Catching Up Now:
FD vs. YFC is still odd. I’m still leaning town on FD, and his case about YFC buddying the crap out of Pathetric is decent, at least.
BW’s
323 further expands on this, and is goodposting. (except for his calling Pathetric’s “some noob” comment at the beginning of the game scummy; that was clearly a joke.)
To (finally) answer Daspot’s question about what we like about their
208: it is concise, well put-together, and well-reasoned. Shows solid scumhunting. *thumbsup*
YFC’s continued insistence that Pathetric is obvtown is becoming really frustrating. It should be apparent that nobody else thinks so. (However, the fact that YFC does lean so strongly to YFC being obv-town leads me to think that YFC may have been helping direct the NK)
BW’s 347 is baaaaaaaaaad. Whooooo boy. “Hey, we think that last post was super-scummy, but does anyone wanna explain why ELSE he’s scummy so we can parrot that? THX.”
Ooh! And followed up by this gem in
351:
BW wrote: So, asking someone to present a consise, neat case that doesn't require me to read through 13 pages of bullshit again is scummy? Ok then.
Course not, BW. Why would we expect a player to read through the game? Silly us.
DAY 2 BEGINNETH
Balam’s
360 is alright. The last point they make (about UB’s change of heart on US) is worth mentioning: They had earlier expressed suspicion of US. Why ask about what "changed?"
LF’s official hydra-entrance (
361 is a good post, mostly because we agree with basically everything they said.
Fez's immediate response to that post is nonsensical. Surely ONE of the heads would have realized how disastrous it would be for scum-UB to have that rule in place. Additionally, he talks about a specific towntell committed by FD, and then votes for FD.
FD’s 370 sounds good to me. Solid reasoning, especially in the second half of the post.
WHOOOO. Fez's
372 made me go look at FD’s ISO. Guess what? The last time they mention a read on Fez was saying how they THOUGHT HE MIGHT BE TOWN. (Granted, this is in the case of scumYFC, but still.) I don’t like that change in thought process, FD. –townpoints for you.
FUTURE EDIT: This is addressed by FD in
379. Your explanation makes sense, but apparent change of heart is still a mild concern.
Fez: if bad =/= scummy in that post, what did bad mean? This seems like you reaching back and finding a way to avoid contradicting yourself.
The end of
379 is a good point. If Fez was planning on writing a good-sized post, why didn’t he do it at nighttime?
Welcome to the game, Copper. Your post is good. We have nothing in particular to comment on from it, mostly because we don't really disagree with anything from it.
UB is essentially our Village Idiot. I’m finding it difficult to pay attention to anything he says, since there’s essentially nothing to it.
YFC, we STILL haven’t gotten a satisfactory explanation from you as to why Pathetric was obvtown, despite your insistence that you’ve explained it. If you want to point out where you’ve made it clear why they were obvtown, it would be excellent. However, I don’t see it.
Scumreads (in order): BW, Fez, YFC
Town: FD, Grey, UB
