.

Probably. If you've got anything better to go off of while I wait for smargaret to dig his hole a bit deeper, feel free to share. Voting dana for lack of content at this point doesn't really count though.

[Kairyuu]

Hey Kai, can you spot the misrep in the third post?

Missed this at first. I assume you're talking about the three posts you quoted. dana is dana. I'd like to hear some actual content from him before I make any judgement calls. I would not be adverse to moving him up or down my list depending on what I hear, but Bub is a better place for my vote at least for now.

[Parama]

I'll lynch either DKU or Bub today. Whichever wagons grows bigger.

[inHimshallibe]

Official Day 2 Vote Tally

11 players remain; 6 votes needed for a lynch.

Bubbiddrskns (1)

- Kairyuu

Danakillsu (1)

- Xreckonerx

Yet to vote (9): Parama, Antihero, Danakillsu, Endertwofour, Starbuck, Maemuki, Bubbiddrskns, Smargaret, Sathoris

[danakillsu]

I'll lynch either DKU or Bub today. Whichever wagons grows bigger.

Haha, what? The case on both of us is pretty much non-contribution. In a grand total of...less than 10 pages. Great idea, tell everyone that one of us is all you're going to lynch today.

[smargaret]

Kairyuu - It's more or less moot now since I don't think you're scum (I got a one-shot tracker last night), but you pretty much explained why your post struck me as off. I was trying to pressure you and cut off some of those options I saw you leaving open. In general I prefer to see reasons spelled out so we can come back to them later if necessary, but I do recognize there are times when it's better to vote and shut up. I didn't see this as one of those situations.

dana - the case on Bub is more than just non-contribution. He's either skimming or rolefishing, based on his popcorn to Sathoris. I'm not sure how I feel about the massclaim restarting either; it was a gambit and it's served its purpose, I don't see any need to reveal any more information.

VOTE: Bub

[Parama]

vote: Bub

wagon go

[Starbuck]

danakillsu

Well, I'm here, and the only unfortunate thing about yesterday is that it was so short, we practically have to start over. Catching scum D1, though, is awesome.

Some type of content from you would be superb.

Surprisingly solid reads from such a short Day 1. Scum lynch helps.

Yes. I agree. SURPRISINGLY solid reads. I'm not so convinced we should be lynching Bub immediately.

Again....CONTENT per favore, por favor and please.

Bub

Okay, restarting the popcorn claim.

Claim: Draenei Shaman

Sathoris, you claim next.

Why would you pick Sathoris when there's a claim on him being town?

Unless you are trying to rolefish.

What makes you think that Sathoris is town?

This post right here...

I got a one-shot cop last night, and Sathoris isn't a Defias.
Don't have it anymore so it's worth claiming.
Not confirmed sane but whatever.

Starbuck is that a list of impossible combos?

Sathoris

Well I don't mind claiming now. I sort of acted the way I did for a reason which I will explain when I'll claim. When's up to you guys if you want.

I think you are good for now and there are others who need to claim before you.


Does anyone have a list of who has and hasn't claimed?

[danakillsu]

Okay, here's some content for you. Bub has posted 5 times. His first two are in the RVS, and one of them is him claiming and asking someone else to claim (which I don't really have a problem with). His other two are pretty much one-liners. Am I missing something here? Because that looks like nothing to me, not pure scumminess.

[Starbuck]

Pot kettle black, sir.

[xRECKONERx]

...why are people voting Bub over dana?

Seriously.

PS, smarg got a one-shot track, Parama got a one-shot cop, both on the same night, and both cleared a townie?

HMMMMMMMMMMMM

[Starbuck]

In general I prefer to see reasons spelled out so we can come back to them later if necessary, but I do recognize there are times when it's better to vote and shut up.

See reasons spelled out?

Come on, you're playing MAFIA.

M-A-F-I-A.

[xRECKONERx]

Hey Starbz, tell me you're town this game so I can just ignore you.

[Starbuck]

I'm town, Reckz.

Dana can definitely just be trying to float along, but seriously, it's not like he replaced into a large theme with 30 people on Day 4. He has to read what? 7 pages? I'm also intrigued by dana trying to splash more suspicion onto Bub when he's guilty of the exact same thing. Although, Bub's complete lack of reading as to how we got the Sathoris semi-town read has thrown me off.

I think I missed that smargaret post when I was doing my catch up as well. Smargaret has one thing going for her that the others don't and that's being on Enigma's lynch, but that can also be null. Her quick jump onto the Bub wagon bothers me as well as her almost deliberate suggestion of suspicion of Mae yesterday (when she asked Mae why she wasn't voting for Enigma when Mae was the first to do so).

I'm more inclined to believe that Parama got a one shot cop than smargaret got a one shot track.

Vote: smargaret

[Antihero]

/facepalm @ last post

[xRECKONERx]

I'm more inclined to believe that Parama got a one shot cop than smargaret got a one shot track.

Why?

[ender241]

VOTE: Parama don't like the rushed voting.

[Parama]

I see no reason not to believe we're both telling the truth.

ender, please request replacement. I'm serious. You obvious have no clue what's going on in-thread and probably don't have any clue how to play mafia, so please request replacement in all your ongoing games and leave the site. Thanks ^.^

[Starbuck]

I'm more inclined to believe that Parama got a one shot cop than smargaret got a one shot track.

Why?

It feels like smargaret just pulled it out of thin air. I already have a bad feeling about her from yesterday. I also have a town read on Parama.


I could be completely off too and maybe they did both have night abilities.

[Parama]

Hmm. If anyone else got a one-shot to use last night, they should probably claim it. NOW.

[smargaret]

1. Why would scum clear two townies?
2. I can reveal the results of my track, but I'll leave that up to Kairyuu.

Starbuck, as far as the reasons thing, I want to see them spelled out for reference later so if you vote Person A for lurking and then don't vote Person B in similar circumstances for lurking and Person B flips scum, we can draw a connection between you and Person B. You know, because we're playing mafia.

[Maemuki]

I personally don't think we should lynch any of the people who claimed their 1-shot abilities. At least, not now.

The problem with D1 was that we got nearly no other information aside from Enigma. I'm personally not very fond of dana, but I'm willing to let him post some content first.

[xRECKONERx]

@smargaret: Why did you track Kairyuu?

Hmm. If anyone else got a one-shot to use last night, they should probably claim it. NOW.

Also, this.

I'll accept Parama's cop result under the condition he doesn't flip scum. Of course, if he & Sathoris are scum together, then they obviously pulled this gambit in an attempt to allow them to survive to endgame given the fact that their buddy got lynched D1. However, that's quite a stretch, and I think Parama would be smarter than that.

@Starbuck: What bothers me is that you seem to just immediately believe the one-shot cop claim over the one-shot tracker claim, whereas I saw no difference in HOW they both claimed. There very well be a role out there that can give out two abilities per night, or there may be a mechanic (like a loot/drop system when a scum dies?) that automatically "rolls" for one-shot abilities. /speculation

In either case, I don't like how Starbuck arbitrarily distinguished between one claim and the other with no real reason to do so. Still liking my vote on dana, though, because he has yet to do anything to assuage my suspicions/disdain for his posts.

[Kairyuu]

@smargaret: Claim your result please. I'd like to hear that before I make any more comments.