Execution Mafia GAMEOVER!

[Setael]

Ok I looked it up and it did. Alright then, I'll let it go. If you're scum, the mod's a bastard.

[Twistedspoon]

so are we having another vote then?

[Setael]

Vote: Tragedy

[Exe]

Why didn't you use it D2?

Because I wasn't going to use it until I felt it was necessary. Day 2 seemed like it would be productive, and also once I was going to be elected anyways, it would've been a total waste.

[Amrun]

Vote: Exe

[charter]

Scummy stuff about Seteal, just from the top of 48.

Defends Exe today.
His flip on Amrun under the assumption scum are telling the truth about who they vote at night.
His plan to elect him if Ant shoots town (knowing that Ant is town unless the scumteam has two people). This really looks like a desperate plea to try and win since it makes about a million times more sense to elect Ant again tonight.

[Setael]

First, we can't elect ant tonight because we need his 2 votes. Second, most of that is pure lies (or you're just not reading). The fact that amrun is very likely town based on N1 votes has nothing to do with assuming scum is truthful about night voted. On the contrary, we very much took into account that at least some of them definitely lied. I'd still prefer me to be the night executioner since I'm the only one I know is town. You're grasping at straws. I would kill Tragedy if she isn't the day kill and TS or charter if she is, regardless of the flip. I would also be willing to vote Haschel as he is my strongest town read, but prefer myself as I could be wrong about him.

Also, once again, I am a she.

[Amrun]

HC, who would you kill at night, if you were to be given night executioner?

[Haschel Cedricson]

HC, who would you kill at night, if you were to be given night executioner?

Unless we collectively decide to no-kill, probably Exe.

Charter: I was expecting more from your case on Setael. While I disagree with Setael on Exe, her flip on Amrun feels genuine. I mean, there's a possibility I'm wrong, but I don't think so, and I'd hardly say your case shows that Setael is "clearly scum".

[Amrun]

Well, then, I'll be voting for HC at night, I think, unless something drastically changes today.

[Tragedy]

Well, then, I'll be voting for HC at night, I think, unless something drastically changes today.

Maybe scum knew that TS and I were scapegoats.

[Ant_to_the_max]

TS, can you link me to three games were you were scum?

After rereading D2 again, I think I have one solid town read now.

[Twistedspoon]

TS, can you link me to three games were you were scum?

I would If I could

But I've only been here 3 months and I've completed no games as scum, just as town

my wiki page has all of my games on it

[Twistedspoon]

oh, and I'm cool with the haschel night-voting plan

[Tragedy]

I'm not cool with the automatic haschel night-voting plan, though.

[Ant_to_the_max]

Ah!. On my phone right now in class and it said you had 80 topics so I thought you would have been in a lot more. I notice a lot are in the non-mafia section. Back with more thoughts later

[Amrun]

Tragedy: about the HC nightkill plan, I simply trust him most to do what town collectively decides (since we can't use Ant at night, or I would say let's make him night executioner). Also I have a townread on him so far, which helps.

[Ant_to_the_max]

Part of my lightbulb.
I thought it over and Exe is not scum. Wouldn't make to much sense if they had a day vig and a night killer, which I am about 90% sure that they do.

Think about it. We didn't see an extra kill from N1 because we have a doc and they guessed right the first night.
N2 scum killed FF because they knew about the doc and guessed he would protect me. If I am correct here, when the doc claims, they can confirm one more townie, unless I was the save N1. No, I don't think they should out themselves yet imo.

As far as things are fanning out. TS and Charter are my top two scum picks now

[Amrun]

...What?

Ant, what?



I'm pretty sure the mechanic is explained in the OP which means no scum night kills. Correct me if I'm wrong. I've seen zero evidence pointing to a scum nightkill. Why would scum get two votes at night if they could kill whenever they wanted? It just doesn't make sense.

I do agree that if scum has nightkills, Exe isn't scum, but I don't think scum has nightkills.

[Ant_to_the_max]

Because with 3 scum, they really can't "control" the night votes till a lot of townies are down. And I am suggesting that it is a role and not a collective power.

Reasoning is me trying to figure out why we had a nurse. A nurse implies a doc (of course it could be there just to throw things off) but if the scum doesn't don't have a night kill, why do we need a doc?

O.O

[Tragedy]

I'm pretty sure having a doctor's obvious. I doubt mallowgeno is a bastard moderator, since we have a confirmed-dead Nurse.

[Ant_to_the_max]

So you are agreeing with my theory?

[Tragedy]

Having a doctor claim after more than half of the town dead?
Pretty knowledgable that a doctor claiming right now is pretty screwed tonight.
A slight change or thought, but did Amrun or Haschel claim anything?

[Ant_to_the_max]

Post #1517

Nothing there is suggesting they should claim. It is about the scum having a killing PR and Exe being town...

-__-;

[Setael]

I think it more likely scum has a 1-shot NK.

However, just in case Ant is correct, in order to still have a confirmed townie if our doc is NK'd, everyone should post the following sentence (with the doc's being accurate).

If I were the doc, N1 I would have protected Exe.

(Obviously no one say Vezok since that will rule you out.)