Scummies 2011 Nominations

[Ythan]

Lol Charlie. Sorry he didn't side with you.

[Mr. Flay]

Shut. Up.

Both of you.

[GreyICE]

Nominate: Olinea for Best Flavor Text

For Open: 288
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... lect=14371

Totally deserves it. I know a lot of Mini Themes get it, but he took an Open, and made it really, really work from a flavor perspective. Well, as much as a hospital with two vigilantes, a serial killer, and a mafia squad can work. Excellent, excellent writing job.

[Scummies]

Updated as of 227

[Klazam]

Nominate: Olinea for Best Flavor Text

For Open: 288
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.ph ... lect=14371

Totally deserves it. I know a lot of Mini Themes get it, but he took an Open, and made it really, really work from a flavor perspective. Well, as much as a hospital with two vigilantes, a serial killer, and a mafia squad can work. Excellent, excellent writing job.

I second this nom.

[Xalxe]

MASTERMIND

WHY DID YOU NOM DGSII?

BLACKBERRY DID NOT FINISH IT

[brokenscraps]

To be fair, I had 2 scum pinned early into D1, and they killed me for it.

Regardless, I'mma

2nd that

3rd

[MagnaofIllusion]

Nominate

Lady Lambdadelta

for

Most Outstanding New Player.

Her play as a replacement in Brotherhood of the Wolf was outstanding. I've read some of her other games and she has shown good instincts and ability as any alignment. She also has an impressive record for someone new to the site (although as recognition of her skills grow I expect she's going to start dying more frequently early )

[Xalxe]

Nominate

Lady Lambdadelta

for

Most Outstanding New Player.

Her play as a replacement in Brotherhood of the Wolf was outstanding. I've read some of her other games and she has shown good instincts and ability as any alignment. She also has an impressive record for someone new to the site (although as recognition of her skills grow I expect she's going to start dying more frequently early )

Second

[CSL]

Nominate

Lady Lambdadelta

for

Most Outstanding New Player.

Her play as a replacement in Brotherhood of the Wolf was outstanding. I've read some of her other games and she has shown good instincts and ability as any alignment. She also has an impressive record for someone new to the site (although as recognition of her skills grow I expect she's going to start dying more frequently early )

Second

===[] time!

Third

[GreyICE]

Nthed

[Mr. Flay]

Is Lambda actually a new player? I always thought she was an alt *shrug*

[Haylen]

She is. It's probably because of the influx of Umineko accounts.

[UncertainKitten]

Double Nth'd on the Lady LambdaDelta nom

I think she is an alt, but I had never seen her old account in a game before so...

EDIT: My memory was apparently incorrect. I thought I saw a thing saying she WAS at some point, but I can't find what I remember so...

[Equinox]

I believe I saw her state somewhere that she isn't an alt. (EDIT: Here in her first game, she states it's her first game.) I wholeheartedly support the nomination.

[GreyICE]

Why does everyone around here think that anyone who is remotely competent is an alt?

[Mr. Flay]

Because we HAVE a lot of alts on this site. And usually it takes a while to 'get used to' the way we play Mafia here; when somebody catches right on, it usually means they either read up before playing, or they're an alt. I'll let you guess which actually happens more often...

Also, hardly anybody joins the site to play Mish-Mash, Large Themes, and Guys Part 2, in that order.

[GreyICE]

Oh.

You guys aren't that different from MTGS. A little better, on average, and less dumb setups that make me cry, but overall wasn't a huge dose of cold water. Of course I've only been there a few months, and scum there are dumber on average. They just have less resources for 'catching scum' and thus less resources for the scum to learn from

Also it's cliquish as hell and the moderators are known to do things like occasionally give their friends the cool PRs or the faction they want, so when that was acceptable, well, that was the end of

that

for me.

[UncertainKitten]

Also, hardly anybody joins the site to

play

Mish-Mash, Large Themes, and

Guys Part 2

, in that order.

I was unaware that was a game, well, outside the large theme, but this reads like the thread itself.

[Faraday]

Oh.

You guys aren't that different from MTGS. A little better, on average, and less dumb setups that make me cry, but overall wasn't a huge dose of cold water. Of course I've only been there a few months, and scum there are dumber on average. They just have less resources for 'catching scum' and thus less resources for the scum to learn from

Also it's cliquish as hell and the moderators are known to do things like occasionally give their friends the cool PRs or the faction they want, so when that was acceptable, well, that was the end of

that

for me.

Axelrod's cool.

[Haylen]

The account is an alt, but I'm pretty sure no games were played under the old account.

[The Fonz]

Oh.

You guys aren't that different from MTGS. A little better, on average, and less dumb setups that make me cry, but overall wasn't a huge dose of cold water. Of course I've only been there a few months, and scum there are dumber on average. They just have less resources for 'catching scum' and thus less resources for the scum to learn from

Also it's cliquish as hell and the moderators are known to do things like occasionally give their friends the cool PRs or the faction they want, so when that was acceptable, well, that was the end of

that

for me.

I've read a fair few MTGS games. They seem to be the closest other style to ours. The main difference seems to be slightly greater amounts of power over there, and the natural emphasis on players knowing each others' psychology that comes from having a much smaller community.

[animorpherv1]

Also, hardly anybody joins the site to

play

Mish-Mash, Large Themes, and

Guys Part 2

, in that order.

I was unaware that was a game, well, outside the large theme, but this reads like the thread itself.

Guys Pt 2 isn't the game, Reck is .

[gandalf5166]

Also, hardly anybody joins the site to

play

Mish-Mash, Large Themes, and

Guys Part 2

, in that order.

I was unaware that was a game, well, outside the large theme, but this reads like the thread itself.

Guys Pt 2 isn't the game, Reck is .

And DAMN is that game easy.

Disclaimer: I do not actually believe this. The setup was just too. perfect. Don't hurt me Reck. Please?

[ReaperCharlie]

Because we HAVE a lot of alts on this site. And usually it takes a while to 'get used to' the way we play Mafia here; when somebody catches right on, it usually means they either read up before playing, or they're an alt. I'll let you guess which actually happens more often...

Also, hardly anybody joins the site to play Mish-Mash, Large Themes, and Guys Part 2, in that order.

I find myself agreeing with this. It strikes me as odd. :X