Execution Mafia GAMEOVER!

[Twistedspoon]

I agree with Setael being Night executioner

[Ant_to_the_max]

I just also want it on the record that post 1560 bothers me.
if Amrun is scum and Tragedy is town, that switch wins the game. I'm just going to continue to write it off as paranoia though

[Twistedspoon]

I want charter and haschel to post
do they not realise it's potential lylo ¬_¬

if Amrun is scum and Tragedy is town, that switch wins the game.

how does it?

[Ant_to_the_max]

Assuming mafia night killing PR

[Twistedspoon]

:/

I don't know what to think of that theory
Why would they have chosen to use it only on day 2, if we are to believe exe that he chose to kill no-one

but yes, I'll admit that we could lose if we mislynch today. Not for certain, but it's certainly possible.

[Ant_to_the_max]

Remember the Doc (assuming there is one >___>) could have saved someone

Which I am 99.99% sure I know how it went down

[Tragedy]

I would sooo rather we switch that plan, Ant.

My scumread on TS is relative to my scumread on Exe, so seeing if Exe will execute TS will be really helpful in me determining Exe's alignment.

Tragedy today, TS tomorrow sounds like a good plan to me.

I don't understand how TS = Scumread on Exe
This is confusing, why would you go for another person instead of your 'scumread' thoughts? Fishy Fishy.
You're fine with choosing anyone since you're too focused to Exe & TS?

[Haschel Cedricson]

I'm okay giving the NK to Setael.

I don't think charter is scum, though. My preference order is Exe, Tragedy, and TS.

But yeah, I understand the plan and will be voting for Setael.

[Tragedy]

I'm okay giving the NK to Setael.

I don't think charter is scum, though. My preference order is Exe, Tragedy, and TS.

But yeah, I understand the plan and will be voting for Setael.

Why not charter? Do YOU have any proof, other than he pops up sometimes or such?
...What was the plan after voting Setael again..? Oh right, he's going to execute one of us..
Uhh.

[Amrun]

Tragedy, none of that was new information. If both TS and Exe are scum, I see his gambit D1 as a way of trying to clear a scummy player (esp. If he could have just shot and killed, which he claimed). If Exe is scum, TS is. If he's not, then I'm back at townish TS, personally.

I have a separate scumread on you, as you should know, Tragedy. Exe is my strongest scumread. It's not my fault no one will support that. I can't execute him by myself.

[Tragedy]

I'm pretty sure you had the chance to execute Exe.
Instead you went for VEZOK who was more 'scummier'. Cool.

[Amrun]

I had a townread on Exe at that time.

Things changed after FF died when he was executioner.

That should be obvious.

[Haschel Cedricson]

I've been scumbuddies with charter in a lot of prior games, and I know how he plays when he's scum. This is not one of those times.

[Amrun]

Tragedy is getting executed today, right, ant?

[Tragedy]

Tragedy is getting executed today, right, ant?

So, if you're pretty concerned of TS, why not execute him first? >_>
You're being pretty stupid here and you're going to screw town over.
A request to execute Amrun, please.

[Twistedspoon]

how abouts we vote?

[Tragedy]

VOTE: Amrun

[Amrun]

How can you not read?

I'm concerned about Exe first. You second. TS third. Charter fourth.

I've made that abundantly clear. I think TS is scum with Exe only because of associative tells. Therefore if Exe turns out not to be scum, TS will drop off of my scumreads. For this reason, I prefer Ex executed first, but since that can't happen, I prefer you executed, Tragedy.

P-edit: vote for what?

[Tragedy]

Why does Exe need to live?

His vigkill wasn't even real.

Your argument seems to be that it didn't prove he was scum, so he should live.

Proving people are scum is pretty damn difficult. If that vigkill had been real and TS flipped town, I would have gone after Exe next, no questions.

No townie really ends the day that early on a whim in this set up.

Twisted: Newb town. I liked his reaction to the vigkill gambit and the major point against him is the supposed rolefishing and I 100% disagree. I don't see it as rolefishing at all. Has said some fishy things, so is closer to null, I guess. Right now I'm attributing it to newb-ness but IGMEOY.

@the rest of this mess: I smell monkey business. I'll need to see a flip out of the Exe/charter/Umbrage group to really figure it out, though.

Uh huh.. Explanations how TS -> Newb Town -> Scum again?

[Ant_to_the_max]

I think making TS and charter claim now might be a good idea. Tragedy already claimed VT so she is covered.

[Amrun]

How do you not get that reads change throughout the game? At that time, I was working off the assumption of Exe as town. Now, working off the assumption of Exe as scum, that looks different in hindsight. TS' reaction WAS townish to me, which is why I don't want him killed unless Exe flips scum.

However, if TS were to flip scum if he was killed first, that would doubly re-affirm my convictions on Exe scum, but the risk isn't ideal imho.

P-edit: directed to Tragedy

[charter]

I'm not claiming now. I can live with voting Seteal tonight...

[Tragedy]

I'm not claiming now. I can live with voting Seteal tonight...

...

[Amrun]

Charter, what? Lol

[Ant_to_the_max]

Ok charter, at least for now, TS or Tragedy?